Loading...
10-27-97 v CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH COMMISSION MEETING- October 27, 1997 AGENDA Call to order Invocation and pledge to the flag 1. Approval of the minutes of the Special Called Meeting of October 2, 1997 and Regular Commission Meetings of October 7 and 13, 1997 2 Recognition of Visitors: A. Tina Stogsdill 3 Unfinished Business: A. Authorize amendment to England, Thims & Miller contract to include additional permit work,if required, in connection with Howell Park drainage(Mayor Fletcher) B. Board Appointments - (Mayor Fletcher) (i) Recreation Advisory Board - one vacancy(4-year term) (ii) Tree Conservation Board - one vacancy(Partial term expires 1-31-99) C. Howell Park Review Committee report and action,if required, (Commissioner Borno) 4. Consent Agenda: A. Acknowledge receipt of Capital Improvement Projects Report, New Occupational License Report and Fire Department Report for the month of September(Department Heads) 5. Action on Resolutions: 6. Action on Ordinances: A. Ordinance No. 80-97-60 -Public Hearing and Final Reading AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, AMENDING CHAPTER 22,UTILITIES,ARTICLE II,WATERWORKS SYSTEM, SEC. 22-27, CHARGES FOR WATER SERVICE, SUBSECTION(2),CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY,AND ARTICLE III,WASTEWATER SYSTEM,DIVISION 7, SEWER USER RATES AND CHARGES, SEC. 22-166, ESTABLISHMENT OF A MONTHLY BASE CHARGE, SUBSECTION(b), CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY, AND SEC. 22-167, SCHEDULE OF WASTEWATER VOLUME CHARGES, SUBSECTION (b), CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY, TO EXEMPT FEDERAL, STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT SUBDIVISIONS AND AGENCIES FROM PAYING OUTSIDE RATES, AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE(Commissioner Meserve) Page Two AGENDA October 27, 1997 7. New Business: A. Authorize the City Manager to execute Utility Service Agreement between the City and Department of the Navy (City Manager) B. Award contract in the amount of$67,802.90, to Beach Construction Co. Inc., for Piping and Instrumentation at Well No. 4 at Water Plant No. 2, pursuant to the specifications of Bid No. 9798-2, and authorize the City Manager to execute the contract documents (City Manager) C. Discussion and possible action in connection with construction of a city greenhouse (Mayor Fletcher) D. Discussion and possible action in connection with a sculpture in Bull Park (Recreation Advisory Board) E. Status report and potential funding for Town Center(Mayor Fletcher) 8. City Manager Reports and/or Correspondence: 9. Reports and/or requests from City Commissioners, City Attorney and City Clerk A. Farewell remarks - Commissioner Rosenbloom Adjournment If any person decides to appeal any decision made by the City Commission with respect to any matter considered at any meeting, such person may need a record of the proceedings,and,for such purpose,may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made,which record shall include the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. Any person wishing to speak to the City Commission on any matter at this meeting should submit a request to the City Clerk prior to the meeting. For your convenience, forms for this purpose are available at the entrance to the Commission Chambers. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 286.26, Florida Statutes, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this meeting should contact the City Clerk by 5:00 PM, Friday,October 24, 1997. v v MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE ATLANTIC T O T T BEACH CITY COMMISSION HELD IN CITY HALL, 800 SEMINOLE E E ROAD, AT 7:15 PM ON MONDAY, OCTOBER 27, 1997 S S PRESENT: Lyman Fletcher, Mayor Mike Borno John Meserve Steve Rosenbloom Suzanne Shaughnessy, Commissioners AND: Jim Jarboe, City Manager M S Maureen King, City Clerk 0 E Alan C. Jensen, City Attorney T C I O Y ONE N COMMISSIONERS N D S 0 The meeting was called to order at I:I p.m. by Mayor e c er. — e invocation offered by Commissioner Shaughnessy, was followed by the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag. 1. Approval of the minutes of the Special Called Meeting of October 2, 1997, and Regular Meetings of October 7 and 13, 1997. BORNO X X MESERVE X X Motion: Approve minutes of the Special Called Meeting held SHAUGHNESSY X October 2, 1997. FLETCHER X The motion carried unanimously. BORNO X X Motion: Approve minutes of the Regular Meetings held MESERVE X ROSENBLOOMOctober 7 and 13, 1997. SHAUGHNESS X SHAUGHNESSY X X FLETCHER X In discussion, the Mayor pointed