Loading...
09-04-01 vCITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD MINUTES SEPTEMBER 4, 2001 Call to order: PRESENT: Curtis M. Sanders, Jr., Chairman Tami Deitchman Peter Wynkoop Carl Russell Mamie Hurd ABSENT: Richard Mann James Pelkey Alan C. Jensen, City Attorney AND: Suzanne Green, Prosecuting Attorney Alex Sherrer, Code Enforcement Officer Julie M. Brandt, Secretary The meeting was called to order at 7:30 p.m. by Chairman Curtis Sanders, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag by all present. Chairman Sanders requested that the roll be read. Secretary Brandt read the roll and it was determined that Board Members Mann and Pelkey were absent. 1. Approval of Minutes of the May 1, 2001 Meeting Following a brief review of the minutes, a motion was made by Board Member Russell, seconded by Board Member Deitchman and unanimously carried to approve the minutes of the Regular Code Enforcement Board Meeting of May 1, 2001 as presented. 2. Recognition of Visitors and Guests regarding any matters that are not listed on the agenda. There were no visitors or guests present. Item 3, Old Business, was taken out of sequence and acted on after Item 4, New Business. Chairman Sanders read the case number and indicated that Mr. James Baker was being brought before the Code Enforcement Board for several violations. Secretary Brandt read the case procedures to be followed. It was noted that neither Mr. Baker nor his representative was present at the hearing. Page -2- Minutes Code Enforcement Board Meeting September 4, 2001 4. NEW BUSINESS: Case No. 342-00-James Baker, 598 Seaspray (Seaspray Lot 33, Block 4). Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer explained that Mr. Baker, the owner of the property, was in violation of Chapter 12, Section 12-1 (1) (2) (3) and (7), Chapter 21, Section 21-24(b), Chapter 24, Sections 24-151 (3)(f) and 24-65 (c) of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Atlantic Beach. in that there existed on the property the following conditions: refuse accumulation, more than one accessory structure, no building permit for the accessory structures, and the existence of one or more inoperative vehicles. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer distributed a case presentation folder to each Board Member. He indicated that Mr. Baker was aware of the meeting since he had been served a subpoena instructing him to be present. The case presentation folder is attached and made part of this official record as Attachment A. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer explained Exhibits 1-9 included in the case presentation folder. It was pointed out that the first notice of violation occurred on October 19, 2000. Exhibits 3, 4 and 5 showing photographs of the junk cars, rubbish and accessory structures on the property were viewed. It was pointed out that between the first notice of violation and the official Notification of Violation, which was signed for by Mr. Baker on March 9, 2001, very little had been accomplished to bring the property into compliance, and additional refuse was found on the property. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer reported that the last inspection of the property had been conducted that afternoon and the inoperable vehicles had been removed from the property, as well as most of the accumulated refuse. It was pointed out that the City Code allows only one permitted shed per property and three sheds were located on the property. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer indicated that Mr. Baker had been advised to obtain a permit for one of the sheds and to remove the other two. Exhibits 7, 8 and 9 were briefly discussed. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer recapped the previous violations on the property dating back to 1989. It was pointed out that a 1998 fine levied against the property by the Code Enforcement Board remained unpaid, including administrative expenses totaled $360.68. Page -3- Minutes Code Enforcement Board Meeting September 4, 2001 Discussion ensued and Board Member Deitchman pointed out that until today, eleven months had elapsed without any progress being made to clean up the property. It was also pointed out that in 1998, the Code Enforcement Board voted to fine Mr. Baker $100.00 per day if the property was found to be in non-compliance again. The Board felt that Mr. Baker should have been fined $100.00 per day since last October. A motion was made by Board Member Russell, seconded by Board Member Deitchman and unanimously carried to: (1) Find James Baker, owner of the property, to be a repeat violator in violation of Chapter 12, Sections 12-1-2-3 and 7 of the Code, (2) to assess Mr. Baker a fine of $500 per day for ten days for each violation, for a total of $10,0000, (3) to defer all but $250.00 of the fine, and (4) give Mr. Baker thirty (30) days to clean up the remainder of the trash on said property. If the property is not cleaned up to the satisfaction of the Code Enforcement Officer on the 31St day, the $9,750 fine will be reinstated. Discussion ensued concerning the length of time needed to remove two sheds and properly permit the remaining shed. A motion was made by Board Member Wynkoop, seconded by Board Member Deitchman and unanimously carried to (1) Find Mr. Baker in violation of Chapter 24, Sections 24-151(3)f and 24-65(c) of the Code, (2) to give Mr. Baker thirty (30) days to remove two sheds of his choice and ninety (90) days to properly permit the remaining shed, and (4) to assess Mr. Baker a fine of $125 per day for ten days for each violation, for a total of $2,500, if the two sheds are not removed in thirty days. Discussion ensued concerning the storage of inoperable vehicles on said property. A motion was made by Board Member Russell, seconded by Board Member Hurd and unanimously carried to: (1) Find Mr. Baker in violation of Chapter 21, Section 21-24(b) of the Code, (2) not assess a fine at this time because the inoperable vehicles had been removed from the property, and (3) impose a fine as a repeat violator if he is found to be in non-compliance again. The Board assessed Mr. Baker $692.41 administrative costs. 3. OLD BUSINESS: Case No. 075-01 Benjamin Brown Jr. , 457 Sailfish Drive (Lot 1, Block 27, Royal Palms Unit 2A). Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer provided background information as follows: During the May 1, 2001 Code Enforcement Board Meeting, Mr. Brown was found to be in violation of Chapter 12-1 (b) (7) outside storage of miscellaneous materials and Chapter 24, Section 24-104 operation of a junkyard in a residential district of the City Code of Ordinances. It was pointed out that Mr. Page -4- Minutes Code Enforcement Board Meeting September 4, 2001 Brown was not fined, but he was assessed $815.50 in administrative expenses which were to be paid within 90 days. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer indicated that Mr. Brown had paid seventy-five dollars toward the administrative expenses and had requested an extension to pay the remaining expenses. A brief discussion ensued, and a motion was made by Board Member Wynkoop, seconded by Board Member Russell and unanimously carried to acknowledge receipt of payment of $75.00 and to grant Mr. Brown a ninety (90) day extension (from today's date) to pay the remaining balance of $740.50 in administrative expenses. Update on the Appeal Filed with the Circuit Court Regarding the Community Development Board's Denial of a Variance to Allow Parking of a Boat in a Front Yard In the absence of City Attorney Jensen, Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer updated the Board on the appeal. City Attorney Jensen's memo dated September 4, 2001 was distributed to each Board Member. The memo is attached and made part of this official record as Attachment B. Parking of boats on through lots was briefly discussed, and it was pointed out that parking of a boat right next to Mr. Sutton's boat on the through lot next to his property would be perfectly legal. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer indicated that the city could take no action at this time since the case is being appealed. Statistical Information Relative to Business Signs and Code Enforcement Case Load The Code Enforcement Investigation Report was also distributed and it was pointed out that since the beginning of the year, 1994 complaints had been investigated. Courtesy Notices were discussed and Board Member Russell requested that the ordinance number be cited on the notice. Code Enforcement Officer Sherrer distributed to each Board Member a list of signs located throughout the city. The list indicated their specific location, condition and if they were located in the right-of--way. Enforcement of the sign ordinance, which was revised four years ago, was briefly discussed. It was pointed out business owners were notified and given four years to bring their signs into compliance with the sign ordinance and most of them still had not done so. 5. REQUEST FOR LIEN ACTION: Name Address Amount of Lien There were no requests for lien action. Page -5- Minutes Code Enforcement Board Meeting September 4, 2001 6. BOARD MEMBER COMMENTS: There were no Board Member comments. 