07-05-94 v TREE CONSERVATION BOARD
Minutes of July 5, 1994
The Board held its regular meeting on Tuesday, July 5, in
the City Hall Conference Room. Present were:
Carolyn Woods, Chairman Tom Frahne
Jim Pelkey Mae Jones
Staff: George Worley, Designee Carl Walker, Coordinator
The meeting was called to order at 7:40 PM by Carolyn Woods.
Under old business, Greg Christovich, General Manager of the
Se l va Marina Country Club, was present to introduce his re-
vised tree removal plans for the club' s driving range. The
revision shifted the proposed area to the south of its orig-
inal location which allowed for the 36" DBH oak, the subject
of discussion at the last meeting, to be saved.
The amended plan calls for a total of 25 trees to be removed,
with a DBH of 6"-14"each; of these, 14 were not shown on the
original application (12 pines, 1 oak, and 1 magnolia) . Mr.
Christovich will replace the trees, on a one-to-one basis but
requested that he be given a year' s time to install all of
the replacement trees. The Board agreed to this proposal.
Jim Pelkey made a motion to accept the revised proposal on
the basis of replacement of 250" caliper, with a minimum of
3" caliper each. Mae Jones seconded and during discussion,
Mr. Christovich was requested to provide a revised listing of
the trees proposed for removal, to include their sizes. This
will be turned in to George Worley and retained as a part of
the file. On this basis, the motion unanimously passed.
The next order of business was the application for removal at
Lot # 39, Oceanwalk, Unit # 1. Property owner Bob Wienberry
was present for the discussion and explained that the house
plan had already been modified in order to save several large
trees on the property. There are 5 oak trees proposed for
removal, and a total of 13 palms, all within the house foot-
print. One of the 5 oaks has a DBH of 36" and the Board ex-
pressed concern on removal of this tree. An oak and a mag-
nolia near the side of the house were also discussed but it
was agreed that they could both be saved.
Jim Pelkey moved to accept the plan with the exception that
4 of the oaks be replaced with hardwoods on a 1/3 ratio to
-pa 4aa.A,Aoa sem s t gl -pas,tana{ a,..taM # pue
R # s.'D1 '..to.t,Aa Ut '4eg; palou sem 4T 'EuoT.eaT Idde eq. u0
-5utuueld a.An4n4 .toj uolpel.o5au jo ads 4
s t g. u t a.ta 4u T passa-td xa sueA3 ,At4 -sasegd u t auop eq P i noa
pue 'sawoH xa4ua0 g.TM aptsiiuI1 eniag uant5 5utipueg ag4 oa.
,stet Twts aq pinoM sTgl -40.1 ICq 4oT Uegl. kag4e.4 'aiogM a se
wawdoianap pauueid agq. EuTMatna..t Jo A4TjtgIssod ag. suet
-.t4 g4TM pessnastp p»teoa aq; 'suoT 4eat Ode ienpzntput agq. uo
u,_'I 4e,.tagT Iap 04 -40T-Ad -H uOT 4aag '9L # )i.O'ig 'c # PUe '2 #
'T # s4o1 ,toj. suoT .eatIdde ea,tgq. ;xau eq. jo Matna-t aqq. ..to3
scap i t ng a T 4soa pe .uesa Ada,A 'UO t s t A T Q a 4e .s £ead 'suenj ugar
-uotsTaap s 6p,.teog aq4 ans..tnd o. esoogo ?Feat Idde ag4 pinogs
peuteldxa Osie sem ssaao.td ieadde aul -saa,t4 4uawaaeida,A ,4o4
AoTiod .ttagq. uo patioIIol P teog agq. gftM uot4es..taAUo3 -aaueU
-TP-10 A q /c I I e3 T J T aad s patio t a.uaw 4ou SCM 4T aau T s .uewa.,t T n b
4uawaaetdau aqq. ,toj. A4t..toq.ne ag4 pa.sanba.t sMagley
' (+suleEe sau'�r -w) a1on T-r e iq passed uoT 4ow agq. pue
pepuoaas Aa)-iia,d wtr -uota.do s , aUMO A4 tado-td agq. 4e 'i4t0
agq. o4 pa4euop -to 4oT agq. uo paaeld eq off. 'gaea titadTTea .2 4.o
wnwtuTw e g4TM 'saa..t4 pooMp-steg g4TM paaeida-.t aq PInoM panow
eq off, H}3Q ..aST 40 1e404 eq. lo 2/T. 4e144. uoi 4daaxa ago
g4TM 'pawasa_td se 'sueid age. .daaae 04 panow au ;oaJ wol
-e3ue4sut sTg4 uT q.uaTat34ns aq .ou pp-tom panowa..t esog4 ,to4
sagauT Jo einw.toJ. .uawaaelda..t aq4 4ia4 aqs 4eg4 pa4e.s
seuor aew -panowa..t 5utaq saau4 ago 4.o uot.eaoT pue ants
'..tagwnu ag+ 4noge uotssnasTp p,Aeog aTge.taptsuoa sem a.tagl
-panowati-t 5uTaq HHQ ..agT pue '4oi age. uo Ojai 5uTaq auam
HQQ 079T g4TM saa�t4 B 4egq. no .145no.tq sMeq ew -.-t�+.i -H8Q .62T
5uT ie4oa. s)-leo L pue 'AIaAT I.aadsa,.t .47T pue ..6 40 s dHt3Q 1-14IM
e T i ou5ew f Jo i enowa.; .:toi sr i ea u._.T lea T Idde aul -saa.t. 5u t 4s T
-xe aga 4o uoT2Tpuoa agq. paiiaaga pue aa.ts agq. pa4Tstn '..taa.sa
- toy ueq..tn '4te5T j 4e44 pue 4oT age. ,toj pau5Tsap uaaq
peg awog ag4 pauteidxe pue JiaswTg paanpo..t;uT '2 # .Tun 'i1TeM
-ueaa0 4173 # l,a1 se peq t,.tasap Al.tadoud 4.o „tauMo 'sMag4ew gEnH
-htsnowtueun passed uoT 4ow agq.