out an error on Page 11 of the minutes of October 13, 1997, and requested an amendment as follows: Motion: Amend Paragraph 4, Page 11 of the minutes of October BORNO X X 13, to reflect that Curtis Sanders was not opposed to the ME SERVE X installation of underground electrical service, but was opposed ROSENBLOOM x SHAUGHNESSY X X to the cost of such installation being spread out to all the FLETCHER X citizens. The motion carried unanimously. The motion to approve the minutes of October 7 and 13 was then voted on and the minutes were unanimously approved, as amended. M S O E T C Minutes Page -2- I 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N COMMISSIONERS N D S 0 2. Recognition of Visitors: A. Tina Stogsdill Ms. Stogsdill, 1032 Mimosa Cove Court, addressed the City Commission and complained of the noise from the Mimosa Cove lift station. She said the pumps cycle on and off all night causing a disturbance. The Public Works Director had provided Commissioners with a chronology of the actions which had been taken by the city to address this situation. The City Manager explained that since funds had not been provided in the current year budget he felt one alternative was to wait until the sewer plant at Buccaneer was finished which would probably reduce the frequency of the recycling of the pumps at Mimosa Cove lift station. Alternatively, additional soundproofing could be done at a cost of approximately $15,000 - $20,000 and there would be no guarantee that it would produce the desired effect. The Mayor felt it would be best to wait to see how the proposed improvements at the Buccaneer sewer plant would improve the situation before considering additional soundproofing. Roger Kjar, 332 Third Street, requested that the city consider amending the ordinance which addresses the number of non-family members who may occupy a single family living unit. He felt the current ordinance was discriminatory. He reported that Jacksonville limited the number of unrelated people living together to three, while Neptune Beach had eliminated this provision from their ordinances. Nancy White, 1729 Seminole Road requested that the ordinance be allowed to remain as is. She felt that elimination of this provision would cause problems with parking and other disturbances from late night visitors, etc. Discussion ensued in which the question was raised regarding whether this ordinance was enforceable and the City Attorney indicated that similar ordinances had been upheld in other areas. The Mayor pointed out that this section of the code was under review and any commissioner could request that this section be changed. Stephen Kuti, 1132 Linkside Drive, addressed the City Commission regarding the Howell Park drainage. He felt that the committee appointed to review drainage options did not include any experts and could not come up with any answers in a few weeks. NIS S 0E T C Minutes Page -3- 1 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N CONE ISSIONERS N D S O J.P. Marchioli, 414 Sherry Drive, presented some comments regarding the city's proposed drainage project, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit A. 3. Unfinished Business: Item 3B was taken out of sequence and acted upon at this time. B. Board Appointments: (i) Recreation Advisory Board - one vacancy (4-year term) (ii) Tree Conservation Board - one vacancy (Partial term expires 1-31-99) The Mayor nominated Peter Coalson for appointment to the Recreation Advisory Board BORNO X Motion: Appoint Peter Coalson to the Recreation MESERVE X X Advisory Board (Term to expire September 30, 2001) ROSENBLOOM X X SHAUGHNESSY X The motion carried unanimously. FLETCHER X The Mayor nominated Susan Bullock for appointment to the Tree Conservation Board. BORNO X X Motion: Appoint Susan Bullock to the Tree MESERVE X Conservation Board (To replace Rick Beaver - term to expire ROSENBLOOM x January 31, 1999) SHAUGHNESSY X X FLETCHER X The motion carried unanimously. C. Howell Park Review Committee report and action, if required Commissioner Borno, Chairman of the Howell Park Review Committee, reported the committee had held two organizational meetings. He reported that Susan Bullock, who is an employee of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, had received a legal opinion from the Corps' Legal Department indicating that there may be a conflict of interest for Ms. Bullock to serve on this committee. Commissioner Borno, however, indicated that Susan Bullock was a valuable member of the committee and it would be his desire that she be able to continue to be a member. The Mayor indicated the City Commission