1514 Park Terrace West TREE23-0022 07.14.2023 NOIPERMIT #: TREE23-0022
ADDRESS:1514 Park Terrace West
APPLICANT:Dustin Brown
PHONE:904 813 3661
EMAIL:dustin@mathieubuilders.com
CATEGORY DBH 8" - 13.9"# OF TREES INCHES OWED DBH 14" - 29.9"# OF TREES INCHES OWED DBH 30"+# OF TREES INCHES OWED TOTAL INCHES
REMOVED
PRESERVATION
CREDIT TOTAL OWED
OAK 36" before reduction 29.2
Live Oak 18 1 36 and/or
Preserving 22" & 24"4,380.00$
live oak = 40" reduction
MARITIME SPECIES 86" before reduction 69.6
Elm 22 1 44 and/or
Hickory 21 1 42 10,440.00$
Magnolia 13.5 1 20.25
PALM 88" before reduction 71.2
Sabal 14 1 28 and/or
15 2 60 10,680.00$
OTHER
and/or
-$
118.5 170
and/or
25,500.00$
CATEGORY INCHES # OF TREES STAFF NOTES PROPOSED- PLANT PROPOSED- PAY CATEGORY INCHES # OF TREES STAFF NOTES FINAL- PLANT FINAL- PAY
OAK 25"4.2"OAK
Live oak 5 5
MARITIME SPECIES 69.6"MARITIME SPECIES
PALM 70"1.2"PALM
Cabbage Palm 10 7
OTHER OTHER
TOTALS 90"80" ($12,000.00)
TREES REMOVED
PROPOSED MITIGATION FINAL MITIGATION
DBH 30"+ = 1: 3
NEW CONSTRUCTION
MITIGATION RATIOS: (inches removed : inches replaced)
DBH 10" -13.9"= 1: 1.5
DBH 14" - 29.9" = 1: 2
Status in accordance with the City of Altantic Beach code of ordinances in effect at the time of application submittal.
APPROVDED
DENIED
TPO ADMINISTRATOR DATE
ADDITIONALINFORMATION:
•The current tree fund rate is $150.00 per inch.
•One shade tree shall be planted or preserved within the required front yard of every lot.
PLANTING REQUIRMENTS
•Oaks must be replaced with oaks and have a 4" caliper and 12' tall at time of planting.
•Maritime Species must be replaced with Maritime Species.
•Mininum 2" caliper for non oaks and 10' tall at time of planting.
•Palms may replace plams.Mininum 8ft clear trunk height at time of planting.
X 5/22/23
DESCRIPTION ACCOUNT QTY PAID
PermitTRAK $12,000.00
TREE23-0022 Address: 1514 W PARK TER APN: 171938 0000 $12,000.00
TREE MITIGATION $12,000.00
TREE MITIGATION 112-0000-329-1050 0 $12,000.00
TOTAL FEES PAID BY RECEIPT: R23395 $12,000.00
Printed: Friday, July 7, 2023 10:54 AM
Date Paid: Friday, May 26, 2023
Paid By: COLLIER JENNIFER J ET AL
Pay Method: CHECK 9111
1 of 1
Cashier: NP
Cash Register Receipt
City of Atlantic Beach
Receipt Number
R23395
Arborist Solutions, LLC
Gene Washington
Certified Arborist
FL-5623A
904-610-1130
April 20, 2023
Mathieu Builders Inc
Dustin Brown
38 W 9th St
Atlantic Beach FL 32233
904-813-3661
Dear Mr. Brown,
Using your existing tree survey, I visited 1514 Park Terrace E Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 to
evaluate the health and condition of each protected tree on the property.
There are a total of 15 protected trees on the property. 11 of those trees appear healthy with a
total of 189 inches DBH and will require mitigation if removed.
I also found and condemned 4 trees with total of 87 inches DBH. These trees should not require
mitigation if removed.
Tree A. 16” DBH Elm – Extreme Decline – Dead Top – Failing Root System
Tree B. 18” DBH Magnolia – Massive Cavity from Ground to 4 ft – Hazardous
Tree C. 29” Laurel Oak – Cavity at Base – Hollow Under Root Flare – Hazardous
Tree D. 24” DBH Live Oak – Extreme Decline - >50% Dead Major Dead Limbs – Hazardous
These 4 trees pose an unacceptable risk. Removal of all 4 trees is the only means of practically
mitigating the risk below moderate.
This onsite assessment was performed in accordance with the tree risk assessment procedures outlined in
Best Management Practices - Tree Risk Assessment, Second Edition (2017) by an arborist certified by the
International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) or a Florida licensed landscape architect and signed by the
certified arborist or licensed landscape architect.
In addition to this letter, I have submitted a property diagram and a tree table with tree details and
problems found.
If you have any questions, please call me at 904-610-1130.
Sincerely,
Gene Washington
Certified Arborist
FL-5623A
ISA Tree Risk Assessment Qualification
Arborist Solutions Tree Table - Dustin Brown - 1514 Park Terrace E
Tree #
Diameter
Breast
Height
Common
Name Comments / Notes
Protected Trees Condemned
A 16 Elm Extreme Decline - Dead/Dying Top - Tip Dieback - Hazardous/Dangerous
B 18 Magnolia Extreme Decline - Massive Cavity from Ground to 4 ft - Dead Top - Hazardous/Dangerous
C 29 Laurel Oak
Extreme Decline - Large Cavity @ 8 ft - Hollow Under Root Flare - Dead/Dying Top -
Hazardous/Dangerous
D 24 Live Oak
Extreme Decline - >50% Dead - Major Dead Limbs - Dead/Dying Top -
Hazardous/Dangerous
Total 87 inches
Protected Trees Appear Healthy
1 15 Sabal Palm Appears Healthy
2 22 Elm Appears Healthy
3 15 Sabal Palm Appears Healthy
4 8 Elm Appears Healthy
5 24 Live Oak Appears Healthy
6 18 Sabal Palm Appears Healthy
7 12 Sabal Palm Appears Healthy
8 18 Live Oak Appears Healthy
9 22 Live Oak Appears Healthy
10 21 Hickory Appears Healthy
11 14 Sabal Palm Appears Healthy
Total 189 inches
Gene Washington 904-610-1130 Certified Arborist - FL-5623A April 7, 2023