7. ADJOURNMENT There being no further discussion or business to come before the Board, the meeting adjourned at 8:45 PM. Curtis San ers, Jr., Chairman Code Enforcement Board Attest: I~1 J ie M. Brandt, Secretary ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-01 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA NOTICE OF HEARING CASE NO. 342-00 June 8, 2001 BY CERTIFIED MAIL Mr. James W. Baker 598 Seaspray Ave Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Dear Mr. Baker: The Code Enforcement Board of the City of Atlantic Beach was created pursuant to Florida Statutes and exists for the purpose of facilitating trie enforcement of the Code of Ordinances. It is comprised of seven citizens, residents of Atlantic Beach, who meet regularly to hear allegations of code violations. You are hereby notified and ordered to appear at the next public hearing of the Code Enforcement Board on TUESDAY, the 10th day of July, 2001, AT 7:30 P. M. at Atlantic Beach City Hall, 800 Seminole Road, to answer and be heard to the alleged violations of the following Section(s) of the Code of the City of Atlantic Beach: Chapter 12, Section 12-1 (1) (2), (3) & (7): Nuisances, Chapter 21, Section 21-24 (b): Traffic and Motor Vehicles, Chapter 24, Chapter 24, Section 24-65 (c) and Section 24-1~1 (3) (f): Zoning & Subdivision Regulations. It is alleged that you are in violation of the above enumerated code section(s) in that there exists on the premises located at 598 Seaspray Ave, a/k/a 35-64 17-2S-29E, Seaspray Lot 33, Block 4, of the City of Atlantic Beach, the following condition(s): Refuse accumulation, More then one accessory structure, No building permit for accessory structures, Accumulation of one (1) or more inoperative vehicles. The Code Enforcement Board has the power to levy fines up to $250.00 per day for the first offense and $500.00 for the second offense against the property, if a violation is found to exist beyond the date set by the Board for compliance. If the violation is corrected and then recurs or if the violation is not corrected by the time specified for correction by the code inspector, the case may be presented to the enforcement board even if the violation has been corrected prior to the board hearing. You have the right to obtain an attorney at your own expense and to present witnesses in your behalf. If you desire to have witnesses subpoenaed or if you have questions regarding the procedure, please contact Patti Kotchkowski, Secretary of the Code Enforcement Board within five days of the receipt of this notice at 247-5810. Please note the presence of a court reporter for the purpose of insuring a verbatim record in the event an appeal should be secured at your expense. ~ - -, Sincerely, Curtis M. Sanders, Jr -Chairman ,~(cL,,~,-~o~ Code Enforcement Board ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-01 Z 425 ],L6 139 US Postal Service Receipt for Certified Mail No Insurance Coverage Provided. Do not use for International Mail See reverse Sent to- ,~?? ~' -r ~ • NA i= r St & N umbe B ~ ~ ~ ~/ N Post Office, S te, ~ ZIP ode n c n ~ ~?):33 Postage Certified Fee Spedal Delivery Fee Restricted Delivery Fee ~ Return Receipt Showing to ~' Whom S Date Delivered o. Realm Receipt Sfawarg to Whom, Date, 6 Addressee's Address O O TOTAL Postage d Fees E Postmark or Date lL n. ~ • - • •s • - err- • - ~ • - - I • - i ~, _ Is your RETURN ADDRESS completed on the reverse side? ~ rn cn ~ ~ w ~-.. ... N ~'t Cn 77 _1 D m.m~`~m~'~oo i o X ? ~ ~ ~ am 3,7o,~aa ZO i ~ c ~. ~ cp ~ m nom. ~~cmmm to m D 3c "~~-~-37 0o m. a ~ a y3 ii d~m• i_ ~ ~ a ma ~ 333 ` ~ „~ J \~ n muw 7 m o. ro i 3 ~ W W ~ ~ ~ ?~ c aj o o ~ }, a o i ~ m ~ ~ D ~ ° n m' n i ~ ~ ~.. F g a ~ ~D m W ~~ o~ ~ m S a ~ 3 g o m ~ ~ ` (,J ~ ~ m ~ ~ m D ~ m3 ~ N m ~ ~ me ~ m 3. ~~ o I (~ r ~ m ~ O ~ w I` Fm ~ m ~ ~. H m m O ~ _ ~~ m f m 3 a i. m g x o m ~ ~ am H a s a ~ ^ ~ m o.m m ~ m V ~ ~ ~ A A j Q d m C p j 4 a ~ m x~ m D d m ~ m m is ~ rp z 3 m g c i m y O 3 m H' n m 7 y ~ N ~ m , am ° ~ ~ a~ 1,1'ic O my <~ ~. v ~ n mo- 4 a •2 o m~ m y N ~ y 0 y f o y ~' ~ ~ ~ N y n O fD t1 y ~ i r7~ ~ ~ N m a~ m o ~ , c w ~ ~ 2 ~ fD m ~ v, n c~ c fD ~ m a m H m ~ ~ ^ ^ '6~1 v y o `m ~ o m c ~ n ~ n D Z 425 1I,6 139 i ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m ' O. n m ~ Thank you for using Return Receipt Service. i is - - - - - -------- - -- - - - -- --- __. ;. f .r ~ =. L....:: :..._. ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-01 CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH C.B. Date: July 10, 2001 Defendant: MR. JAMES W. BAKER Case #342-00 Location: 598 SEASPRAY AVE A/K/A 35-6417-2S-29E SEASPRAY LOT 33 BLK 4 RE# 170703-0432 Violation: CHAPTER 12, SECTION 12-1 (1) (2) (3) 8~ (7): REFUSE ACCUMULATION CHAPTER 24, SECTION 24-151 (3) f: MORE THEN ONE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE CHAPTER 24, SECTION 24-65 (c): NO BUILDING PERMIT FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES CHAPTER 21, SECTION 21-24 (b) ACCUMULATION OF ONE (1) OR MORE INOPERATNE VEHICLES Owner Occupied: X Rental: Homestead: Yes X No _ Code Enforcement Board Members: 1. Inspection of the property revealed that a violation of the Code of the City of Atlantic Beach is present. Ownership of the property was determined through: Tax Records x Title Search Other 2. The code #(s) and nature of the violation(s) discovered are: CHAPTER 12, SECTION 12-1 (1) (2) (3) 8~ (7): REFUSE ACCUMULATION CHAPTER 24, SECTION 24-151 (3) f: MORE THEN ONE ACCESSORY STRUCTURE CHAPTER 24, SECTION 24-65: NO BUILDING PERMIT FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES CHAPTER 21, SECTION 21-24 (B) ACCUMULATION OF ONE (1) OR MORE INOPERATNE VEHICLES 3. The inspection was prompted as a result of a: Complaint X Routine Inspection -Other 4. A violation notice was issued to the owner/occupant on: MARCH 9, 2001 5. Notice to the owner-occupant was achieved by: Certified Mail X Delivery Posting of Property. The method of service meets with requirements of Florida Statutes 162-12. 6. I did did not speak with the owner someone X in charge of the property concerning the violations. ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-O1 PAGE 2 CODE PRESENTATION SHEET 7. Brief description: On October 19, 2000, in response to a complaint of excessive refuse and abandoned vehicles in both the front and back yards, an inspection of 598 Seaspray Ave was conducted. My inspection of the front yard, revealed one unregistered vehicle and refuse, the back yard was enclosed with a privacy fence and was inaccessible for inspection. A Courtesy Notice of Violation was placed on the front door of 598 Seaspray Ave, with a note for the owner to contact me. On October 26, 2000, I was contacted by and met with Mr. Marvin Baker, who identified himself as the caretaker. After discussing the seriousness of the reported violations, Mr. Baker agreed to a full inspection of the front and back yards. My inspection revealed the front yard was now in compliance, but inspection of the backyard revealed several serious violations. These violations included three junk automobiles, with large piles of refuse and old used household furnishings throughout. Much of the backyard was inaccessible because of the sheer amount of rubbish, much of which was either out in the open, under tarps, in bins and in sheds. After a lengthy conversation about the violations, Mr. Baker agreed to correct the violations over an unspecified amount of time, with monthly progress checks. Over the next several months, attempts to meet with Mr. Baker were unsuccessful. Only after posting several notes on the front door, did Mr. Baker arrange for an inspection. On March 5, 2001, an inspection was conducted, and while some progress had been made, additional violations were identified, including additional refuse which had been deposited elsewhere on the property. Mr. Baker was told that his rate of progress was found unacceptable, and that the accessory buildings (sheds) would also need to be corrected. Mr. Baker received an official Notification of Violation on March 9, 2001, with a required compliance date of thirty (30) days from receipt. 8. The latest inspection was made May 31.2001 as a result of following up on the original complaint(s). 9. The violation(s) is still present X in compliance _. 10. In order to achieve compliance, it is necessary to correct all of the violations and maintain the property: By removing all trash and rubbish from the property; remove two of the three (3) accessory buildings (sheds), ensure the remaining shed is properly permitted, and meets code; and either remove all inoperative vehicles from the property or properly repair and title them. 11. I do X do not have photographs of the property and violations as they existed on the property. They represent a fair and accurate representation of the property at the time they were taken. 12. I would estimate that 30 day(s) would be sufficient time to correct the violation. ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-01 PAGE 3 CODE PRESENTATION SHEET 13. Further Comments: Mr. Baker's has been cited for these same violations of City Code on ten (10) separate occasions since 1989, for thirteen {13) separate violations and has been brought before the Code Enforcement Board twice. Mr. Baker was cited for excessive rubbish in February 1989, August and September 1993, June and August 1997, April 1998, and August 1998; for illegally storing junk/abandoned vehicles on February 1989, June 1992, September and October 1993, May 1997 and August 1997; for violating vegetation height restrictions in June 1995, October 1996, August 1997 and Aprii 1998. On September 11, 1993, Case# 0061, Code Enforcement hearing was held for excessive rubbish. Mr. Baker was given thirty days to come into compliance. No assessments orfines were imposed. On September 8,1998, Case# 98-7518, Code Enforcement hearing was held forthe violations of excessive rubbish and the storage of junk vehicles. Mr. Baker was given 30 days to come into compliance. Mr. Baker was also assessed $110.68 for administrative fees and given a $250.00 fine, both of which remain outstanding. 