Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC) - 08 Nov 2023 - Agenda - Pdf
City of Atlantic Beach
Agenda
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
Meeting
Wednesday, November 8, 2023 - 6:00 p.m.
Commission Chamber
City Hall, 800 Seminole Road
Page(s)
1.CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
2.APPROVAL OF AGENDA
3.COURTESY OF THE FLOOR (5 MINS.)
4.CONSENT AGENDA
4.A.Approval of the October 11th minutes3 - 7
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC) - 11 Oct 2023 - Minutes - Pdf
4.B.Outreach Subcommittee Report9 - 12
ESC Outreach Subcommittee Nov 8 report
4.C.Tree Subcommittee Report13
Tree Subcommittee minutes 10.14.23
4.D.Sustainability and Resiliency Subcommittee Report15 - 16
Sustainability Resilience Subcommittee Agenda and Minutes October 26 2023 2
5.90 DAY CALENDAR
2023 Working Calendar November
5.A.17 - 48
6.CHAIR REMARKS
6.A.City of Jacksonville Resiliency Plan
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1j21eOUZoeX_hafPlkn1OdQZ1vY5QsALm/view
6.B.City of Atlantic Beach Parks Master Plan
6.C.ESC member recruitment
7.SIGNIFICANT MATTERS ARISING IN SUBCOMMITTEES
7.A.Outreach Subcommittee
7.B.Tree Subcommittee
Page 1 of 55
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC) - 08 Nov 2023
7.C.Sustainability and Resiliency Subcommittee
8.MAYOR AND/OR STAFF REPORTS
8.A.Status of Chapter 23 updates
8.B.Q4 tree report
9.OLD BUSINESS
9.A.Beach Avenue Property
10.NEW BUSINESS
10.A.Schedule of a Specials ESC meeting to discuss:49 - 55
Updates to organization
ESC 2024 priorities
ESC budget
Initial 2024 ESC Priorities Draft
budget
11.MEMBERS CLOSING REMARKS
12.ADJOURNMENT
Any person wishing to speak to the Environmental Stewardship Committee on any matter at
this meeting should submit a Comment Card located at the entrance to Commission Chamber
prior to the start of the meeting.
This meeting will be live-streamed and videotaped. To access live or recorded videos, click on
the Meeting Videos tab on the city's home page at www.coab.us.
In accordance with the American with Disabilities Act and Section 286.26 of the Florida
Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodations to participate in this
meeting should contact City Clerk Donna Bartle at 247-5809 or at City Hall, 800 Seminole
Road, Atlantic Beach, Florida not less than three (3) days prior to the date of this meeting.
Page 2 of 55
Agenda Item #4.A.
08 Nov 2023
MINUTES
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
Meeting
Wednesday, October 11, 2023 - 6:00 PM
Commission Chamber
Present:Anastasia Houston, At Large Member
Amy Palmer, At Large Member
Mark Gabrynowicz, Chair
Heather Markaj, At Large Member
Daniele Giovannucci, Vice Chair
Romy Vann, At Large Member
Barbie Brooksher, District 1312 Member
Sarah Boren, District 1306 Member
Bruce Andrews, District 1308 Member
Absent:Linda Chipperfield, At Large Member
Patrick Nobles, At Large Member
Also Present:Amanda Askew, Director of Planning and Community Development
Candace Kelly, City Commissioner, Seat 4
1.CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
Mark Gabrynowicz called the meeting to order. Anastasia Houston called the roll.
2.APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Sarah Boren asked to move item 11D after item 6 and to move item 7 after item 11. There was
no dissent to the change.
3.COURTESY OF THE FLOOR (5 MINS.)
There were no speakers.
4.CONSENT AGENDA
A.Approval of the September 14th minutes
B.Outreach Subcommittee Minutes
C.Tree Subcommittee Minutes
D.Sustainability and Resiliency Subcommittee
Mark Gabrynowicz asked if there was any discussion about the consent agenda. He
stated that since there was no discussion the consent agenda was approved. A motion
and vote was not recorded.