could waive the conflict. BORNO X X ESERVE X Motion: Take the position that there is no conflict of ROSENBLOOM X interest with Susan Bullock serving as a member of the Howell SHAUGHNESSY X X FL C Park Review Committee since she has no involvement in the M S 0 E T C Minutes Page -4- I 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N CONLMIISSIONERS N D S 0 permitting or any other aspect of this project and authorize the Mayor to sign such waiver document which may be necessary Ms. Bullock explained that she was a member of the Water Management, Meteorological Section of the Corps of Engineers and is involved mostly in issues that relate to central and southern Florida such as the Everglades. She does not feel that there is any conflict and would like to continue serving on the committee, if possible. The motion carried unanimously. A. Authorize amendment to England, Thims & Miller contract to include additional permit work, if required, in connection with Howell Park drainage Commissioner Borno requested approval to continue to utilize England, Thims& Miller to assist the committee at a cost not to exceed $10,000.00 There was no discussion and the motion carried unanimously. BORNO X X MESERVE X X Motion: Approve expenditure not to exceed $10,000 to ROSENBLOOM x England, Thims & Miller for technical assistance as necessary SHAUGHNESSY X FLETCHER X Commissioner Rosenbloom felt the committee should have been appointed at the beginning of the process. He expressed concerns that the city has already paid ETM for a design to which the City Commission does not seem to be able to support. He also was concerned with the possible escalation of the cost of the project and asked what the city hoped to get for the additional $10,000. Commissioner Meserve responded that the City Commission had given specific direction to ETM and he felt they had performed the task as they had been directed. He felt the city was going the extra mile to address the concerns which had been raised by the citizens. He pointed out the city had already held public hearings and addressed the concerns of the citizens in the Johansen Park area. He felt the committee should be allowed to complete the task and the City Commission should then make the decision on behalf of all the citizens and move ahead, knowing that it is impossible to please everyone. The Mayor inquired regarding the source of the funds and the City Manager responded that funds would come from the Capital Projects Fund. The motion carried unanimously. M S 0 E T C Minutes Page -5- I O Y October 27, 1997 ONE N COMI IISSIONERS N D S 0 • At this time the Mayor indicatedshe wished to reconfirm Commissioner Meserve's appointment to the Waterfronts Committee. The City Commission concurred. • Commissioner Meserve gave a status report on the Waterfronts activities. He reported this is a joint venture between the City of Atlantic Beach, Jacksonville and Daphne Schmidt, a Master Planner from the City of Jacksonville, had been assigned as the Project Coordinator for a three-year period. The organization has been named the Mayport Waterfronts Partnership and a building in the village of Mayport will be leased to the organization for $1.00 per year and will be used as an office, a meeting place, and information center. A $10,000 grant will be used to refurbish and furnish the office building. A committee of about 23 people, including such people as Councilmen Eric Smith, Dick Brown, and Max Leggett, members of Mayport Civic Association, and area businesses, had been tentatively formed to support her. The goal is to fix up and clean up those areas and encourage good business growth in the area. Commissioner Shaughnessy requested that the City Commission receive reports from Mayport Waterfronts Partnership on a regular basis. 4. Consent Agenda: A. Acknowledge receipt of Capital Improvement Projects Report, New Occupational License Report, and Fire Department Report for the month of September The consent agenda items were received and acknowledged as presented. 5. Action on Resolutions: Agenda Item 7D was taken out of sequence and acted upon at this time D. Discussion and possible action in connection with a sculpture in Bull Park Recreation Director, Timmy Johnson, introduced Stephanie Galloway who presented a sketch of a sculpture which members of the Recreation Board had reviewed and had recommended be included in the Bull Park improvements. She explained the sculpture could be located in front of the Adele Grage Community Center and that there would be no cost to the city. NI S 0 E T C Minutes Page -6- I Y October 27, 1997 COIvIIN D S N �IISSIONERS N D S 0 It was felt that the City Commission did not have enough information to act on this matter this evening and additional information will be provided and the matter will be placed on the next Commission agenda. Ms. Galloway urged the City Commission to move quickly on this issue so that the project could be incorporated into the First Night activities. 