14 Summary: The Code Enforcement Officer has been trying to work with Mr. Baker for the past nine (9) months to resolve these violations. Mr. Baker has been before the Code Enforcement Board on two separate occasions and found in violation of City Code both times. Mr. Baker has been issued 13 notices of violation, and still continues to violate City Code. Mr. Baker has chosen not to pay his previous assessments and fines, and while there's no proof that Mr. Baker did not bring his property into compliance in the past, two of the three illegally stored vehicles appear to be identical to those previously cited. 15 Recommendations: That Mr Baker be found guilty for non-compliance, and per Florida Statute 162.09 (2)(a) be fined the full $5,000.00 each as a repeat violator for the illegal accumulation of rubbish and the illegal storage of junk vehicles on his property, for a total of $10,000.00. That Mr. Baker's fine be assessed at 50°~ of the $10,000.00, with the additional $5,000.00 deferred pending compliance within thirty (30) days. ff at the end of thirty days, Mr. Baker fails to bring his property into compliance, he will be assessed the full amount for a total of $10,000.00, plus $250.00 a day after thirty (30) days for each violation involving the illegally erected accessory buildings, for a total of $500.00 a day. Furthermore I recommend that Mr. Baker be assessed the fuf! administrative costs of conducting this hearing, per Florida Statute 162.07 (2). Respectfully submitted, Alex Sherrer Code Enforcement Officer ATTACHMENT A Code Bd. Minutes 9-4-01 Code Enforcement Administrative Charges for Presentation to the Board Pursuant to Florida Statute 162.07 (2) the following charges for prosecuting this case before the Code Enforcement Board shall be charged to the violator provided he or she are found in violation. Code Enforcement Board Meeting: July 10, 2001 Case Number, 075-01: Mr. James W. Baker, 598 Seaspray Ave, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Code Enforcement Officer, $ 14.35 per hour x 22 hours = $330.05 Code Enforcement Secretary, $ 9.76 per hour x 3 hours = $ 29.28 Code Enforcement Attorney, $125.00 per hour x 2 hours = $250.00 Postage, Certified Mail, $ 3.74 x 2 = $ 11.22 Copies, Xerox $ .10 x 756 pages = 75.60 Total Charges $696.15 July 10, 2001 Alex Sherrer Code Enforcement Officer ALAN JENSEN ATTY 1379 P01 ALAN C. JF.~I~EN Attornt~ at Law 935 Nom Third Street Post Office Box 50457 Jacksonville Beach, Fbrida 32240-0457 Telepbooe (904) 2A6.2500 FAX MF,MORANDUM DATE: September 4, 2001 TO: Julie Brandt, Secretary Code Enforcement Board SEP 04'01 13:43 ATTACHMENT B CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD SEPTEMBER 4, 2001 FacaimUe (904)1A6-9960 E~Mail: AJe~enLaw®aol.com Time• ~ ~.j~ ,,,, COMPANY: City of Atlantic Beach PAX NUMBER: ~~ t.~ (/~~ i (904} 247-~`' NUMBER OF PAGES: ~ (including cover sheet) FRO _ JENSEN ES ALAN C M: , Q. . CI.IFIVT/MA~'I''ER NO.: Sutton vs Atlantic Beach Appeal of CDB denial of a variance to allow parking of boat th front yard MESSAGE In the event that I am unable to make the meeting tonight for the reasons explained to you, please provide the Code Enforcement Board with this update regazding the above appeal: ,1. The CDB denied the variance at its meeting on May 15, 2001. 2001. 2. The Order Denying Variance was signed by the chairman of the CDB on rune 19, 3. Previously, on June 11, 2001, the City Commission had unanxittously upheld the action of the CDB to deny the variance requested by Mr. Sutton. An appeal to the City Commission based on an illegal action taken by the CDB was denied. 4. On or about July 19, 2001, Mr. Sutton filed an appeal to the circuit court by a Petition For Writ of Certiorari, which is the appropriate method of appealing a decision by a city board. The appeal basically states that Mr. Sutton had never been previously cited with a violation of the ordinance, even though he had been keeping his boat there for approximately 11 years. He also claims, because of the unique shape of his property, that he cannot get a ten foot wide boat trailer down his side yard. In my opinion, neither of these arguments is a sufficient basis fA reverse the decision of the CDB. ALAN JENSEN ATTY 879 PO2 SEP 04'01 13:44 Julie Brandt, Secretary Code P~fozcement Board Fax Memorandum of September 4, 2001 Page 2 5. I filed a Motion to Dismiss the Petition For Writ of Certiorari on behalf of the City, stating that the grounds set forth in Mr. Sutton's petition were insufficient to reverse the decision of the CDB. I further alleged that Mlr. Sutton failed to allege any basis regarding the standard of review which a circuit court must use in reviewing a quasi judicial decision of the CDB, said standard of review being as follows: (a) Whether the petitioner was afforded due process; (b) Whether the CBD observed the essezltial requirements of law; and (c) Whether the findings and decision of the CDB are supported by competent substantial evidence. 6. I also argued that the court cannot substitute its judgment for the CDB, but only determine whether the board complied with ttte standards of review. I cited cases to the court in support of till my arguments. 7. On August 22, 2001, the circuit court entered an Order, which. dismissed the Petition For writ of Certiorari, stating that the petitioner failed to exhaust his admizuistrative remedies. However, since an appeal was taken to the City Commission, I believe the court incorrectly ruled, and I did not even make that point iul the Motion to Dismiss I filed. If necessary, the other attorney and I will get with the court to correct what I believe is an error in the court's decision. 8. In my discussions with Mr. Sutto>tt's attorney, there is a possibility that this entire matter may become moot, thereby eliminating the necessity of aay further court action. I will notify the City if that becomes the case.. 9. A hearing was previously scheduled for October 19, 2001, on the Motion to Dismiss I filed. Please advise the members of the Code Enforcement Board that they are free to contact me if they have any questions at all regarding the above matter. The information contained in this facsimile message is attorney privileged attd confidential information intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. 1f the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disscrpination, distribution or copying of this commutticauott is strictly prohibited, ff you have received this coriumuttication ita error, pleax immediately notify us by telephone arid returzt the original message to us at the above address via U.S. Postal Service. Thank you. Exhibit (1 ) Property Appraiser Track Info tion Page 1 of 1 • RE No.: 170703 0432 Owner's Name: BAKER, JAMES W ET AL Property Address: 598 SEASPRAY AV Unit No. ATLANTIC BEACH 32233 Mailing Address: 598 SEASPRAY AVE ATLANTIC BEACH , FL 32233-4165 Property Use: 0100 SINGLE FAMILY Legal description: 35-64 17-2S-29E SEASPRAY LOT 33 BLK 4 ANLYN W RODDY(SIS) O/R BK 5284-159 Neighborhood: 941601 SALTAIR NBHD Sec-Twn-Range: 17-2S-29E OR BK & Page: 05284-0159 Map Panel: 556A4 Sale Date: 2/5/1981 No. Buildings: 1 Sale Price: $49,000.00 Land Value: $15,908.00 Heated Area: 1872 Class Value: $0.00 Exterior Wall: COMMON BRICK] Improvements: $99,936.00 Taxing Authority: USD3 Market Value: $115,844.00 County Tax: $527.53 Exempt Value: $25,000.00 School Tax: $615.96 Assessed Value: $90,766.00 District Tax: $208.62 Taxable Value: $65,766.00 ,Total Tax: $1,352.11 1161] PI Mt Home PRC Map-IT 12321 1'7 http://pawww.coj.net/pub/property/RENO.asp?RENUM=170703+0432 10/19/00 Exhibit (2) .' 1 is t .. . 9D 2 V l 4 , A N N .• / i CIO • _ ___ - "logo CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH CODE ENFORCEMENT DIVISION 800 Seminole Road • Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 • • PHONE: 147-5855 COURTESY NOTICE OF VIOLATION t JO/0a •M-i "it;.2•4\•P% TI . ,1‘, OWNERMUn\ vs )., ,•,,,,,,,, Ff 5/ 56 9 ,/147 ADDRESS -a- \ ., \ j ' ,‘- ' \ ' THE INSPECTION MADE OF THE. ABO' E PREMISES THIS DATE DISCLOSE)) YOU WERE IN VIOLATION OF ORDINANCE: /2.-/ ---.)- 11749,11.17,e, PeehidestIadiis4 OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF ATLANTIC BENCH, FLORIDA. YOU CAN COMPLY BY A /". -rnifi twilis Irro/e t2 ' / ir74 y 4-ri.,C WITHIN /0 DAYS OF THIS NOTICE (t71/ 1 -E /0 ek-Cieff //44117 THIS IS A COURTESY NOTICE IN ORDER TO MAKE • YOU AWARE OF A VIOLATION OF THE CITY CODE OF ATLANTIC BEACH. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR WOULD LIKE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION PERTAINING TO THIS NOTICE, PLEASE CALL ATLANTIC BEACH CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICE. CODE ENFORCEMENT C 11749/ oFCHEE#R35 0 V RECEIVED BY Exhibit (3) lit , , . . . ,_, 4 ‘. ,,,.....1. ...- , :... ... ,t --" '' ' 4. if .telfk 43 1.' 4" 11(II ft' 4,jki t i 1 '''' - \i. 4' t'' -:.1-.4c11,;.:s.4* A. -. :,;!*.‘./,-. ' "ss •••kr Ai" * *:!•4•tlk- "' '':' A. 71•3E f+ I i,,« '!� r_ • i`♦ .r • i . ! "�)JP., ,e,'24, ',1,.,,r 4}1"'.'" : .. ...A,- ► a �+.4 a, e 7�/ l '. t • ,!w .,,,,,6,..t, „,., .... ,.%.,:,. . +tF d .. '4 "+`a 4t � '� .'17::' 1 y • "*a` R' r 'i. ka s i ! 'it . '►k } �'4 ,•.4-••07.,.. p 't ,x ,Y y» ,VI i P :' '_ d 1 r .. f l de, ! �1 • a Xa: .ice i !4,, rI. * 1 ,;„,..4„..: `. v YJMY ,p.,y$,,.� F� -.� x i I i 11 1. `If x#� a '9 Te :.%..t 3 �• N. * .)4 ..>a *. .i'-.�1.4 . . +'l. p4 t� filar 1,440 �' ) _ � "'BHN.. 4• '�`A4,,,,„....;_„ k , � ` 1 .t' ! f.' Y i'r r Y 7, '3"4„.„444...4- � ' , ...v».. ,`ve ���+ x p k Mir ttibitt le. r - ,t � � • 4. • : t. .,, I ; .- .'''''.,4 4,,,,,...4 4, ,....;* :,....; 1",07.7444,44.44/444.............. 4: ,.., .V.:71.:::°:10/.., 41,i • Mr d:L ,: # " .�.:0 r 40 4,,a., •,.i I... 4r +°,irp i -w_,.y.R....- —F_--.�,.`.+r...�.... Ai ,,r 8�. ,„,;00k, .._:.ef q,, -+, x , �4 + F _ „.....`,4:;-..-- ., ,,,r�ry+-�M M,� ...40..... , • .. -•('`' «. r� ,I f , . _y .. Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 Facing north along back of house Exhibit (4) nt (,� R f° ;.,_ fwj„ R .