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
October 11, 2023
Page 1 of 5
Page 3 of 55
Agenda Item #4.A.
08 Nov 2023
5.90 DAY CALENDAR
A.Review of 90 Calendar
Sarah Boren reviewed Amy Palmer's suggestion of having one event a quarter. She said
the committee should start planning for 2024. Discussion about events ensued. Sarah
Boren asked if members would like to do an "ESC Meet and Greet" in December.
Members were in support of the event but did not want to push for it to happen in 2023.
6.CHAIR REMARKS
A.Public Works, Public Utilities Capital Improvement Plan
Mark Gabrynowicz said he included the Capital Improvements Plan (CIP) for committee
members to review.
B.Parks Master Plan
http://www.coab.us/854/Parks-Master-Plan-Project-Page'
Mark Gabrynowicz announced there is an upcoming Town Hall meeting for the public
to provide input on the Parks Master Plan. Discussion about parks and the Dora Street
property ensued.
C.Member recruitment
Mark Gabrynowicz stated there are Board Member Review Committee meetings coming
up where upcoming vacancies may be filled. He said there are no candidates at this time.
11.NEW BUSINESS
D.Recap from special ESC regarding Charter Review
Sarah Boren reviewed the special called meeting do discus a motion about adding
language to the Charter about environmental stewardship. She said members decided the
most logical place for the statement is under Article 1 and in a new Section 5 called
"Environmental Leadership" and should state:
"In order to ensure the health and safety of its citizens, and enhance property values,
high quality of life, and healthy environment, the City of Atlantic Beach shall continually
improve its leadership and preparation for sustainability, resilience, environmental
stewardship, and protection of tree canopy".
MOTION: to recommend to the Charter Review Committee to add Article 1 Section 5,
"Environmental Leadership", which states:
"To ensure the health and safety of its citizens, and enhance property values, high quality of life,
and healthy environment, the City of Atlantic Beach shall continually improve its leadership and
preparation for sustainability, resilience, environmental stewardship, and protection of tree
canopy".
Motion: Sarah Boren
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
October 11, 2023
Page 2 of 5
Page 4 of 55
Agenda Item #4.A.
08 Nov 2023
Second: Anastasia Houston
Anastasia Houston (Seconded By)For
Amy PalmerFor
Mark GabrynowiczFor
Heather MarkajFor
Daniele GiovannucciFor
Romy VannFor
Barbie BrooksherFor
Sarah Boren (Moved By)For
Bruce AndrewsFor
Motion passed 9 to 0.
8.MAYOR AND/OR STAFF REPORT
A.Request environmental recommendation regarding fires on the beach
Amanda Askew reviewed permitting for fires on the beach and the problems the city has
with the debris and cleanup. She asked for a recommendation from ESC on how to make
the regulations more enforceable and environmentally friendly. Discussion about
enforcement and environmental impacts ensued.
MOTION: Recognizing the social benefits of allowing seasonal beach bonfires, we also note that there are
negative environmental consequences primarily due to the detritus left behind from bonfires eg. cinders,
inappropriate and dangerous items that have been burned, screws, nails, trash, and particulate matter and thus if the
city continues to allow beach bonfires that this aspect should be addressed in order to protect this special privilege.
Motion: Daniele Giovannucci
Second: Romy Vann
Anastasia HoustonFor
Amy PalmerFor
Mark GabrynowiczFor
Heather MarkajFor
Daniele Giovannucci (Moved By)For
Romy Vann (Seconded By)For
Barbie BrooksherFor
Sarah BorenFor
Bruce AndrewsFor
Motion passed 9 to 0.
B.ESC budget
Amanda Askew reviewed the ESC budget.
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
October 11, 2023
Page 3 of 5
Page 5 of 55
Agenda Item #4.A.
08 Nov 2023
C.PlanIt Geo
https://cem.pg-cloud.com/atlanticbeachfl/#canopy-map=12/30.35208/-81.44424
Amanda Askew showed members the Tree Canopy Assessment database. Members
discussed the PlanIt Geo database and partnering with the local municipalities to access
the database.