6. Action on Ordinances: A. Ordinance No 80-97-60 Introduction and First Reading AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 22, UTILITIES, ARTICLE II, WATERWORKS SYSTEM, SEC. 22-27, CHARGES FOR WATER SERVICE, SUBSECTION (2), CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY, AND ARTICLE HI, WASTEWATER SYSTEM, DIVISION 7, SEWER USER RATES AND CHARGES, SEC. 22-166, ESTABLISHMENT OF A MONTHLY BASE CHARGE, SUBSECTION (b), CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY, AND SEC. 22-167, SCHEDULE OF WASTEWATER VOLUME CHARGES, SUBSECTION (b), CUSTOMERS OUTSIDE THE CITY, TO EXEMPT FEDERAL, STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL SUBDIVISIONS AND AGENCIES FROM PAYING OUTSIDE RATES, AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. BORNO X Motion: Adopt Ordinance No. 80-97-60 on final reading. MESERVE X Mayor Fletcher read the ordinance by title only and opened the floor for a Public Hearing. Dezmond Waters felt that federal and state agencies should be required to pay outside city rates. He did not feel the city should subsidize other governmental agencies and requested that Section 22-166(b) be amended to this extent. There being no further comments from the audience, the Mayor declared the public hearing closed and invited comments from the City Commission. Commissioner Meserve informed the Commissioners the ordinance would allow the City Manager to execute a new contract with the Navy, and he pointed out adoption of this agreement would increase, not lower, the rates NI S 0 E T C Minutes Page -7- i O Y October 27, 1997 ONE N COND.ESSIONERS N D S 0 to the Navy. He also reported the sewer line to the Village of Mayport was being installed by Jacksonville at no expense and no future maintenance by Atlantic Beach. The City Manager agreed with some of Mr. Waters' comments and pointed out there needed to be a compelling reason for the city to change its rates, which in the case of the City of Jacksonville, was because Jacksonville would read the meters and collect payments, do hook-ups etc., which would result in a considerable savings to Atlantic Beach. However, he felt that it would be appropriate to change the ordinance to allow the city to consider applications for service from other governmental entities on their individual merits. Commissioner Meserve indicated he had no objections to the amendments suggested. 'Commissioner Shaughnessy moved to amend Section 22-166(b) of the ordinance by replacing the word "shall"with the words "may be allowed to" which would provide the City Commission the flexibility to consider each case on its merits. Following further discussion the motion was withdrawn. Commissioner Shaughnessy also indicated she would like an interlocal agreement with the City of Jacksonville in this regard to be executed before the ordinance was passed. She also indicated she would like to see a list of all political subdivisions or agencies which may be impacted by this ordinance. Mayor Fletcher also suggested the ordinance specify which agencies were covered. Also he felt action on the ordinance should be deferred until an interlocal agreement is entered into with the City of Jacksonville setting forth the responsibilities of each party. Commissioner Borno suggested that exceptions to the ordinance be included in agreements with the various entities rather than to address them in the ordinance. Motion: Amend ordinance to make it clear who, if anyone, BORNO X will receive relief under this ordinance, which is specifically to ME SERVE X the Navy and the City of Jacksonville; Also provide the City ROSENBLOOM X SHAUGHNESSY X X Commission with a plan as to how the three entities FLETCHER X X (Jacksonville, Navy & City) will all meet up at the same time and the same place; defer action until the next meeting and continue the public hearing at that time. M S 0 E T C Minutes Page -8- I 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N CONEWSSIONERS N D S 0 The City Attorney indicated that he would amend the ordinance for the next meeting, but pointed out that the changes would have to be constitutional and may not be exactly what the City Commission wants. He felt it would be unconstitutional to selectively identify entities to receive certain benefits while others would not. The motion carried unanimously. 