�,. A. %.r. . L'4?' r t'. yea .I A,'.a ! tdP 444".' r.• ,-S. �, ,•a,, f .t S« , « t= '� ' , a w r. 5. s . A�' « ***6 1� j 1✓, 4.1§? '' , 1.�1 `� t ,l' v Pi- w ! Ra „.,f,---...:41e.„,,,, x�t 4 y f . W ' .4 y9a*. • .Jt F'� y by.i 4` wW a4'1:44 �.a4 � 41 ta •Pr ��i J W �; 1,1' `* �[r . x , ,,,t t. ,, , +' '1 r,t, .. 0 •* 4`s+ a II*. R .t •! r r e , �' ,w tR rt .r :„ yF •�:4 ht"..A Y. ' . tn't I ,y� bfrik i �,.r �' :aw+ :4. *-* ..o'r. �+ 1bf,rr 1,•t.. ' e- '►a.` `` ')i .,a�„ i * ; •. ,, ,i yr • .” %.'.1Vw . 'b`• '� `t,.,'�:,si' `'�*",r' :e„0 . : fr.4,• . : „,.....,..r4 r - , •• . r..• t, , k ....7.-' *''''' , AVrou?,:-2 . • '^t- le*"."1-; ` '', t j eytItionc. l � "1J � � t�,� 1, Y i '�, � .,,,.,”TT :; .w. ,.w.rr �yY'4',i,' �i��,�.; �J�� '+!��. , 4.1*—„„(,::,t, --,,'„.) A,'4",„4'4'4). 1 Va,\"'"•44.44,5 ' - '4. —*sesIES'./.s't ...‘ .,-, 5:, ',.N, i. „,,"ill,.4,_0:4 irk i„s04;1,4,,,,,,,o,.. 32,‘, . „iil (4110 7:1-0. ) 1 , .4, , „..NzAtf: , 4T t 1t r �1 „ ,, ‘.4.,1, , t ! . ,pue . A '1k 4 4,!'•-'`' " t/ , '1•-,. p. �b ''Me k. `°e".r€` 'A V - - P.', y f - r k x + ep ilk i..y„y«. ,-,-(z- � •tea ! Sy .ki r'. ,f �' -,1/4. 4 (1 rt ' r� e� k t �d � " ,lf� M`" #` " )r.' O. ,iil •� lilt w •f I girt A '' '""" f a . y ' S +'wt ..4 J� 4i *.** y.4' S,4 tet , t;.---, ' wJ it * P .'t s �� e rt._ �� Y ��t wa.+�,;. ,*���` }�a`/�'I, Y mii'' ht P17�.,L �(t ►!?t 1.. p� ��* y _ .� f c e . YV,J' � a. °� . r 14 1•i 4. 1 'x.4a t'4 ' t k' , Nbi ;i t4 to , .1r ,,,,,,,,,t.:0/11... rt. �s,.,, ! ': t !c ,.. y}, R' ( r`111 � _It ! <� .*4 I" • '"'✓'..`� �f � o •�• � • r �,,/�'�"!, ��� ld, !•� � 7 } 3�.. +' , r..'" - -'t 4 „,� 3 r,,N �,f*`Y,i). rt a.„„ 4• 'i f4 - - R�1Vy'6„d,. ” y jj w +�€ ash 4 • . ♦ •-' A �w • .� ,-. 1 {: ar ++fes r , �• �` . ,`{ 4,` ,,,,.. a, t, `',`,... :ireL `, _r.tf '�, 9n, 4 y Y - >., -"` Rjk,, AARS ,. sl .. �w�.f+ ...+ ` a,6� -\.'i�'f 1/4,... ..,, �' � Zt,,. ed� :‘,.;,,kii' { r '..# , 'a '�' .... i ..• w ,y t,.. i'. i^'c iVa�Y.4 Y'•` ',kV: ' 4'-& y▪ .�, i y �' . f wda J w ` . i "+4‘.,,,,..,,,,, • • Y , d• "'=�.1 '�, *T r+ ?t Et i ,,if s.�. 'w•.`•, }, j.Y r'�. �w :.,. + l M s Iy .:s` .`C�."r-.�je}r .. r.A. 4 `®« ,. 2414 ,,.w� `'# .yt1►��411104aY.r ,` +1#t µ`,44� � • # ,t t .! , y 11 V ; c .r iR '� _rtr x• $ +. 'n' as w f L.1�.,�%,s . 1''��r11.v ,.'.., ! ,i "l!';r"i 1t 4,f. r '.,w' ". � �..�wa iS ir z•^ !`iv -y w 'ti ` 31 144/c ` A ;1 •,.+`, l .* C M am r t. q n " X3:1 . y , �+ i, 1 '' 4.ik, , Ai _..,e'1 L' .a .r� tit. ! Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of three sheds located in backyard A,' �'F x h 8 • rtf '�. ': #° ss a`r.d►^ 'a. fi g . T s msr-^ KaM h y o �'',, , '� f t' c A:Y p �L d�j f �� d "4 ' ' �a" R I -' -.• s a aM' ;-• ';''''';%;:74/"4. x 1:;141,11.---.. ,',;;,;;;;7:::!,- � say ; ,.,4'. S:e�, `4 � 91 � ,,,1„1.:. ,fig O f' f ,• ry A ./f,,, ':::,,r;:'.., 7 z $k` '' 3 .. Stit y� a , 4,,,1, :i.. i.,,,..,,tr;11?":.',:;";:::::,,''':,,.,..f..,:::::::„;,,,i,7.,';''':11;:: ,,,,,,,,' _ s 1::?:,,::-.:::::7, ,kl ' i,::"i .„'-..:.'.-:—.' , , '. , t A�, , pol . S}} ',./.' .�" . ,jg ' � .,,ii,,,, ' y . ea � n3 � a. . Zi.f " � r � ° - A : ; , .,r �} 5 s s=, f-t',.; 1 ' '.;'Al iii '::: ., -. t I Ii. .4' ' ',,,..:'' 4.7•.i`. .,.;,-,. . " ��;a . r ;. 1 '' gyy. 4-,....1‘ I$d L-:x .pt9 "' '� 2y�'1 .;� 3 ♦ r e '"`' a a-.f$ 'off •:' a .'T { a <. .x ' i`. fit" r _�°`� §, a,Ye may .?d 1 .. p t*`.,j 3 ,, 8 ,'. ,tea.- )a.. .' '1. .`2,,7" 7'..- '-.''=i '''' 4 ., o� P ' :::;4"2:i.,ro is. t � ei 1::tpr.. ','!'141.:-:...,,,...,,....-::::.....iii.:,',.7:::,:,'...:„....,,,c,.....-.,.. yy 4 �aa. a4.. '.';',..,°-'40.*''' f '3 41./,‘•77.10,g,-,,...., ..(4''.("..N„(..,, , , • ,, ......1,,c./.., ., , ,, *,1,-1.,• , ''''';‘:' * 1::' '-.'.::: tli .... ' -. w t� Arw file/ -fi+ i ,t?* (( __.... .1. .�. w.sus_ 1d.__......,.ta�.`m"a '_� 1. .__.'`.,�®Ff _• ♦.. .* Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of three sheds located in backyard P r �, ,.7..k, 1.4. a � rV ./I*' .. 'v0i .As:"4 ir'19#' ' „,,,,,;-, Nle .,•,,.' Alt 1$,,,,,t1144 ,40 . Aill,\,44., •.\ $44,„ , i r . - * :::::%• k _r ♦t i" r �Mf '" µ yr• t��i , , r�, ` '• ,' • ` ' tf 1 .A ► • ' +• * x ' .P.{y ' . �*,,� ' rIA• -• .1 1gg! W'• ..i.s , am+ ,V .4? r .^'� , y . _,i • • z ♦a . •Nit � !'w.i i�i ,Sf 0. A, !.w `l'Sof Fy•" NA\ .'''., .,k Alibi ,•� Q �f • . . IT ♦ ry - �t c{ ' • ,t,d� f� «' " t t '` ., i , ittA 3 14,4°.,,. 11 W ,.°x'i !i.• i Imo „ c y , : . .... . ;..8'.:. .. ''.446-6t,..'•-* 0407 41444/14‘ 1 ,p,. Y Il \ 3, , 4\:,,,. � / 3t n,..,♦ X Li 3 1 t .. r .,l.:a1 e wr i,tip.. 'ry ' >*„.,�. /11; r a 1 e * '. . # *";"I: .„.,„, . #‘ ii 2. \ '� • /mow '�'`�3 `, ,y} • y�. •# ‘ 1 i 4 \ r r r.�f 7/fr1 1 a� r ° 4 ♦ #- iv, , '..,\.•ikeir 44 ,, ,, . *.o.- 4.* '''' 1::` '.• t .-7 *e!!!..\ �t • �y ! r v. e m all,- 4 f � Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of three junk vehicles located in back yard y ., yam, .�'" d�y a a r f .7 f. aa�wt Yli� a� r'++�' "*• 4 6:164r., 4 . • . . 00 Ve6t, , \ . .. . :1:4 I I";*'......„. : ;0,,,iL It':''''. , * • , A:,,, : i ,,, ,/ ., .s:::; ' ' .."04::::.;,:#,,i73,---,,,.,, . —...1"""s".. 4-- ''''. ..4, ,,,c,m,„,,,,,,,,,,,,.. _ , i ,..,,, i , . .,,...,;.*:m.. itlit,,,,,..:„., ,..,,,,,, ,4 ,,, ,. 'a."'" 0.1//ii'. . ' . • .., y ,,,, ,, ,.. s•• ,,,..., „,,,,, 1, , , * / , „de..4 • Or. .'.„,.‘ •., . `'4,400"" «s. « , xf, ..;!-- fit' .,,,,:- t,,lcNI'AN:,.. tc„-g- ' k i r , ..» y � ..yw wy.w a I..«,,�w s , x er yid a t * xa�• q y. y .: - ,. '12 ,, ,, ,, A\ • ..,, ,,;„ il % 4 r ► % 4 „` % .,.. joie ,.., ,t.• • ..„.„.„,,,„1141-4:' . e + 6 a* .., 0 ,0„,,a. * ,,, »sF - ,,'fir s;' .p as ,r ,,... . • t ,, .„ i .., .. .... . mm a , ,. . N 1 i i 4 1.*:14',A -.i.':'''''''''''',..,/.1:'1 "; � Mame ..-r+ a • i A '''''a. ire a ' ^ A , ,' i� N. P, e m '). ..aria• r, ilb 4 4 1't. I<Y Z d S # „. it Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of three junk vehicles located in back yard ' , ,'M " ! ° '._. ,; ... .+ e4". �" � ;�'.,y+„Sr- ia+ ..„i�;�, rFr '"LTi' tt' +, ^�1.s 4 41,,� �. 1 —r 1. '4 '. �x' y * t �# .r ~' yr "1 ,$, y w' ♦"fit,.., 1,' ,gyp ''� 1,* k - fan }�' 'd y]j • / .*s."3.,' .4e f"►d r r } f( ? i I • �♦ A - i !4w - .4e r."-# 4,,x.:-- --.ai; 4 . �� '� t.. y C f% f `1 6 •� / fes'.• f� i !1 # . ;, .: ...., / 4, i fie 4' . 1 1 �. r € 3+ ;;!..77111.14514' ;111"14 .4++w�”, '' '•` �/ 4 40. w v R'r -t# � � ' �+�.u.-..r,�,,F fes' a t r y+ ♦ AS t ♦ t ♦ 1 ''< f ,� itki* ' w' e wo. ,, , t ;µ �' �_ ' ♦ y L C • ' :�. ' :w �e r a may , , ..x "'" . .. Ofirt Ili ♦ b a I . �, „ fey. a w • FrxMM a n 3, t ` y, M Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of three junk vehicles located in back yard Exhibit (5) \ �s� r, r yd � �{ .r f t ,�t r �„i',w* a•� '^, z,,t � �t R ttt�r r d �""'�+9I f�! ' t. '}d T �. .r + � � •,',' ..:,'1,;-- ",37),',,o',":",. '..'°" ,�`aeLi. 1�y� � I: 4 p-, 9! E - dk_s ` .: dd y-` k, td yam,"' ', % # f �, �,€`', g g' ta .9 yr. i s '+' .11! ,. ',apt -1, 4- "4 ,!II• t e • • °� wg��1, a `f 444, b R y { tom` it ✓'- • w t y q,' ,:....,,,.., .A. :;,,,I, , .,,, 44- ,I.,,,,;‘. i "T.,..,.-„,,o,ii ,, yr te'.'' , ..1,,,,,..:',14,' ,,,_ „ ' ,,, , , ,.. , ',I. \ I,',' 1 ,' .,';?,':4, .:.::,:tr ,,,,•;.: '1.-149:. kit 4,/ Y• •. . tf•'4., 1 \ — -ri * N • �`:7 ' R'iR f , t, ILII + $ t"'fF, , I k k W .9 f ¢ t r., _ § ',. t is ' ',.. 'N'r 'k , ; ,. . f,', � t7d f*,rt et .st „,..,..,,e,,,,,,,:: d < rc „• +,. �. J ; i, tom' h • ,tl a a .4. { c4 ''4� t 1 . -C,„.-,:r!.;„7:' �,6k [t .4 J. 1 M I 0 � r^ 31 i Y y .d r v ti..u.� y„�_ ♦ ” e eb. .vf w• 1. ,4 i '� � .1� w , *' s r *.d 4:, ,. mac j a } t • • a k_ t —.NV.- .'"t. y �f >''^d'.C,i Or - 'k',st o” -v"-i i 1 ,,,..„..,to,„ t w {' „'R' '.7& ,f yya . .dy Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 Bin located along southside fence 0,,,et1 TiF 'V8§ .,.'^,41.: e � u- .i wr ..xFaayrF �rr . ..- i. - •/r x +� . 4 Y ,r1 .4,....4.'%i • .fir I w I -. �Ii•/► ..,&t y" ..,„„,:„.,...;;,,,,... ../ to £ �- ..• � "4 'ar-.; ..,♦ ,. , b ox.! # �.` •;,1tJ.:Aitit. if/ i!i., ., ,:-.. -., is /�` • �� .k .,,.:,..',:,ir',.:',:: ,� a . kgk? ' ,,,,„orstt. , ) 24� ,' >' .'tea`? .s g 1,„..„ ., ,. 4 .....„1„,•*,....t..• . . ., z x 99�""" .• , ,:: ..e. . .14:1,-„Eit , i .. ,v ^"�5i t• ....„ ,,,,, ,,a ..... ....,• :„. ....441, , flg i .� 'i ,d rte . ?.:41:: }*. ♦ -` sire .. +4 � { w { 9 litr dra04 4.,..', Y4 m i' ' ks «.. / S T $ ...••. , ;''--, ' : . .,, . 1,,,,,,,„:...:..„,,.,,,,,,...,,,v,. a F .tom .f1 I wF y- six >t � , Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 Rubbish and debris along back of house zoig ? -1:,,,c , 14,,„;•,,,,,,A.,, 1,li..,4.0 4 i i%*t^v.,,.sib- ',IN:s,..4"4" ,,:"/ '. �wj °�+ + � s� F�� *1�: ~^ s. �=«'��°~ 7 ', 'mss .-. 4. 107 ilf:.: (4,:f '. ' ,'lie 41 40* ''''t Nti011 4e.... 'I — *1 - 'E7 ' — ' I 4p ¢ 4 'J � l # F �•� ~ .`''' . -4" If Ali, ,O• ' *# 4...,,**ine,t s , Soi /jot . • , �' 3 �` P ". nti33 . w J.`0 _ 4kill x [ r iF {p \ +.',,: ,.lt, . ..%. i ' 1 '."44f ;:' / . 1,,,,, ' :-P,:., .. -v A:A, _A ., .,,,,,k.#, ..- ;8.4,, . ..A.:,. ,-..... , ...4, . .„ ' . , , ., .. g, . . ,..,. ; .040 ..,,,0i/ t. ‘4,1I.:-8- � ' ."' I # E 3 [/1 / p tom.. :1 1:.;,. , '"" ri . ;. ,, T:' 4iv.iiIrti "' ,fit, 104, :$ , ,::: ',/--•04141 f,',/,,,",;1;1', , ....?. li; .A.:;'J.:....•, -il.Y.A.,,,, ;!,.,, 4$4' ; , .• -. . • - ,% ' . ' ; ' ' .77 . .: ., !.* it. 1",� •1 s- "� 1" r; ', ,I (�,�! r- rJr! •?s AI, n .,,. .:*-y'i ,._ $..'.: '.. --..: k.: . . iir , :.., - 4 .,0-111 tili 1.- •,,,. 1 .lit-7 " N., . '''''''''.'",';';''''' ':*''''''1'''''''''; .,::,:ti's 114';:', 7'..:-•;::"; .' ,., -.0.—,:... ....,..1`,..:. . t. .'-' ,.., l p/r'.' . ' 4 • r ii: q'$� + ''- e u xfi E' R R 3 *444 w as f t w +IY ..� .. 51i a,' " • nK""cn`ft� T 1:',.$s° " ' R' 41 ! fi k „a+y�.•r..., y, Mi' ,£gam€ X. ..� 11 ,. ... .. Nr / t1 , , .....A. t.. s� 1 ' i."; .1f., — a b . , c Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 Rubbish and debris along northside fence q�— �; 4 4 „ ..