9.REPORTS
10.OLD BUSINESS
A.Chemical Management Plan (CMP)
Mark Gabrynowicz deferred the item to the Sustainability and Resiliency Subcommittee
for further action.
B.Proposed Chapter 23 changes
Mark Gabrynowicz went through his draft of proposed changes to Chapter 23. Members
discussed the change to section 23-14 to allow city funded trees to be planted in rear
yards, Section 23-24 to increase the required tree protection zone, and Section 23-52 to
remove language about the inaugural committee terms and revising the geographical
requirement. Discussion about changes and enforceability ensued.
Bruce Andrews stated he wants to also add the change requiring trees planted as
mitigation to be protected no matter the caliper size.
Sarah Boren expressed she is not in support of revising the geographical requirement.
She said this is a large committee and there should be at least one person from each
district. Discussion about having a seat for each district ensued.
Mark Gabrynowicz stated he would like to add an annual review of Chapter 23 to the 90
day calendar.
MOTION: to approve the changes to Section 23-14 and Section 23-24 as written, to approve
the changes to Section 23-52 regarding inaugural committee terms, and add language "any tree
planted as mitigation
under section 23-33 shall be considered a regulated tree under Section 23-8 and not be
subject to minimum caliper size of 8 inches".
Motion: Bruce Andrews
Second: Amy Palmer
Anastasia HoustonFor
Amy Palmer (Seconded By)For
Mark GabrynowiczFor
Heather MarkajFor
Daniele GiovannucciFor
Romy VannFor
Barbie BrooksherFor
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
October 11, 2023
Page 4 of 5
Page 6 of 55
Agenda Item #4.A.
08 Nov 2023
Sarah BorenFor
Bruce Andrews (Moved By)For
Motion passed 9 to 0.
11.NEW BUSINESS
A.Florida Communities Trust Parks and Open Space Grant
https://floridadep.gov/parks/ogt/content/grants
B.Review of ESC member 2024 priorities survey
Mark Gabrynowicz asked members to think about the priorities.
C.
7.SIGNIFICANT MATTERS ARISING IN SUBCOMMITTEES
A.Sustainability and Resiliency
B.Outreach
C.Tree
D.Charter Review
This item was not discussed.
12.MEMBERS' CLOSING REMARKS
A.Amy Palmer Remarks
Amy Palmer brought up the idea of regulating tree removal to business hours. Amanda
Askew said this would be enforceable but may infringe on homeowners who want to do
the work themselves. Amy Palmer proposed only regulating tree companies. Discussion
ensued.
13.ADJOURNMENT
There being no further discussion, Mark Gabrynowicz declared the meeting adjourned at 8:10
p.m.
Attest:
Amanda AskewMark Gabrynowicz, Chair
Environmental Stewardship Committee (ESC)
October 11, 2023
Page 5 of 5
Page 7 of 55
Page 8 of 55
Agenda Item #4.B.
08 Nov 2023
!
Page 9 of 55
Agenda Item #4.B.
08 Nov 2023
Page 10 of 55
Agenda Item #4.B.
08 Nov 2023
Page 11 of 55
Agenda Item #4.B.
08 Nov 2023
Page 12 of 55
Agenda Item #4.C.
08 Nov 2023
ESC Tree Subcommittee Minutes – October 11, 2023; 5:15 p.m.
Bruce, Mark, Anastasia, Heather, Sarah and Amanda were present. Adopt-a-Tree program discussed.
Heather reported that she coordinated some children going door to door didn’t have a good experience
with many residents.
We discussed Donner Road again. Dan volunteered to solicit residents for backyard plantings.
Bruce asked Amanda to have PW provide new trunk protectors to use trees that need larger conduit. He
will then coordinate volunteer installation.
Mark suggested again that we develop a Tree Fund budget.
Dan reviewed a PowerPoint presentation that addressed strengthening our tree ordinance.
We agreed to solicit citizen volunteers to assist with the Seminole/Atlantic intersection analysis.