pue papuooas augo_tj wol -EuT lueid A04 Alto ag. o4 pe.euop ,to
4o1 agq. uo paaeid aq ,cew saa.t4 .uewaaeida..t agl -gaea .tadITea
..L tunwtutw e g4TM '..tad T tea ..9*7 4 0 Te l.o4 }e ion '> eo Hi3Q..9c- ag.
40 tie 4o apew eq 4uawaaeida-t I ir,4 e 4egq. pue 'panowa,t asog.
0
- c' -
Aue 4a-teras
A a l i a,d u
//2‘?"
d -
'pa44twgris i T inl4aadsaH
'Wd O+7:5 4e
pau-tnoCpe sem 6ut4aaw aq . pue ssautsnq uag4un4 ou sem auaUl
-A Isnowtueun passed uoL-.ow aUl pue pap}.Maas /Caifia,d wtr -peat
se 'but aaw 4sei aq4 to sa.nutw aq. 4daaae o4 paAow sauor aeW
•:CeM,tapUn AT.ua.tuna f,tot 4an.A suoa aq4 uo _yap-to ) uom dols
e ansst o4 aigtssod st 4t It aas o4 itoago osie pue 't,tnos
-ueW -_.LW g4TM aipueq iiuM /Cai.A,DM a5,toa9 -4aw uaaq 4ou peq
'AeM l0 445T-1 aq4 ut sifeo 4uawaaeidatt 30 5ut4ueid aU4 ' ilea
-t4Laads '43e,t4uoa 4eq . to suor4ipuoa aqa. 4eq4 paau5e sem 4t
'uotssnastp ..ta44b -eag aU. Aq Auelltl 40 t,tnosuew eleg q IM
apew uaaq peq UaiUM laeuluoa aq4 do 414Eno-.tq spooM u/(io.,.te0
'squawa,.ttnbau .uawaaeida.t agq. (4 tM 4uawaa,t6e uT sem p.teog aql
--tauMo ,cq tado..td '/Cpueug ifoT,A4e,d -.AW pue 'pueog aU . 40 1ieq
-aq uo 'spooM u1i ueg uaaM.aq apew 4uawaa,.6d uot4e6t.tW ienow
-ay aa.tl aq . paMatna,t pue 'T # 4Tu0 'anoup ueaao 'b # if3013
'nT # 401 4e pa unaao UatUM U0i4ei to aq4 passnasLp p,Aeog aql
'ATsnowtueun passed uot4ow
aq4 : papuoaas augo,tj wol -..tads iea „c? o. saa..t4 .uawaaeid
-au i e;o. aq 4 6u t 6uega 'p # pue T # s a.,'-t se suo z s T Aoud awes
aU. L IM sue-0 aU. ;daaae o4 paAow savor aeW '2 # x.01 uo
'passed 1Cisnowtueun +.tot 4ow aq4 pue papuoo
-as sauor aew -paaeida„t 5uTaq uadtiea „L2 to ie404. C U4itrt
'T # 401 {o1 se suotsino..td awes aU. U.tt sueid aqq. 4daoae o4
paAow augoud wol -panowau 5u t aq i e;o. Ht3Q „29 aU 1 .404 rC i dd e
p i n„M suo t 4 I puoa awes aq. 4eU 4 pap t oap sem 4T '1 # ;o1 uoA
-Aisnowtueun passed Uotgm 'uot4ow aq4
papuoaas augoud wol -suot4eooj aa.t; 4uawaaeida,t at4 5uttiogs
sueid 'sicep og utga.TM 'aptAoAd 4snw 4Ueat idde aq4 pue 'gaeat3
at 4uei 4u 'H not 4oas uL s.tapi inti aL 4so{f Aq paumo A4-tadoud
Aue uo pa i.ue i d aq Aew saa..t 4 4uawaae i dau aql •Uaea ff 2 ue q.
ssa i ou 40 ad t i ea e t4 T M 'aaueu T p,t0 aU. Aq pau t lap se 'aa„t 4
adA4 Cue 10 ad L ieo 0747 l0 apew aq .uawaaeida,t 4eq; +.tot.daa
-xa ue q .IM 'pasodo,td se 'ueid aqa. 4daooe o. panow Xaifia,d wtr
'uotssnasLp EuiMoil, A •ienowau _sol pasodo.td auam Hga „ T`T to
Te4o4 e Uf.IM saau4 autd cT 4eq4 pa4eir+oieo sem 4t 'T # 401 uo
v