�" `i�•ey `,R R" } -t✓il' :.1. . aF, ' v-..4 � �- f �♦ �s { yy ' "2 4 >.Jn_ 4 *` ' 4 I T J �a .. a4, ' , ,.� t44 ry •••22' .. .. [zl i 4k‘t 9» .t y�,f z � y, ..2'2•••244� �t24.,,,•:•' ,.Y;,+ '":44.,/S,.*.rt.- w ay..,'ie ,�!`a ,....„2„1,,,, -;.„,,...4,:.,s,*"w4a '^' ♦` � + r `,+'y. .j" i t I '. a fit` 5 .,S,. y 44"' .$2.2.7'7 5.4 1, -tet` +,'4 • 4:: ' ' ,,, ,itirt. ..a s.. % t .,.a ' 3g'y w `1.; ti E ,� ,s � icy '� Vp�r� a, ,�4 .�.T K1.*� µ s,w4 . ,, :: p Irk � ' + ! + 4.j...� -- 8 y - 1%* i , *ifs ' ,# a°x^ • f. 4 v i #i �i- ' dd 1 r�L1' . f`rp 71 # �' �tj$��.'�A. � t ' t��'t J1r�' _sY�. ,, �1. ♦ �" e.' r /s y +` t 4 •x � 4"•''' 4$ 2 '1'0/ "*I'•,2••., * Z+`x., : 1IN' 5 .rte 3 t { j]� ' 2 4'44 ,�aw'x;�., ° ;.T it 1 1 % ',J u 1, e a. 1 i y�{ ` -' ..44‘ ri e R ..�y 1"iea "t 2� -d ♦� % K '� " _i., yi.'T w ."'";.%"41'''a''' ;.w•,,. `'r-y r.,t�'yom�, ..:4. •'` x y ry,,�r L.� o , , t t' ray '4,, 1,,,- ♦ "M 4P3 9r �.;"4 c X11 i t 4. ^. 8,.. .y....,,„.:'.44'`4 1 t" * �b.° ,..,� z . , ',,,,5rsk", w 1 1,111' i k''8- _ "> „it . flo ii- 'f :�., y4. �• '� ..i�..L,A oye•r '� i '44 a ��, µ s y r;# • 1. w ` 9�...,, •_ f 3.;INt '. , "thrs •� , ' .,2222•Z ./tea,' F ,,. •0 '".. ! ,`R.+ 1 fir`. .. *. .w t'7411'„ �Mi� l+.'. ',, p �' a iM ft f' �.ai 4, '' �•4„ a -,'', ,,' v�t .4! �, e t , r �3 '404.10'74.'ro�-1;* "4 4'"..`. . ,s. , ... k + — gip,„61. j��, ,e, ,.,y. _�. ,ssAmot, •-•••*. '.--. ';,.p * r,7 . ..� .r , 1 ' � -,,r ' �air + ” .1!... ' ,� Si & ... }s 2r." , .• • ".••L ..r • "t ' ''•'.2 ,_ ..74 ? A*., , fit li t ' 1314014% q fi •+h .w.r t - ,w ,, � rte, �.F -• e.. r. ,41.x. •,� ,,. t c• � :, ♦ .. z ;.� <:; .. '4444.'•3►•`, ..� ..,� L .,.u`e.•ej�.1/ "'�.• +w/'«E�. ,c • r Backyard of 598 Seaspray - 5 March 2001 One of several covered piles located throughout Exhibit (6) PS Form 3800,April 1995 - 0 d 2 F N o fD N o (/)o N o o C • r f„3 a w. m CO m p H n OO CDC p m a B. nn c° F,, mfD D.w d w cn !i c7) 0-51 ,2 o CD 9. • _ mOnmm m , - D 7" 7 CL On March 7, 2001 )-2 T su W � N Mr. James Baker W �� 598 Seaspray Ave Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Subject: Atlantic Beach Code of Ordinances, Chapter 12: Nuisances, Chapter 21: Traffic & Motor Vehicles and Chapter 24, Zoning and Subdivision Regulations. Dear Mr. Baker, Tax Records indicate that you are the owner of the following property: Re: 598 Seaspray Ave A/k/a: 35-64 17-2S-29E Seapray Lot 33, Blk 4 RE# 170703-0432 Consider this letter as an official Notification of Violation. On October 19, 2000,the City's Code Enforcement Officer identified the property commonly known as 598 Seaspray to be in violation of several City Codes. These violations were for the accumulation of excess refuse and abandoned vehicles. A Courtesy Notice of Violation was placed on the front door of 598 Seaspray Ave. On October 26, 2000, a meeting with a Mr. Marvin Baker, who identified himself as your brother and caretaker of the property, was held. During the meeting, an inspection of the property was conducted, several violations were identified, and Mr. Marvin Baker agreed to correct the violations over an unspecified amount of time, with monthly progress checks. Over the last four months, several attempts were made to verify that progress, with no results. On March 5, 2001, Mr. Marvin Baker escorted the City's Code Enforcement Officer to verify what had been accomplished to bring your property into compliance. While there had been some progress in removing the accumulated refuse, additional violations were identified and additional refuse had been deposited elsewhere on your property. The rate of progress in bringing your property into compliance and the additional refuse found on your property is unacceptable. The following violations have been identified and must be corrected within thirty (30) days • . of receipt of this letter: City Ordinance: Chapter 12, Nuisances, Sec 12-1 (1) (2) (3) - Refuse accumulation. 1. Remove all refuse from property. City Ordinance: Chapter 24, Accessory Uses and Structures, Sec 24-151 (3)f—More then one accessory building. 2. Remove all sheds erected without a permit, only one shed per property permitted. City Ordinance: Chapter 24, Building Permits, and Sec 24-65 - Building Permit—No building permit for accessory building. 3. Provide or obtain a permit for any existing sheds on the property. City Ordinance: Chapter 21, Traffic & Motor Vehicles, Sec 21-24 (b) Accumulation of inoperative vehicles. 4. Make all inoperative automobiles operational or remove from property. No further extensions will be granted. Furthermore you are reminded of your responsibilities as a property owner and that failure to comply will constitute a violation of city code. Continued violations can incur fines of up to $500.00 per day, per violation from the Code Enforcement Board. Should you have any questions or concerns involving this matter, you can contact me at (904) 247-5855. Sincerely, ALEXANDER J. SHERRER Code Enforcement Officer SENDER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1, 2,and 3.Also completetem 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. A. Received.by(Please Print Clearly) B. Date of Delivery i .. . ■ Print your name and address on the reverse.- f-4 so that we can return the card to you. C. Signature Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, ❑ or on the front if space permits. X Agent `A// c 0 Addressee 1. Article Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different from item 1? 0 Yes If YES,enter delivery address below: 0 No spza .A= �_A o [7 5��3 3. Service Type ��L, 1 0 Certified Mail 0 Express Mail 0 Registered 0 Return Receipt for Merchandise 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D. 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes . Article Number(Copy from service label) a � -e/ aik g s s- S Form 3811,July 1999 Exhibit (7) 1 4 . �`, ! ,•t' _ CITY OF Mt i: '.io ,Iiii ioiik tkicustcc Eeetd - evlida 716 OCEAN BOULEVARD P.O.BOX 25 ' ATLANTIC BEACH,FLORIDA 32233 r4,. . ;3 r TELEPHONE(904)249-2395 February 28, 1989 , Mr. James W. Baker 598 Seaspray Avenue Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 Dear Mr. Baker, Our records indicate that you are the owner of the following property in the City of Atlantic Beach, Florida: Lot 33, Block 4, Seaspray RE: 170703-0432 (CRS010000040) 598 Seaspray Avenue Investigation of this property discloses and we have found and determined that the property is in violation of Chapters 12 and 21 of the Code of Ordinances of the City of Atlantic Beach in that junked or inoperable vehicle(s), automobile parts, and miscellaneous items are being improperly stored. All such items must be stored completely within an enclosed building and not be visible from the street. Further we have determined that a violation exists of Chapter 23 • in that excessive weeds, underbrush and/or other growth is exceeding a height of twelve (12) inches along the western portion of the property. We ask that you take immediate corrective action to remedy the situation and continue to maintain your property on a regular basis. Than y. . _ r your cooperation. 41 CI Y OF ATLAN , BEACH CODE ENFORCE OFFICER cc: file o6` le o RESOLVED 4 e CITY OF • "r��+l�e�r a V...W.IIY (NptrvW ,I 800 SEMINOLE ROAD - ATLANTIC BEACH,FLORIDA 32233-5445 TELEPHONE(904)247-5800 FAX(904)247-5805 • June 18, 1992 ; Dalr� YI =eac , L 32233 "o1 r Dear Sir" : / it, This letter is to confi, our conversation of June 15, 1992. You have agreed in this conversation to have the grasp: cut at 598 Seaspray Avenue within seven (7 ) days. You have also agreed to have the following vehicles repaired and/or updated license plates on them within thirty (30) days: 1965 Ford Van 1970 Chrysler New Yorker 1970 Volvo Station Wagon 1977 Ford LTD 1978 Dodge Also you have agreed that you will clean the pool in the rear yard of your property. Please contact me at 247-5826 if you have any questa cans_ regarding this matter. I will inspect this property again on July 14, 1992. Thank you again for your cooperation in this matter. Sincerely, C Don Ford i Code Enforcement Officer DCF/pah cc : City Manager . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13 : 43 : 58 cMR001 Ci en Complaint Management $ tem FMTA Complaint # : 0000928 �,omplaint Date : 93/08/18 __ne : 14-19-13 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant MONTE DEBBIE Address 5 SEASPRAY City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) 246 - 675- Complaint TypeTRA TRASH ACCUMULATING IN REAR YARD Location SEASPRAY City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property Owner Compliance Y Dept/Division30 8 Priority Code . . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart • 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:29:23 CMROO1 Ci an Complaint Management : tem FMTA Complaint # : 0000985 complaint Date: 93/09/27 _me : 16-52-32 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant MR MONTE _ Address 596 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) 246 - 675 Complaint Type. . . NUS JUNK IN REAR YARD Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerJAMES BAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionTO 8 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by PHARRIS Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13 : 39 : 31 CMR001 Ci .en Complaint Management tem FMTA Complaint # : 0001002 ,.omplaint Date : 93/10/11 _ _me : 13-35-49 4 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant GRUNEWALD Address CAB CEO City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint Type. . . CAR ABANDONED LINCOLN 4DR BLUE FL HCG79U EXPIRED 12-92 Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property Owner Compliance Y Dept/Division30 8 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13 :51:33 CMR061 Ci en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0002844 --mplaint Date : 95/06/09 ne : 8-56-57 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant GRUNEWALD Address CAB CEO City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint Type. . . VEG HIGH GRASS AND WEEDS Location 598 SEASPRAY City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerBARER Compliance Y Dept/Division10 8 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart - 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:30 :50 CMR001 Ci en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0005296 .,umplaint Date: 96/10/22 _1e: 15-44-45 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant MONTE DEBBY Address SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint Type. . . VEG HIGH GRASS AND WEEDS IN REAR YARD Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerBAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionTO 6 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:20: 17 CNROG1 Ci en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0006258 .,umplaint Date: 97/06/06 __1e: 8-37-48 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant ANONYMOUS Address City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint Type. . . CAR TOYOTA, CORONA,GOLD, LXR48X FL 1994 Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerBAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionI0 6 Priority Code . . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:52 : 30 CMR001 Ci en Complaint Management $ tem FMTA ' Complaint # : 0006257 ,,,,mplaint Date: 97/06/06 _Ile : 8-34-19 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant ANONYMOUS Address City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint TypeTRS CARPETING AND OTHER ITEMS STORED IN FRONT OF GARAGE Location 598 SEASPRAY City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerBAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionI0 6 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:32 :27 CMROC1 Ci en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0006599 ,..,mplaint Date : 97/08/11 le : 16-26-59 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant MONTE AL Address 596 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) 246 - 675Z— Complaint 75wComplaint TypeTRS WORK # OF COMPLAINANT ABANDONED VEHICLES,TRAILER IN FRONT YARD,WEEDS,VEHICLE IN FRONT YARD BEING USED FOR STORAGE OF CLOTHING Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerJAMES BAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionTO 6 Priority Code . . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13 : 50 : 11 C'MR0C1 Ci en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0007491 .,.,mplaint Date : 98/03/31 _ 1e : 14-53-47 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant HARTKMEYER STEVE Address 455 HELMSMAN DR City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) 398 - 7334 Complaint TypeCAR ABANDONED VEHICLES IN FRONT OF HOUSE TRAILER TRASH Location 598 SEASPRAY City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerBAXTER Compliance Y Dept/Division1-0 6 Priority Code . . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13 :21:55 GMR001 Cil en Complaint Management S :em FMTA Complaint # : 0007518 .,.,mplaint Date: 98/04/02 _ __le: 15-47-01 r Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant CAB Address CEO City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Complaint Type. . . TRS CHAP 12-1-7 TRASH AND DEBRIS STORED IN FRONT YARD CHAP 12-1-3 HIGH GRASS AND WEEDS W. SIDE OF FRONT YARD CHAP 24-13-2 HOUSE TRAILER STORED IN FRONT OF FRONT FRONT YARD SET BACK LINE Location 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property OwnerJAMES BAXTER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionTO 6 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart . 10/19/00 City of Atlantic Beach 13:34 : 10 t0C1. Cit :n Complaint Management S: am FMTA Complaint # : 0008574 �umplaint Date: 99/08/30 14-07-40 Sfx Last Name First Name MI Complainant MONTE DEBRA Address 596 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) 246 - 675 Complaint TypeNUS BACK YARD IS TRASHED Location 598 SEASPRAY AVE City/State/ZipATLANTIC BEACH , FL - Phone/Extn ( 904 ) - Property Owner. JAMES W. BAKER Compliance Y Dept/DivisionTO 6 Priority Code. . . . 0 Taken by KARLGRUN Enter=Validate F1=Help Window F2=Investigation Screen F3=Exit F9=Print F12=Restart Exhibit (8) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA NOTICE OF HEARING OCTOBER 26 , 1993 JAMES W. BAKER 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE ATLANTIC BEACH, FL. 32233 Dear MR. BAKER: The Code Enforcement Board of the City of Atlantic Beach was created pursuant to Florida Statutes and exists for the purpose of facilitating the enforcement of the Code of Ordinances. It is comprised of seven citizens, residents of Atlantic Beach, who meet regularly to hear allegations of code violations. You are hereby notified and ordered to appear at the next public hearing of the Code Enforcement Board on Tuesday, the 9TH day of NOVEMBER, 1993 AT 7: 30 P. M. at Atlantic Beach City Hall, 800 Seminole Road, to answer and be heard to the alleged violation (s) of Section(s) 12-1-7 - (OPEN STORAGE NOT PERMITTED) of the Code of the City of Atlantic Beach. It is alleged that you are in violation of the above enumerated code section(s) in that there exists on the premises located at 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE, ATLANTIC BEACH, FL. condition (s) : OPEN STORAGE NOT PERMITTED . The Code Enforcement Board has the power to levy fines up to $250 . 00 per day, against the property, if a violation is found to exist beyond the date set by the Board for compliance. You have the right to obtain an attorney at your own expense and to present witnesses in your behalf. If you desire to have witnesses , subpoenaed or if you have questions regarding the procedure, please contact Trudy Lopanik, Secretary of the Code Enforcement Board within five days of the receipt of this notice at 247-5821 . Please note the presence of a court reporter for the purpose of insuring a verbatim record in the event of an appeal should be secured at your expense. Sincerely, _67e_e_e-2.4 *. eorge Eg. Martin Vice Chairman, Code Enforcement Board I CODES ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH ''// RECEIPT OF NOTIFICATION I , f,.�A R L f'(/, e',,FvrvEGc...-4 /Csved notification to: JAMES W. BAKER at 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE ATLANTIC BEACH or Atlantic Beach, Florida this � day of , 1993 . at e A.M. • .M This notification was in reference to: A NOTICE OF HEARING of the Codes Enforcement Board to appear at its meeting of NOVEMBER 9 , 1993 . Signature of Server: Yr 4 % --t _ ,� Signature of Receiver: 4207,/ftiJ % '7 z ' Dated: / // a/y'3 Please return to the City Clerk' s Office. Thanks t CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA CASE NO. 0062 RE: VIOLATION OF SECTION 12-1-7 OF THE ATLANTIC BEACH CITY CODE. LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOT 33, BLOCK 4 , SEASPRAY, RE#170703-0432-2, (ALSO KNOWN AS 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE) The Code Enforcement Board has heard testimony at the Code Enforcement Board hearing held the 9TH day of NOVEMBER 1993 , and based on the evidence, the Code Enforcement Board enters the following FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW, FINDINGS OF FACT James W. Baker was found to be in violation of Section 12-1-7. The Board agreed to grant Mr. Baker 30 days , until December 10, 1993 , to bring the property into compliance to the satisfaction of the Code Enforcement Inspector. If the property is not brought into compliance by December 10, 1993 a fine of $50 . 00 per day shall be levied against James W. Baker. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW There was competent, substantial evidence presented to support a finding of a violation of the Ordinance Code as charged. ORDER It is the Order of this Board that JAMES W. BAKER shall comply with Paragraph Two, Findings of Fact, as stated above. If JAMES W. BAKER does not comply within the time specified, he shall pay a fine of $ 50. 00 per day for each day the violation continues to exist. If N/A does not comply within the time specified, a certified copy of this Order, together with a Claim of Lien, shall be recorded in the public records of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court in and for Duval County, and once recorded shall constitute a lien against the property upon which the violation exists, or if you do not own the land, upon any other real or personal property owned by you, pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes. Upon complying, JAMES W. BAKER shall notify the Code Enforcement Officer who shall inspect the property and notify the Board of compliance. Should a dispute arise concerning compliance, either party may request a further hearing before the board. DONE AND ORDERED THIS 9th DAY OF NOVEMBER , 1993 . � l 9 .• Sec. George E. Ma tin, Chairman Code Enforcement Board CITY OF teaottfc &ad - 9eauda 800 SEMINOLE ROAD 4 . -,- __-_ �- ATLANTIC BEACH,FLORIDA 32233-5445 TELEPHONE(904) 247-5800 Ok FAX(904)247-5805 October 14 , 1993 Mr . James W . Baker - 598 Seaspray Avenue Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Dear Mr . Baker : Our records indicate that you are the owner of the following described property in the City of Atlantic Beach, Florida: 598 Seaspray Avenue a/k/a/ Lot 33, Block 4, Seaspray RE#170703-0432-2 Investigation of this property discloses and I have found and determined that the following City of Atlantic Beach Ordinances are in violation: Section 12-1-7 (Open Storage Not Permitted) (See Enclosure) As prescribed in Florida Statute 162 .06(3) (Enforcement Procedure) this is a repeat violation. You will be notified by certified mail when to appear before the Code Enforcement Board. Under Florida Statute 162 . 