Anastasia will ask Fred Jones and Bruce will check with Sarah Dark.
Meeting adjourned at 6:05 pm.
Page 13 of 55
Page 14 of 55
Agenda Item #4.D.
08 Nov 2023
Sustainability & Resilience Subcommittee Meeting
Thursday, October 26, 2023 9-10am
Agenda
1.Call to order and roll call
Attendance: Heather, Sarah
Absent: Mark, Romy
2.Agenda Adjustments - None
3.Chair remarks
Recommend reading COJ Resilience Report – www.resilientjacksonville.com
Recap of meeting with CM on resilience hub idea, CAP and Mayport road
2030 Parks Master Plan
4.Consent Agenda – Punted to next meeting
September 28, 2023 Meeting Minutes
5.Courtesy of the floor / Public comment - None
6.Reports and/or requests from other COAB Boards/Committees/Subcommittees/Working Groups - None
7.Continued/Ongoing/Unfinished Business
Review draft 2023 CAP survey – Heather and Sarah narrowed total number of questions down. Sarah
will work with Kevin to refine questions and input into survey monkey and launch survey November-
December.
Review progress on S&RCAP metrics and milestones and discuss next steps Punted to next meeting
Update on voluntary energy & water challenge pilot -- Punted to next meeting
Update on working group recruitment -- Punted to next meeting
Resilience working group
Other working group or volunteer needs for S&R
AB Resilience Hub update – S&R Subcom will start with a “What is a resilience hub?” educational event
AB CIP and how it fits into S&R work (review the PU & PW CIP plans before meeting and come prepared
to comment/discuss) -- Punted to next meeting
Septic to sewer next steps -- Punted to next meeting
8.New Business
Revisit new date & time for S&R Subcommittee meetings to include Heather – Heather’s ideal available
times are M-F 7-8am or Mondays 4-5pm. Sarah to follow up with other S&R Subcom members and
Amanda to see if any of these times work for the majority and if Chambers are available. Also need a
new or reaffirmed zoom link moving forward.
S&R Subcommittee 2024 priorities -- Punted to next meeting
9.Courtesy of the floor / Public comment - None
10.Closing Round/Comments - None
11.Adjournment – Adjourned 10:16am
Meeting Resources
Resilience Hub Information
Page 15 of 55
Agenda Item #4.D.
08 Nov 2023
USDN Resilience Hubs Guidance Document -- http://resilience-hub.org/wp-
content/uploads/2019/10/USDN_ResilienceHubsGuidance-1.pdf -- READ THIS IF YOU ONLY HAVE TIME FOR ONE
ITEM
USDN Resilience Hub website resources -- http://resilience-hub.org/resources/
USDN Resilience Hub White Paper -- http://resilience-hub.org/wp-
content/uploads/2019/07/USDN_ResilienceHub.pdf
Orlando’s Resilience Hub website -- https://www.orlando.gov/Our-Government/Orlando-plans-for-a-future-
ready-city/Transforming-Community-Centers-into-Resilience-Hubs
Orlando’s Future Ready Plan --
https://www.orlando.gov/files/sharedassets/public/initiatives/final_futurereadycityplan-appendix.pdf
S&R Subcommittee 2023 Priorities (Decided during February meeting)
TOP FOUR
Support Commission priorities of energy and water conservation (2023 Commission Priority / CAP:
Energy & Climate and Water)
Determine how to set short- and medium-term milestone targets for each SRCAP 2050 goal and
determine best measurement metrics to show progress toward long term goals. (requested by
Commission for next SRCAP report)
Conduct an annual SRCAP survey (SRCAP: Governance, Outreach & Education)
Review and report out on status and progress of SRCAP before the end of the year annually and educate
accordingly (required in SRCAP)
ADDITIONAL
Improve use of landscape and rainwater harvesting tools to capture rainwater for filtration or reuse.