7. New Business: A. Authorize the City Manager to execute Utility Service Agreement between the City and Department of the Navy Commissioner Shaughnessy indicated she had requested that this item be withdrawn since the City Commission had not received attachments referred to in the agreement. -B. Award contract in the amount of$67,802.90 to Beach Construction Co. Inc., for Piping and Instrumentation at Well No. 4, at Water Plant No. 2, pursuant to the specifications of Bid No. 9798-2, and authorize the City Manager to execute the contract documents Motion: Award contract in the amount of$67,802.90 to Beach BORNO X X Construction Co. Inc., for Piping and Instrumentation at Well RESERVE X ROSENBLOOM X X No. 4, at Water Plant No. 2, pursuant to the specifications of Bid SHAUGHNESSY X No. 9798-2, and authorize the City Manager to execute the FLETCHER X contract documents The motion carried unanimously. The City Manager reported that rebidding this item resulted in savings of $20,000 and thanked Public Works Director Bob Kosoy and Asst. Public Works Director Jim Jacques for recommending that the item be rebid. C. Discussion and possible action in connection with construction of a city greenhouse BORNO X Motion: Authorize the City Manager to construct a city RESERVE x greenhouse and authorize $6,000 for that purpose ROSENBLOOM X X SHAUGHNESSY X FLETCHER X X The Mayor indicated that it was his opinion that a city operated greenhouse would result in significant savings to the city by growing its own trees and plants for landscaping. M S O E T C Minutes Page -9- I o Y October 27, 1997 ONE N COMMIISSIONERS N D S 0 Discussion ensued and concerns were expressed regarding the possibility of vandalism, on-going costs of operation and maintenance of such a facility and whether the city had the staff to operate such a facility. Commissioner Shaughnessy suggested that staff seek input regarding the feasibility of a city-owned greenhouse from Jodie Richards who owns and operates commercial greenhouses in the city. The question was called and the motion failed on a vote of 2 - 3 with Commissioners Borno, Meserve and Shaughnessy voting nay. D. Discussion and possible action in connection with a sculpture in Bull Park This item was taken up earlier in the meeting. E. Status Report and potential funding for Town Center Mayor Fletcher reported that the basic construction of Phase II of the Town Center project was completed; however, there was a budget shortage of approximately $70,000 and the Mayor requested that Atlantic Beach contribute $15,000 to help complete the landscaping and installation of benches. He indicated that Mayor Delaney may have some discretionary funds which he could contribute; also Neptune Beach may contribute further. BORNO x Motion: Authorize expenditure of$15,000 of bed tax funds ROSENBE x ROSENBLOOM X X for Town Center improvements SHAUGHNESSY X FLETCHER X X Finance Director Ann Meuse confirmed that sufficient bed tax funds were available. The motion carried unanimously. The City Manager suggested that a professional be hired to review traffic problems in the Town Center area. The Mayor suggested that Jacksonville may be helpful in this matter. Commissioner Shaughnessy indicated that the Chairman of the Jacksonville Transportation Authority had suggested replacing the traffic light at Ocean Boulevard and Atlantic Boulevard with stop signs. She felt this may be worth looking into further. 8. City Manager Reports and/or Correspondence: NI S O E T C Minutes Page -10- I 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N CO?IVIISSIONERS N D S 0 • The City Manager provided each commissioner with a draft of a letter dated October 27, 1997, to the Department of Environmental Protection, requesting an amendment to the Consent Order to extend certain dates and asked that he be authorized to submit this request. Motion: Authorize the City Manager to submit a request BORNO X X to the Department of Environmental Protection, seeking MESERVE x ROSENBLOOM X extension of certain dates, as stated SHAUGHNESSY X X FLETCHER X The motion carried unanimously. • The City Manager reported that a picnic to recognize Commissioner Rosenbloom and Mayor Fletcher (who will be leaving office) has been scheduled for November 9, 1997 in Donner Park. He indicated that the event was being organized by citizen volunteers and inquired whether the City Commission wished to authorize • funding for the event. The Mayor indicated he would prefer not to use public funds for this purpose. The City Commission concurred. • The City Manager also provided each commissioner with copies of a communication he had received from the City of Port Richie requesting support of a recent resolution which had been adopted by that city. The Florida Constitution currently allows for abolishment/merger of cities without a referendum and Port Richie was soliciting support in having this reversed when the Florida Constitution is revised. The Mayor requested that this matter be included on the next agenda. 