1306 Beach Ave Abrorist Letter
Tree Assessment Report
Inventoried April 9th, 2025
Prepared For: Cam Greene
1306 Beach Ave
Atlantic Beach FL, 32233
Prepared By: David Martin
Certified Arborist #FL-9959A
ArborStar Tree Care Solutions
4930 Spring Park Road
Jacksonville, FL 32207
904-200-3121
ArborStarjax@gmail.com
Notice of Disclaimer
Assessment data provided by ArborStar Tree Care Solutions is based on visual recording at the time of inspection.
Visual records do not include testing or analysis and do not include aerial or subterranean inspection unless
indicated. ArborStar Tree Care Solutions is not responsible for discovery or identification of hidden or otherwise
non-observable risks. Records may not remain accurate after inspection due to variable deterioration of surveyed
material. Risk ratings are based on observable defects and mitigation recommendations do not reduce potential
liability to the owner. ArborStar Tree Care Solutions provides no warranty with respect to the fitness of the trees for
any use or purpose whatsoever.
1
Contents
Summary 3
Introduction 4
Observations 4
Methods 4
Purpose 5
Limits of the Assignment 5
Tree Location, Data and Photos 6 through 7
Conclusion 8
2
Summary
On April 7, 2025, David Martin, an ISA-certified arborist (FL-9959A), conducted a
comprehensive Level 2 Tree Assessment at a property located on Beach Avenue in Atlantic
Beach, FL. Commissioned by homeowner Cam Greene, the evaluation focused on assessing
the health and risk associated with a Cabbage Palm on the premises.
During the assessment, a dead palm tree was identified. In alignment with the ISA Best
Management Practices (BMP) and the Arborists' Code of Ethics, it is recommended that the tree
be removed to alleviate potential hazards and improve the overall aesthetic of the surrounding
landscape. Based on the ISA BMP guidelines, removal is considered the most effective
mitigation strategy. Furthermore, this action qualifies for permit exemption in accordance with
Florida Statute 163.045. Detailed findings and supporting data are available in the following
report:
3
Introduction
During the assessment of the Cabbage Palm, thorough visual observations were
conducted, considering both the tree itself and its surrounding environment. Detailed
measurements were recorded, allowing for a comprehensive evaluation of the tree's overall
condition and risk level.
Observations
● The soil is composed mostly of sand and loam.
● The property has adequate drainage with no signs of water pooling.
● The tree has no signs of active photosynthesis
● The tree in question is dead.
● The tree has significant signs of decay in the root flare
● The tree has a slight phototrophic lean towards the corner of the house.
● The cause of death is believed to be attributed to severe damage from piercing insects,
specifically Bronzing Leaf Hoppers, which have led to the onset of Lethal Bronzing
Disease in the tree.
● Signs of piercing insect damage in additional trees, yearly arborist inspection is
recommended.
Methods
Species: Tree genus and species were identified.
Diameter at Breast Height (DBH): Trunk diameter was recorded to the nearest inch at 4.5 feet
(breast height) above grade, not exceeding 30 feet not to exceed +/- 1.5”.
Height: Approximate tree height was visually estimated with a variance not to exceed +/- 10’..
Crown Spread: Approximate crown diameter was visually estimated with a variance not to
exceed +/- 10’.
Condition: The arborist evaluated the structure and health of the tree compared to other trees
in surrounding landscapes. Excellent, good, fair, poor, or dead were used to describe conditions.
Risk Level: The arborist evaluated the structure and health of the tree and documented any
defects. Low, moderate, high or critical were used to describe conditions. Note on empty lots,
risk level was determined based on the proposed site and building plan.
Targets: All structures and items within 1.5 times the radius of the tree that could potentially
sustain damage or pose a risk to life in the event of catastrophic tree failure.
Objective: The client articulated their aspirations and concerns regarding the tree's condition
and future.
4
Recommendations: Tailored recommendations were provided in alignment with the client's
objectives and in accordance with industry Best Management Practices for arboriculture.
Geolocation: Approximate locations were determined by adding points to geolocated aerial
tiles. Locations provided by the land surveyor are more accurate, and should be used for design
purposes.
Purpose
The purpose of this report is to provide an assessment of the tree in question and determine
their risk level as well as mitigation options to help reduce risk to an acceptable level.
Limits of the Assignment
Many factors can limit specific and accurate data when performing evaluations of trees, their
conditions, and values. The determinations and recommendations presented here are based on
current data and conditions that existed at the time of the evaluation and cannot be a predictor
of the ultimate outcomes for the trees. A visual inspection was used to develop the findings,
conclusions, and recommendations found in this report. No physical inspection of any canopy,
sounding, root crown excavation, and resistograph or other technologies were used in the
evaluation of the trees.
5
Tree Location, Data and Photos
6
006
Tree Number: 006 (red on map)
Species: Palm
Diameter at Breast Height: 11”
Approximate Height: 22
Estimated Spread: 8 feet
Health: Dead
Risk Level: Greater than moderate
Targets: House, fence, pedestrian traffic, plantings.
Objective: To reduce risk to an acceptable level for the tree owner and to improve aesthetics of
the property.
Recommendations: Removal
Photos:
7
Conclusion
In conclusion, the assessment conducted on April 7, 2025, reveals that the Cabbage
Palm located at the property of Cam Greene is in a state of irreversible decline, classified as
dead. Significant decay has been observed at the root flare, and symptoms indicative of Lethal
Bronzing Disease, likely caused by piercing insects, have been identified. With the health of the
tree severely compromised, it presents a risk rating greater than moderate, posing potential
hazards to nearby structures, pedestrian traffic, and other landscaping elements.
Based on the findings, it is strongly recommended that the dead palm tree be removed
to mitigate safety risks and enhance the overall aesthetics of the property. This removal not only
aligns with the ISA Best Management Practices but also qualifies for permit exemption under
Florida Statute 163.045.
Additionally, given the identification of piercing insect damage in other surrounding trees,
a yearly arborist inspection is recommended to monitor and manage any further risks
associated with the tree health and overall landscape integrity. Regular maintenance and
monitoring will help ensure the safety and beauty of the property moving forward..
8
9