(2023 Commission Priority – stormwater management / CAP: Water)
Assess feasibility and support adoption of expanding the Baker Center services to include serving as a
Community Resilience and Sustainability Center and creating a centralized virtual accessible space with
educational programming so residents and businesses know where to go to learn about and engage in
sustainability and resiliency efforts (CAP: Education & Outreach)
Start learning and paving way for AB to become a solar and EV ready community (2023 Commission
Priority / CAP: Energy & Climate)
Support getting outdoor exercise equipment installed in appropriate parks (CAP: Quality of Life
/Livability)
Assess feasibility and support implementation of collecting and reusing unused paint (CAP: Solid Waste)
Support staff, ESC and ESC subcommittees as needed and in promotion and implementation of the CAP,
sustainability and resilience efforts
Page 16 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
Clumping of Results from Initial 2024 ESC Priorities Survey
10 out of 11 ESC members responded (91%)
MARITIME FOREST
Plant 100 trees in 2024
o Plant more streetscape trees on both public and private property – Tree Subcom leads
o Get more trees planted in commercial and industrial parking lots to reduce heat island effect plus other
benefits. – Tree Subcom leads
o Plant edible community trees and bushes throughout the city (“edible walking tour/trail”) – Tree
Subcom leads
Educate about ordinance and benefits of trees at least once a month
o Use door hangers to promote tree planting program - redouble efforts when backyard trees included –
OSC leads
o Expand education and outreach for AB Verified Tree services – OSC leads
o Develop AB Verified programs for landscapers and developers – OSC leads
o Continue to educate and reinforce the value and benefits of trees (including absorption) – share
inspiring local stories, launch a campaign where people post videos about
identifying/inventorying/assessing their own trees, create an editorial calendar where ESC (maybe in
partnership with UF/IFAS) creates and city posts helpful tree information each month, etc. – OSC leads
o Add best residential and commercial tree award to awards nominations. – OSC leads
Update and strengthen policies and ordinances negatively affecting trees annually (introduce by at least Nov)
o Update and strengthen Chapter 23, present to Commission, amend ordinance (examples: backyard tree
plantings allowable; incentives for heritage trees, such as subsidy to help pay for maintaining trees;
strengthening tree ordinance to mirror stronger ones in Florida that require "every effort to save"
designated trees and disallow clear cutting; Develop incentives for protection of the canopy; strengthen
enforcement) – ESC leads
o Continue growing the green streets campaign – Staff or ESC leads?
o Improve building codes so they harm less trees and incentivize keeping trees – Staff or ESC leads?
Expand data and understanding of tree canopy and its benefits via at least 3 actions
o Receive regular reports on status of tree canopy – Staff leads
o PlanItGeo Assessment structured into planning systems to integrate it so that it is regularly utilized in
planning and policy. – ESC leads
o Develop and execute plan for canopy species identification. – Staff leads
o Identify and understand scope of invasive species problem and make a plan to reduce problem – Staff or
ESC leads?
o Perform a heat study in June 2024 replicating the one done in 2022 – S&R leads
o Decide on a tree canopy percentage for AB to maintain (this works toward and refines the SRCAP 2050
goal to “Increase and maintain healthy, diverse tree canopy to 40%” – S&R leads
o Perform a mature tree assessment or somehow understand how many, location, and ideally
species/expected lifespan/key details of our mature trees so we can design incentives to keep them and
plan for replacement (this works toward/refines the SRCAP 2050 goal to “Increase number of historic
Page 49 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
homes/buildings, number of lots that retain trees (not denuded due to construction), and renovate
versus razing by 25%” – OSC leads
PARKS & OPEN SPACES
Choose at least one action and implement it in 2024 that develops and enhances connectivity and walkability
between parks and within city – S&R leads
o Work with staff to understand their long term plan to connect parks and how ESC can help – S&R leads