09 the Code Enforcement Board may impose fines up to $500 . 00 per day for a repeat violation. Sincerely, /'./- l /P/7, v7/CLQ Karl W. Grunewald Code Enforcement Officer K47G/pah cc : City Manager Don C . Ford VIA HAND DELIVERY • • CITY OF ' ,;:� iVeleuttic 'e e - vara 800 SEMINOLE ROAD °'•�j _ - ATLANTIC BEACH,FLORIDA 32233-5445 • 4t TELEPHONE(904)247-5800 FAX(904)247-5805 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I , Karl W. Grunewald , hereby certify that I delivered a notice to James W. BAker at 598 Seaspray Avenue Atlantic Beach; FLorida 32233 , this //:5/ day of October , 1993 atj4 ' �O O' clock ? M. This notification was in reference to CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH Code Enforcement re violation of Section 12-1-7 SIGNATURE OF SERVER: �/ _ - SIGNATURE OF RECEIVER: r.� �'�/. �i�f`L ''• /15 DATED: ��/77 • CITY OF ALTANTIC BEACH COMPLAINT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM TAKEN (date/time) : / j9 3 / COMPLAINANT: ��j ADDRESS: Last Name First Name MI CITY/STATE/ZIP: 4 -8 C TELEPHONE: ( ) 79/ _ COMPLAINT: ",; " • /(--1/S e , TTvi LOCATION: \J-Y5- PROPERTY y5- PROPERTY OWNERS PHONE: ( ) _ PROPERTY OWNERS NAME: DEPARTMENT FORWARDED TO: COMPLAINT TAKEN BY: DATE/TIME: i OFFICE USE ONLY - INVESTIGATED: (date/time) /.7777 3 ASSIGNED DEPT. /-DIVISION: / /d._ � PRIORITY: INVESTIGATOR: �7 CONDITIONS FOUND: a,„7-- 49,4/ SOU /lii Tf7` ?/yPe�i4 l �L j ACTION TAKEN: 4 " r, �7/ COMPLIANCE: NOTES: • CITY OF ALTANTIC B ,FIIr1 n « COMPLAINT EACH g4.A I LI , MANAGEMENT SYSTEM >; (. a 1 A 1993 TAKEN (date/time) : /Q / `{/ q3 /0 /5 Building and Zoning COMPLAINANT: • 1410t4-f.Q- fi ,p.I Last ADDRESS: ' q� Name ,4�P First Name MI CITY/STATE/ IP: _ / r44,,,E--,� , f '• .5_1...13 3 TELEPHONE: (q0"-{) -)4(.. - (0 7 5 cx>c42 K 7 q I C. ..2_ COMPLAINT: lAJ / Oc7D I I /A 4e/ ate Q J vAlk_ fief 6) N/2973 / TEe /•Oil as i) il-N 1 el-6' e / LAS%y6% {ie 6 _,)14,3 her' /7 �illfia`e Lite/t) /(e Pv% &A -, , Fe jc e i� . �� :cktA z td` /4,,, G Z fjib C� �,, - D� : (� Ia� � 4 . t s v, - s/iexr tk4/ LOCATION: Cd �/ 4'e441.,- PROPERTY OWNERS - G PHONE: ( ) _ ;2;,74� PROPERTY OWNERS NAME: ' DEPARTMENT FORWARDED TO: COMPLAINT TAKEN BY: DATE/TIME: • OFFICE USE ONLY -- — INVESTIGATED: (date/time) ASSIGNED DEPT. /DIVISION: INVESTIGATOR: PRIORITY: 1 CONDITIONS FOUND: ACTION TAKEN: COMPLIANCE: -- -- — - — NOTES: — — -- •� Y .stir I •• ;', "i''':::‘ „iiiv--— I:a '� '''11P:',:".'.'"i'l'...-111111111:,• ._ x ..`; �_,. a, F• -r.••• }:• fit .7........• iv 4..' .e. .111....)44:.: :'1‘ �" ! '1 J/ I� t� 3 \ .,i,4 o �. wsy"y /['A '-.W,....., ` � f'4,.,:•;., . :•µ� z"� t'.•. • / .�. ♦ .:jam,Ilik i� �+!�• .. • � ':•'79t �`- �►":•rt� �� a��� I 4 , rR� �v� \ S(>7�l} b ' /C! 0. \ • '' '+�•' � ` , r , ` '. , rM � Illi I *,•t• ' •` ` ' \ `•.�`. •5 r 1 • �ar" . ?� ,t�• • 1'11 � „�• f ,A '�; r�< .ito ...i . ..1"/.19,-:..+-•:./4 .... . ... rc, •u 1 ,.+',71! � - �t • ..-,,e.::: wi. 71 '{. . am� :/,, . _. /= ! ' .�„�, �Y J v'_ !ti•' �` , � � �• \ F • '' -7 . ' - •- i 0 lis"v. '- !Fr do. ,N17 i .„... ,,,, -......*:::,...„......t, , . ...-.. .-, - ... . ::t. „ I 'V' - '• , ' ' Ac '', -'---- 'N •, •`� ..._.._�,--rter , r .• fil:a;01110.7';._ �1e,.� yi 'd"�1k �- �t't x ' ;:' ,. •9 __». !i 1: �� mac• ► !i . .4, .... .„ ,t,,,,..,.:,,, ,..:ti!.,i......A.,',w_:.7.1..,,,.'•,,c4,‘., .\,. ,.. - ,7_1?1`..-4,41,e'.-110.-: ' ' ' • t , • • • • r • ._ ., . , i.•,, I ;,...'• ,,i...,, i4. .i-- _ ., -7.., / I . ' . ..... 41:11:: ...,. •k. . um /v.-IV f 1 , 1 11 sik vs. ir - , 11 .• 1.1=111.111W ,t• ' -',1 • .• t•t.. • Mr• .11ZAISIOni 1 i......1• ali 1 • -.••-,t.,,,1324,I, ,Z.., :- li i.....0.,sem•, . .. - ,••.:.• , .a .. ye is rit.e:_-__ ,A . . . . . . , \ '' • • 5.i' 12 iris tali; 1'' 17 I., 7 I act,. . , _ . . , - - •.% - ' . -./4 , --!. ,,, ,s-..:• . 111111:111111 1,6 .- , ,',.- .7'- 7 ., , i i ,•••'7 I YAW-:* - ' '*`' ' ' ' - 4. - - , ... ' •""41111. • ik. ,n.mist./Z...,. •.;.1. , Lij‘.1.•Pl•47771.,)• '' ' #* ' ' '0" . i t' , 1,.--",14.4--- 7"-'\.,,.. -f' .1.• at,- - er ' '•-,,'• ‘, ' 6, '-, 11.;.? it' '__.......... -... ..i...•• fr - • ..,,,.. ......,,,11.3,4,__ zio.",7,,,,V51..„. , i..r.,,,,;.,....1...4K4 _4.....,,. _...,., .4.,....4t •' L \ %lig` r ,, - '-' .-...--;,--- -- t'• 4 7 ) 1,4; t .1 ., ,- - 4k..-4\:,r'"•••\-*.it.,o,-!• '' ' • •,‘ • N • , .1\11k,41.;-• : rut---.c•tnygnt,a---. ...4A A' , t illit .. ,N •1 ", -N,-'II•4'N, -12-,... .....,1-kVe-:12141' -/- i I! r . • \ \.„. , .,.. . ‘. . :IV/A ,..:-r...w.. , . .... .„,..-. • .,.. u ..„,,,... -.....7_zs_.2 •-ago, ' rft....., . `7•V. %.. \, N y .r.,,,, .'. N.:._..........44—...—-,,.-.• .;)t.'.4...;; 7.-1 r , . '-4•'-***/' - •:-.`,14,...- --e--, ..... - . . ..\\'''''' , ) 4 - 4.-5•• -*-4-.4- .A,• '''...• ..r..r..1.1 F.... 7.--- , •S, ' .. '. J.o. . it,,ed--..„•Ives,--. - ,F.4, .....i:::47.-.-.G•,-"..***.•,.''',-1 '' ' '- .-•,- Atagt.>t -• ..- ' __ ' ' 4.. --7 / C•••••-/"••;;‘..?'‘''''' -. '0...,4 ..,,,,Ci'ili. - -Ii14'C' . \ ..... „Ir it -...... ;••i'.:c.,:-*•'•• ,-- ' ;,.2••••I f .71 . ‘ - . -• ;-..r:' •••••• VI, ) .1.- - 4C.,k" ;.*:-.4 . ,.t...‘. , .. •,-2' • `'L'iti,3-4,-'.- , . , • .. '' '4 . \\ ,-. . .. ....I , -Z...V ..• ' ? - ..:.. -A,.-_..,-. -4 „ .-,..,,,, - I •_, pile. .. - -.--4.-• A.; .i461•4° - 01-' '• ,),If r, .." -' ' •. ''''''4,Atf.r 'fri• •,.i.i"'/,' "1-: 1qt' ."4"".""7- 4.--.;• V.' -4 ' -,-,-31/4- •%Pk'.$.3.ti_.--1 - .:-..'•' - „.??...,....,'...."..t... .1*-.,..,.,:sz . I.: .o- 7,%,% ,•„.;14,-. • ;;..; ir. tid."...- / • . - _,„tHm.1,214"P',50`..,..-",*.- •)„,_,-., _lir' - 7", t';11.-N:L';;;-it:tt..;-,;•". ' --- .„e07•74 il- .• .1°.-V11.;.-!:_!"`7. 0:';:.?..•..;22::,, .i..7.0s.. ..?;.7***••.kl,,,,64.:..1,...- , .1 / .. - - \ '1.. ,.. fr. • 7‘‘••••■;••• ..c: --'-*• '' k i '• ".. - elin • • ‘•.It ' ' 1Vb:2 'itst•r..-TN.• \ 16,' );\ ---;- •••, . ..., ,...... . . ,. • • ••,, ...,-Ile-- - ' 'it; - • - - ' % ' ig I .4 ..%1 •r- ..:1•, . A• 1 '' '1 ::_,k_v_,...•,:.)07 . ---r..-1... ..‘ ,, , \ 1., . ',11111111illif r• • •-141 ' ' •.• ',II, -„Ay,, . L'''''' ii ', 1 '' . 11'1 1.'IL I- ';C'l• i ' '',. '...1'6,'Ii'.'"-•.: s"• .1 i-• .‘ -:"--:. 5...”"''!. '.,..-r-i-.. • • '7' • ' ...: ' ....N 4'4::-1 )1• -.-.. -1-,"--'-T11411:::. -lii4410"'Ilif 1.4 • , ,----- , n\ : , •74SY' .. -- ••••IAIII4 • k t \ .......A .-. " '''. i ••• -'11r.. • 1 -\ ' .. IT \ ..-."..41`.•••• ': • i• * ' . ' I s. ,i. . i..11... ... .ir -,- 124 ii ../\, ,4 11%..._- •• ,•- .... • '• 7"•••• •. N • . • l• ...N.Z...!--' ir. -... - • ,i - • V / _ %. - •," ••••-• • ellies, tr..41' - 4: .. ' 1 -.41k s -,• • It :-. ,,:.-ts—......._,..— . • . r .. . ..... ... .. .......r•• . • .• - ewer' "'s," • . - • 414.. N.• . - T .11 '. '' • r:S,t"'• , • " ' , ' -,v- '. ,, . - - .'• 7 i _ ,......._.1._. ...._,..,1.,,....;,.... ...,•7,.:,:.:,71_.,.i-,,,,74,tt.,..9..,.,..... .:.,-., -.-t::„:4.-r--.>_,,,,,,,..._, ....0:‘ :.,..1.....,,,,,:, -V. -,. ..4, ,,,, •. \ --,• --, - 4-.. Aoci,,v,441.,-: *-'. 4, --,.../_• .4- '„, -- - / '• f . • •... .„ ..• - -,?- • :11. _4(.00)7".%'.• •.• . .4.,, •- .1•! •-:-•."--;;0-*•• • *7 • _ - .- _ •. ,.... . • • . ,.•:•:., .. ,-.,..i..„,-_-,..-.fr•-.nt-.•:.#.0:4';;;/•r. -- • • . .\•,...75.,,, .\-c4k 1 • • e 3 , i-4 . ,. t 4-it'...-' -. • • ....,.,,,_ ...1---- :. 5,..:-f..i,' •iTIL„..,1-- . . . ,.. ., .....- . ....... e.t.;•1,. .,..:4.-•;.1. . ....--'.,' 1'.,,:.e4-11.!".-1•.1,-.4...7,, .-.( ' .-'.'A'. ......:1r ..•-I+;2* ''"itI..TA :-'•tv-1 T:-.-,-'e,..e..••— . ...-•'';.,...'.,.4.".e•104::1-,..t-2..o..1....._;•r,.,t:.i.„r..e.• -.,'..-1, •-.'. . . i;' • , 1 • r13q/dir.. N.4.1,15”, .- • '..". A....,•.• ••••....i. ., , .45.."*. .• ,•-..•*I'Ar.si-.-:.A --r.- -..,•:,-,,.:. .1e-,-...-•*,i..- .v` • - ,. . " ' .1,., '••• ''''' - -'•. *-• t`114427.4.`,•''-r;%-' ..T.:' -..1.. i".4.r •4 i', ''''' Ai. ,.,g,-:, 1, •'.... ...4- ' ',..17,t Ait'-:.--.. '-"L."41-21-5., ..:-:trfr,-,.e.W.:-...v • - ... - . _- ...t.4 ... -, :II, • .-- • . •N.- •0. ,..v. iv,A-9,.....,-,..,,, • - •4!, ;- C '. =.., .i5..'?,..i...!.,117'''',". 3 ',..4::dim..2$14 •10.tiv.'z.p.;;Imi.• 4-4•••: ••- •. '• . •.' ..• „ -4, r - -. ' • - ,• -01 ... tt.,_ r , . . ./ o-iroo-0.4)-;-1,...i.- -- • -• ' .• , • ' - * • C•.P., -.' o' 1 .." •' tit . OZ,Sliiift .e.' , ili9-1' ' • / ' •-:../.;/*. :: i' ' •..'. ' - got -•.-• ,, ' " ! ' S. •#'.4.' • . . ii 4 ', I t• .' G ., ... . .. • .• "'"‹, r,....-.., ...,-._ , - ..,%-.-..• ,4- , p , s Exhibit (9) CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA CASE NO. 98-7518 RE : VIOLATION OF Chapter 12 . Sections 12-1-3 and 7 and Chapter 24 . Sections 24-163-2 OF THE ATLANTIC BEACH CITY CODE OF ORDINANCES . LEGAL DESCRIPTION: RE##170703-0432 . aka Lot 13 . Block 4. Seaspray (598 Seasprav Ave. e) The Code Enforcement Board has heard testimony at the Code Enforcement Board hearing held the ftth day of September , 1998, and based on the evidence, the Code Enforcement Board enters the following FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW: FINDINGS OF FACT Marvin Baker, representing his brother James Baker, owner of the property, was found to be a repeat violator in violation of Sections 12-1-3, 12-1-7 and 24-163-2 of the Code. The Board voted to assess a one time fine of $250 .00 against said property. If the property is found to be in non-compliance again, the Board voted to impose a $100 . 00 per day fine against said property from the day the property is cited until compliance is reached to the satisfaction of the Code Enforcement Official . The Board also voted to assess Mr. Baker $110 . 