9. Reports and/or requests from City Commissioners, City Attorney and City Clerk • Commissioner Shaughnessy reported she had recently attended several Navy functions and would visit the U.S.S. John F. Kennedy the following day. • Commissioner Shaughnessy requested that the City Clerk contact Jodie Richards for input regarding the feasibility of constructing a city greenhouse and that this matter be placed on the next commission agenda for action. A. Farewell remarks - Commissioner Rosenbloom Commissioner Rosenbloom complimented the City Clerk and City Manager •for the jobs they do for the city and presented them with gifts to express his I M s o F T C Minutes Page -11- I 0 Y October 27, 1997 ONE N COMMISSIONERS N D S 0 appreciation. He reflected on some of the projects in which the city is involved and commented on procedures and memorable moments in his tenure. Resolution No. 97-39 The Mayor presented in full, in writing, Resolution No. 97-39 recognizing the service of Commissioner Steve Rosenbloom on the City Commission. Motion: Adopt Resolution No. 97-39 The motion carried unanimously. The Mayor presented the framed resolution to Commissioner Rosenbloom with the good wishes of the City Commission. There being no further discussion or business to come before the Commission, the meeting adjourned at 9:05 PM. /. Lyman Fletcher Mayor/Presiding Officer ATTEST: Maureen King, Certified Municipal Clerk EXNiB,T A comm I SSi o fq fr1 EE-I/AIG /0/,27/(17 414 Sherry Drive Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 October 25, 1997 Honorable Mayor Lyman T. Fletcher & Fellow Commisioners City of Atlantic Beach, Florida SUBJECT: CORE CITY PROJECT - Surface Water Run-off & Tree Conservation Sirs & Madam; For hundreds of years, waters in the core city have drained from areas surrounding Howell Park into Howell Park , ultimately destined for intercoastal waterway. Modern day, so-called improvements, proceduresexcavate "collection" ponds to perculate run-off. I would speculate that Fifty Percent (50%) of Howell Park, containing so-called "SWAMP" land by unthinkers; has been NATURALLY perculating rainwater for hundreds and hundreds of years. Currently, this would not include the large portion (North end of park. ) that is no longer considered to be part of Howell park. In an effort to upgrade the core city area surrounding Howell Park, engineers, hired by the city (For approximately Three Quarters of a Million Dollars), have over-designed storm water run-off plan with two six foot (6'0"0) inside diameter reinforced concrete ipes, partially below sea level, at 5th & 7th streets that would flow rainwater into canals, with sumps, displacing hundreds of healthy treasared trees. My thoughts would be to replace the two six foot (6'0") ID reenforced concrete pipes that are to flow into sumps and manmade canals into the existing lagoon, with Five four foot (4'0' ID concrete reenforced pipes. One pipe, entering the lagoon at its origon at Pine Street could be easily run along the grassy area at the North end of the elementary school yard. The second, third and fourth pipes could flow into the NATURAL perculation area as follow: second stopping at the West Side of Sherr} Drive at the Howell Park 4th street entrance on the North side of the entrance walk; the third pipe would replace the existing pipe at 3th±hatl been flowing into the NATURAL perculation area; the fourth pipe at 7th street also running into the NATURAL perculation area; and, the fifth pipe entering the lagoon at the North side of Plaza. This plan would eleminate the necessity of constructing huge dewatering excavations, sumps and canals to reach the existing lagoon. . saving hundreds of trees. We must remember, that we have long dry seasons with very little rain. In the past, there have been rainy seasons that would be easily controlled by the planned run-off control In the case of five-year, or thereabouts, heavy rainfalls, flumes over the pipes on Sherry Drive would handle the excess not covered by underground surface water run-off pipes. For HURRICANES , pary and/or evacuate. ------- � S . yours / , ��� JPM/jpm . P. (Marc) Marchioli