Improve Experience with at least two significant actions
o Provide water bottle filling stations at all parks. – Staff leads
o Plant edible plants - permaculture additions to parks (citrus, mulberry, fig, etc.) – Tree Subcom leads
o Increase recycling bins in all parks. – S&R leads with help from OSC on education
Update and implement Parks Master Plan
o Ascertain where residents do not have access to a park/open space within ½ mile and look for open
space for city to buy/designate a park/open space/community garden (this works toward and refines
the SRCAP 2050 goal to “Ensure that 95% of residential addresses are located within ½ mile of a park or
open space.” – Staff leads
o Incorporate native plants and trees into our green spaces – Tree Subcom leads
o Establish a native plant demonstration garden – OSC leads
o Establish a robust "friends of the park" infrastructure so that each COAB park has a group of citizens to
advocate for their park. In order to be effective, some city staff assistance would be needed to
coordinate. – OSC leads
o Help get no sale of AB parks without a citizen vote/referendum in the Charter and passed – ESC leads
o Install exercise equipment for long, healthy, active life in one of AB’s parks (partner with Blue Zones) –
Staff leads
o Have City create account and add/update native plantings as they plant – Staff leads
o Clean up and create a natural walking path along Hopkins Creek – ESC leads
o Disc golf – add to suggestions to Parks Master Plan
o Bat boxes – Staff leads
Expand and convert Baker Center (or one/all community centers) into Resilience Hubs – S&R leads
o Host a “What is a Resilience Hub” educational event
o Host a community charrette to hear what the community wants
o Secure additional funding
Educate the community at least once a month – OSC leads
o Education about the benefits for parks, open spaces and green spaces (e.g., create an editorial calendar
for telling stories about each open space/park AB has)
o Participate in Homegrown National Park effort
o Launch a residential native plant challenge with goal of 100 new plantings on map by end of 2024
o Launch a commercial native plant challenge with goal of 50 new plantings on map by end of 2024
BEAUTIFICATION OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE SPACES
Start at least three projects
o Beautify and connect/delineate sidewalks on Seminole & Atlantic Blvd corners; Redesign, connect
sideways, beautify, and vegetation to Seminole & Atlantic Blvd corners (less concrete) – Tree Subcom
leads
o Improve Atlantic Blvd Median with perennials, expand native plantings – Tree Subcom leads
o Break ground on Demonstration Garden – OSC leads
o Identify public spaces and initiate action to plant oasis in asphalt /concrete deserts – Tree Subcom leads
o Add native species to green spaces, side of road/right of way, etc – Tree Subcom leads
o Identify a location and establish an Art Installation Program with a budget. Example:
https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/136091ee6017400fa216fb9cbc383fe0 – OSC leads
o Identify locations and create natural habitats for butterfly's/bees/birds – Tree Subcom leads
Improve at least two internal City practices
o Have existing "Plant Palette" used and enforced by Public Works – Tree Subcom leads
Page 50 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
o As with pilot project in Howell Park, plant native grasses on creek beds, ditches, etc. – Tree Subcom
leads
o Establish a formal channel with Public Works to ensure that Atlantic Blvd and Mayport road medians are
maintained properly (contractor is currently not performing) and to have input into public plantings at
five-way, welcome to AB areas, etc. – Tree Subcom leads
o Encourage more tree and native plant planting along AB commercial corridors (Atlantic Blvd & Mayport
Road) – Tree Subcom leads
o Create a compost drop off/pick up location at one of AB’s parks – OSC leads
Update/pass at least one Policy / Ordinance that improves public or private spaces
o Update Chapter 24 to require more trees and native plantings in commercial/industrial parking lots –
ESC leads
Outreach and educate at least once a month about how to City is beautifying in an environmentally friendly
manner its public spaces and how residents/commercial owners beautify their private spaces – OSC leads
o Educational campaigns for all of the following, which are interconnected: native landscaping,
xeriscaping - use less water, no biocides, backyard habitat corridor, etc.