68 administrative costs . CONCLUSIONS OF LAW There was competent, substantial evidence presented to support a finding of a violation of the Ordinance Code as charged. ORDER It is the Order of this Board that Mr. Baker shall comply with Paragraph Two, Findings of Fact, as stated above. If N/A does not comply within the time specified, he shall pay a fine of N/A per day for each day the violation continues to exist beginning from the day the property is cited. If N/A does not comply within the time specified, a certified copy of this Order, or a Claim of Lien, shall be recorded in the public records of the Office of the Clerk of the Circuit Court in and for Duval County, and once recorded shall constitute a lien against the property upon which the violation exists, or if you do not own the land, upon any other real or personal property owned by you, pursuant to Chapter 162, Florida Statutes . Should a dispute arise concerning compliance, either party may request a further hearing before the board. DONE AND ORDERED THIS 8th DAY OF September , 1998 . Attest : Ottjx,u /0 /rL 4,1-14fr KEN RO OSSKE, Chairman Secretary Code Enforcement Board ` ..tiy�^;:.� , CITY OF ., ta°curt;C Fate( - Qevruda - yr 800 SEMINOLE ROAD 4 ATLANTIC BEACH,FLORIDA 32233-5445 TELEPHONE (904) 247-5800 FAX (904) 247-5805 SUNCOM 852-5800 September 14, 1998 Marvin Baker 598 Seaspray Avenue Atlantic Beach, FL 32250 Reference: Code Enforcement Board Meeting - September 8, 1998 Administrative Expenses and Fine for Case No. 98-7518- RE#170703-0432 Dear Mr. Baker: During the September 8, 1998 Code Enforcement Board Meeting you were assessed $110.68 for administrative expenses incurred by the City of Atlantic Beach in processing this case and fined a one time fine of$250.00. The amount is due and payable to the City of Atlantic Beach within thirty (30) days from the date of this letter. If not paid within thirty days,the $360.68 will become a lien against your property with interest of 10%per annum from the date of certification until paid. If you have any questions concerning these costs, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely, CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH Karl Grunewald Code Enforcement Officer KG/jmb Marvin Baker September 8, 1998 Code Enforcement Board Meeting 598 Seaspray Avenue Administrative Costs Assessed Atlantic Beach, FL 32250 Case #98-7518 - RE#170703-0432 Amount Due: $360.68 PLEASE ENCLOSE THE SECOND COPY OF THIS LETTER WITH YOUR PAYMENT. P. 'kT/o o j" City of Atlantic Beach J -1 ,-, 'CORVOP Code Enforcement Board Case Presentation C. B. Date: Sept.8, 1998 Defendant:_James BAKER Case # 98- -7518 Location: 598 Seaspray Ave Lot 33,BIk4, Seaspray RE # 170703-0432 Violation : Chapter 12, Sec 12-1-7 ( outside storage) Chapter 24, Sec. 24-163-2 ( recreational vehicle ) Chapter 12,Sec. 12-1-3 ( high grass and weeds) Owner Occupied: x Rental .. Homestead: yes x No_ Code Enforcement Board Members: 1 . Inspection of the above property revealed that a violation of the code of the City of Atlantic Beach is present. Ownership of the property was determined through the x tax records, a title search, Other 2. The nature of the violation is: 1 . Abandoned vehicles and travel trailer, High grass and weeds, outside storage. 3. Inspection of the property was prompted as a result of a complaint x Routine Inspection X 4. Notice of violation was issued to occupant x on April 3,1998 5. Notice was achieved by certified mail X hand delivery posting_ method of service meets with requirements of Fl S.S.162-12. 6. I did x speak with the owner X occupant X of the property. 7. The latest inspection was a result of following up and routine inspection. 1 f 8. The violation is still present X , in compliance 9. In order to achieve compliance, it is necessary to remove the Trailer, car and other items from the front yard as well as cut all of the vegetation. The rear yard must be cleared of all junk vehicles and other outside storage. 10. I do X Do not have photographs of the property and violations as they exist on the property. They represent a fair and accurate representation of the property at the time they were taken. 11 . I would estimate that 30 days would be sufficient time to correct the violation. Further comments: This property has been a continuing problem dating back to 1993. The Bakers have with regularity brought the property into compliance only to allow it to again fall into non compliance. There is located in the front yard a small travel trailer that violates Chapter 24, Sec 24-163-2, recreational vehicles must be stored behind the front yard set back line, this trailer has not been moved in years. There is a Dodge, Diplomat, White/Blue, Reg.J873987 FI Temp, Exp.4-30-98 stored in the front yard, the vehicle is filled with trash and appears to be inoperable on a public road. The vegetation is high and the property generally unkept. The rear yard has become a junk yard of cars and other items. Mr. Baker appeared before the board January 4,1994. This is a repeat violation. Recommendations: It is my recommendation that a one time fine be placed against this property in the amount of $500.00. That a time certain be stated for compliance with a daily fine of $100.00 per day if compliance is not meet in that time . That a Fine of $500 per day be noted should the property ever fall into non compliance again. Witness and Complainant: Mr. Al Monte, 596 Seaspray Ave. Karl W. Grunewald Code Enforcement Officer 2 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA NOTICE OF HEARING CASE NO. 98-7518 August 5, 1998 James Baker 598 Seaspray Avenue Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Dear Mr. Baker: The Code Enforcement Board of the City of Atlantic Beach was created pursuant to Florida Statutes and exists for the purpose of facilitating the enforcement of the Code of Ordinances . It is comprised of seven citizens, residents of Atlantic Beach, who meet regularly to hear allegations of code violations . You are hereby notified and ordered to appear at the next public hearing of the Code Enforcement Board on TUESDAY, the 8th day of September, 1998 AT 7 :30 P. M. at Atlantic Beach City Hall, 800 Seminole Road, to answer and be heard to the alleged violation(s) of the following Section(s) : Chapter 12 . Sections 12- 1-3 and 7 and Chapter 24. Section 24-163-2 of the Code of the City of Atlantic Beach. It is alleged that you are in violation of the above enumerated code section (s) in that there exists on the premises located at 598 Seaspray Avenue (RE#170703-0432, aka Lot 33 , Blk 4, Seaspray) in the City of Atlantic Beach, the following condition (s) : Travel trailer stored in front of the front yard setback line. abandoned Dodge Diplomat in front yard filled with trash and high vegetation (grass and weeds) on the property. The Code Enforcement Board has the power to levy fines up to $250 . 00 per day for the first offense and $500 . 00 for the second offense against the property, if a violation is found to exist beyond the date set by the Board for compliance . You have the right to obtain an attorney at your own expense and to present witnesses in your behalf . If you desire to have witnesses, subpoenaed or if you have questions regarding the procedure, please contact Julie Brandt, Secretary of the Code Enforcement Board, within five days of the receipt of this notice at 247-5821 . Please note the presence of a court reporter for the purpose of insuring a verbatim record in the event of an appeal should be secured at your expense . Sincerely, ATTEST: Xktfa`Z ECRETARY Ken Rogos e e Chairman, C de Enforcement Board Code Enforcement Administrative Charges for Presentation to the Board Pursuant tO F SS 162 . 07 (2) the following charges for prosecuting this case before the code enforcement shall be charged to each violator provided they be found in violation. Such costs may be included in a lien authorized under s. 162.09 (3) if not paid within 30 days. Case Number 7518, James Baxter, 598 Seaspray Ave. Code Enforcement Officer, $ 14.43 per hour x 3 hours= $ 43.29 $ 43.29 Prosecuting Attorney, $ 100.00 per hour x .5 hours = $ 50.00 $ 50.00 Code Enforcement Secretary , $ 9.83 per hour x 1 hour= 9.83 $ 9.83 Postage, Cert Mail , $ 2.52 x 3 = $ 7.56 $ 7.56 Total Charges $ 110.68 CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA, ) VIOLATION NO. 98-7518 Petitioner, ) vs . ) SUBPOENA • JAMES BAKER Respondent. ) TO: NAME: JAMES BAKER STREET 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE CITY ATLANTIC BEACH, STATE FL 32233 GREETINGS: YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to be and appear before the Code Enforcement Board of the City of Atlantic Beach, Florida at City Hall, 800 Seminole Road, Atlantic Beach, Florida on Tuesday, the 8TH day of SEPTEMBER 1998 at 7 : 30 . p. m. in reference to violation of Section (s) : 12-1-3 AND 7,AND 24-163-2 ABANDONED VEHICLES AND TRAVEL TRAILER STORED IN FRONT OF FRONT YARD SETBACK LINE, HIGH GRASS AND WEEDS IN FRONT YARD LOCATION OF VIOLATION: 598 SEASPRAY AVENUE Failure to appear subjects you to penalty of law. Dated this 5TH day of AUGUST , 1998 . CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA BY1 ebacnat Secretary (•-ZsAM - POLICE DEPARTMENT: AFTER THE NOTICE HAS BEEN DELIVERED PLEASE RETURN THIS RECEIPT TO THE CITY CLERK' S OFFICE. THANK YOU. CODES ENFORCEMENT BOARD CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH RECEIPT OF NOTIFICATION I, /94, .P/ served notification to: AL MONTE 596 SEASPRAY ATLANTIC BEACH, FL 32233 727 this /a day of 457, , 1998 . AT /7/ 0-r- 4"/P.M. This notification was in reference to: A NOTICE OF HEARING OF THE CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD TO APPEAR AT ITS MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 8, 1998 7 :30 P.M. CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS, 800 SEMINOLE ROAD, ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA. Signature of Server: / A Signature of Receiver: /5 7e of�� Dated: Please return to the City Clerk' s Office. Thank you.