Explore ways to develop Mayport Road well and in an environmentally-friendly, attractive manner – Staff leads
o Explore ways to incentivize businesses on Mayport to increase green space and to reduce impervious
surfaces.
o Work with staff on zoning and code to define and develop the way AB wants to develop this corridor
ENVIRONMENTAL STEWARDSHIP
Work on at least one action item in each focus area of the S&R CAP and plan for 2027 LEED Recertification – S&R
leads
o Continue with LEED roadmap (or current name). Try to focus on a few achievable goals for one year.
o Complete Chemical Management Plan; Pass a required integrative biocide and chemical management
plan for city operations/public sector and voluntary guidelines for private sector.
o Provide green building, sustainability and resilience training to staff, have staff review workplans and
projects with a sustainability and resilience lens, and add environmental stewardship to staff’s annual
performance reviews
o Start a Green Business program; Grow green business recognition and establish community-based
recognition for local stewards of the environment
o Create draft plan on how to meet greening AB’s energy supply by 2050
o Create a citizen’s guide for sustainable and resilience buildings and living
o Integrate PW and PU CIP into SRCAP actions and vice versa
o Grow number of people interested and engaged in making AB more sustainable and resilient by 50. – All
subcommittees lead
o Increase community events that spotlight environmental themes in order to raise awareness.
o Create and implement strategy that will Increase and maintain healthy tree canopy to 40% (or whatever
% is decided upon) *
o Meet or exceed drinking water standards
o Follow the recommendations of the S&R Subcommittee for 2024 action items.
o Create roadmap to achieve Platinum recertification in 2027
o Create an annual LEED performance metric spreadsheet that is completed each year by staff and ESC
o Implement one action to reduce municipal solid landfill waste and increase recycling rate
o Discern and implement incentives to walk/bike and reduce VMT
Update/pass at least one policy or ordinance and/or improve at least one internal city practice through staff
coordination – S&R leads
o Ensure upgrading of our policies to better value resilience as an investment
o Pass an incentivized green building and resilience ordinance for new and existing buildings; Adopt
and/or incentivize best practices for resilient properties; focus on green buildings
o Work closely with staff on the ocean dune invasive plant study and participate in the planning for
removal and reclamation.
Page 51 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
o Address conflicts in Chapter 23 and zoning ordinances (i.e. swales) -- where the law is working at cross
purposes. This may require partnership with CDB.
Funding – ESC leads
o Pursue land preservation grants in collaboration with other stakeholders
o Increase engagement/awareness of grant opportunities and pursue appropriate opportunities (try for at
least two grants in 2024)
o Establish SR line item in AB budget
o Work with staff and Langton Associates to seek funding opportunities for ESC/SRCAP work
Educate the community at least once a month on environmental stewardship, sustainability and resilience
actions and strategies – OSC leads
o The ongoing community education objective tying in env. stewardship to resilience in ways that any
homeowner or politician can get behind smarter long-term policies.
ESC ORGANIZATIONAL EXCELLENCE
Expand outreach through improved COAB website by improving traffic by 50% – OSC leads
Increase effectiveness, productivity, and improve satisfaction of ESC meetings and measure success through
overall scores on ESC self-evaluation questionnaire – ESC Chair leads
o Focus on agreed-upon priorities at meetings by limiting time spent on ad-hoc issues that are brought to
us outside of our workplan.
o A greater focus on planning and accountability for measurable goals, and more efficient meetings with
pre reads that could help to reduce the extensive exploratory conversations that, although certainly
valuable, tend to ramble. – All ESC members lead
o If the meetings could be done virtually sometimes that would help.
o All ESC members must come to each meeting prepared – meaning they have read through the full
agenda and all the supplemental documents (minutes, motions, background info, etc.) and come
prepared to vote, ask questions, make concise comments and suggestions using motions/discussion. –
All ESC members lead
o Add a member round to the standing agenda so each member has a chance to share their perspective,
new ideas, announcements, etc.
o Hefty items (e.g., motions, items that need thoughtful feedback) should be place early on the agenda
and less time spent on reviewing subcommittee work already outlined in minutes and under consent
agenda
o I think consent agenda is working fairly well and has improved efficiency of ESC meetings
o The order of the meetings would be more productive if subcommittee reports were held to the end and
the items from staff and/or substantive conversations should be prioritized instead. I think 1 minute for
each committee member to speak at the end would be appreciated. I know that I always have items to
share or broach and there is not really an appropriate time in the agenda for this.
o I suggest spending more time during meetings on policy formulation, staff reports, meatier topics, guest
speakers to help educate us so that we can make strong recommendations to commission, etc., vs.
recounting subcommittee activities. The only subcommittee items that should be discussed are ones
that need full committee approval for moving forward. Otherwise, members can keep up to date by
reading consent agenda items.
Improve internal processes measure success through overall scores on ESC self-evaluation questionnaire – ESC
Chair leads
o Increase delegation and accountability.
o Increase collaboration between subcommittees.
o Continue to improve the planner/calendar/metrics and annual workplan to stay ahead of actions, meet
our goals, stay accountable, and share what we are working on and accomplishing
Must decide ESC priorities by no later than December
Must make recommendations for Commission priorities by no later than December
ESC should set its 2024 calendar by December including events (e.g., are we renewing speaker
series, doing film series, new citizen meet & greet,
Must put together a requested budget by no later than January
Page 52 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
Work with staff to improve monthly/quarterly metrics reporting
o Set up automatic emails reminding ESC members to submit suggested agenda items,
planner/calendar/metrics
o Send calendar invites for each meeting
o Get each ESC member to subscribe to City calendar and texts
o Continue to improve the ESC Member Guidance Packet (aka Onboarding Packet) so that it can help all
members not just new members. Add a Chair/Vice Chair/Secretary description (what does each position
do?) Add subcommittee descriptions. Add links of where to find key items. Add past accomplishments
and kudos.
o Have one online place where ESC members can find everything from agendas and minutes to record
decisions and sign-up sheets/graphics for events (e.g., could be external facing ESC webpage and meet
two major needs)
o Start an internship program
o Understand better what we can and can’t do under Sunshine Laws (e.g., work on creating a program
once vote for program has been approved)
o Get clarity on what needs a formal ESC vote
o Strategic plan for each year for ESC should include something from each of the four focus areas under
ESC. I therefore appreciate this survey!
o Start planning early and make sure the Commission has all information needed from ESC to include in
their priority planning.
o We have two ESC members rolling off in December (one At Large and one District 1312). It would be
great to recruit two new members before then so they have some onboarding time but definitely by
January.
Continue to improve the best practice of annual self evaluation – ESC Chair leads
o Seek suggestions to improve and perform end of year evaluation/continual improvement questionnaire.
Choose 1-2 items to improve. Creating an onboarding packet was the result of the 2022 year end self-
evaluation survey.
o Combine with self-evaluation questionnaire or complete a separate annual ESC Demographic Survey
Increase the number of ESC volunteers/SMEs by at least 20 people – OSC leads
o Recruit volunteers (e.g., citizens, SMEs, university students) and stand up necessary working groups
o Start a “block/neighborhood communicator” program
o Improve how we recruit ESC members – ESC leads
o Grow a partnership program and increase number and depth of partnerships by at least 5 (e.g., Friends
of XYZ Park, N FL Green Chamber, UNF, JU, Beaches Watch, AB Preservation, Beaches Go Green, Fletcher
Interact) – S&R leads
Use ARCC collaboration to increase ESC visibility at Art/culture events
Partner with other committees to increase community engagement.
PROPOSED 2024 ESC SUBCOMMITTEE MEMBERS
Tree OutreachSustainability & Resilience
Bruce AndrewsAnastasia HoustonSarah Boren
Daniele GiovannucciAmy PalmerMark Gabrynowicz
Mark GabrynowiczPatrick NoblesRomy Vann
Mark GabrynowiczHeather Markaj
Sarah Boren
Missing: Two new ESC members in 2024
List of documents/resources ESC should read before/take into account in setting its 2024 priorities
Page 53 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
Adaptation Plan Phase 1 (recommended by Steve Swann)
Parks Master Plan
Chapter 24
Chapter 23
Staff quarterly tree report
PlanItGeo Assessment
S&R Community Action Plan
Comprehensive Plan
ARCC Committee’s plan/priorities for 2024
Page 54 of 55
Agenda Item #10.A.
08 Nov 2023
Page 55 of 55