08-13-03 vAGENDA
REGULAR MEETING OF
TREE CONSERVATION BOARD
August 13, 2003
7:00 p.m.
Adcle Grage Community Center
1. Call to Order
2. Introduction of New Board Member
3. Recognition of Visitors
4. Approval of Minutes of Meeting of July 9, 2003, and July 23, 2003
5. Old Business
A. Tree Removal Applications:
1) East 100 Feet of Lot 70A, North Atlantic Beach, Unit No. 3 (2038 Beach Ave.)
2) 1814 Hickory Lane
6. New Business
A. Tree Removal Applications:
1) 121 Ocean Forest Drive N.
2) 19-16 17-25-29E Donners RIP Pt. Govt. Lots 2, 3, 4, Block 21 (Simmons Road)
3) East 40' of Lot 17, west 10' of Lot 15, Block 12, Atlantic Beach (10`h Street)
7. Reports and Announcements •
8. Adjournment
All information related to these applications and full legal descriptions for the subject properties are
available for review at the City of Atlantic Beach Building Department located at 800 Seminole Road,
Atlantic Beach, Florida.
If any person decides to appeal any decision made by the Tree Conservation Board with respect to any
matter considered at the above meeting, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and for such
purpose, may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the
testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is based.
Notice to persons needing special accommodations and to all hearing impaired persons: In accordance
with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons needing special accommodation to participate in this
proceeding should contact the City of Atlantic Beach (904) 247-5800, 800 Seminole Road, Atlantic
Beach, Florida 32233 not later than five days prior to the date of this meeting.
itiIINUTES OF ThE
REGULAR MEETING OF ThE
TREE CONSERVATION BOARD
August 13, 2003
A regular meeting of the Tree Conservation Board was held Wednesday, August 13, 2003, at the
City Hall Conference Room. Present were Chair Barbara Mears, Bill Permentcr, Maureen
Shaughnessy and Susan Dunham. Absent was Charles Carroll.
1. Call to Order
The meeting was called to order at 7:00 p.m.
2. Introduction of New Member
New member Charles Can o114vas not in attendance.
3. Recognition of Visitors
None.
4. Approval of Minutes of Meetings of .Yalu 9, 2003, and .Yalu 23, 2003
A motion tivas made by Board Member Permentcr, seconded by Board Member
Shaughnessy, and unanimously carried to approve the Minutes of July 9, 2003.
A motion was made by Board Member Shaughnessy, seconded by Board Member
Permentcr, and unanimously carried to approve tl~e Minutes of July 23, 2003.
5. Old BUSiness
A. Tree Removal Applications:
1) East 100 Feet of Lot 70A, North Atlantic Beach, Unit No. 3 (2038 Beach Avenue):
The Board addressed this item later in the meeting.
2) 1814 hickory Lanc:
The Board addressed this item later in the meeting.
G. NCw Busines$
A. Tree Removal Applications:
1) 121 Ocean Forest Drive N:
Mr. Michael Sones introduced himself. He stated that he needed to remove trees to allow for the
renovation of his personal home. He advised that he plans to relocate the three short palm trees to
another location on site.
The Board determined that the applicant was removing 14" of oak, 12" of hardwood and 72" of
palm.
A motion was made by Board Member Permentcr, seconded by Board Member
Shaughnessy, and unanimously carried to direct the Building Official to issue a permit for
121 Ocean Forest Drive North to remove 14" of oak, 12" of Hardwood, 72" of palm to be
mitigated with 7" of oak, G" of hardwood and 3G" of palm to be planted on site.
2) 19-1G 17-25-29E Donncrs R/P Pt. Govt. Lots 2, 3, 4, Block 21 (Simmons Road):
The Board addressed this item later in the meeting.
Minutes of Tree Cor:servatiort Board
Augccst 13, 2003
Page 2
5. Old Business
A. Tree Removal Applications:
2) 1814 IIickory Lanc:
Ms. Margie Petit introduced herself and advised that she was the buyer of the home located at
1814 Hickory Lane. She advised that she would like to remove the trees for the purpose of
installing a pool. She further advised that she understood that the trees that she would like to
remove had been used for prior mitigation but that she would be willing to plant trees inch for
inch. Ms. Petit also informed the board that she did not plan to remove the 30" live oak on the
east side of the lot which was originally proposed for removal. She proposed planting eight 4"
oak trees to mitigate for the removal of protected trees.
The applicant was advised to ensure that tree barricades were placed around all the trees that were
to remain on the lot.
Chair Mears stated that the applicant's proposal. provided for more trees than originally proposed
and there would be no bald spots on the lot.
A motion was made by Board Member Shaughnessy, seconded by Board Member
Permenter, and unanimously carried to direct the Building Official to issue a permit for the
removal of a 5" Laurel oak, a 10" laurel oak and a 13" laurel oak to be mitigated 100
percent with eight 4" laurel oaks to be planted on site.
6. New Business
3) East 40' of Lot 17, West 10' Lot 15, Block 12, Atlantic Beaclt:
Mr. David Burbridge introduced himself. He stated that this request was for the removal of trees
for new construction next to his home at 340 10`x' Street. He further stated that he would like to
attempt to relocate the 14.3" palm tree on site but would like the option of removal if necessary.
A motion was made by Board Member Permenter, seconded by Board Member
Sltaugltnessy, and unanimously carried to direct the Building Official to issue a permit for
the removal of a 14.3" palm tree to be replaced with 8" of palm or relocated on site.
2) 19-16 17-25-29E Donners R/P Pt. Govt. Lots 2, 3, 4, Block 21 (Simmons Road):
Chair Mears advised that the applicant could not use crepe myrtle trees as mitigation.
A motion was made by Board Member Permenter and seconded by Board Member
Shaughnessy to direct the Building Official to issue a permit for the removal of 33" of oak to
be mitigated with 16.5" of oak and to remove 24" of pine to be mitigated wit}t 12" of
hardwood citlter to be planted on site or to be paid into the Tree Fund.
Discussion was held and the board determined that the best way to handle this situation was to
deny the application and to request that the applicant re-apply with proper mitigation noted.
The vote was called and Chair Mears, Board Member Permenter and Board Member
Shaughnessy voted against the motion. The motion failed.
A motion was made by Board Member Permenter, seconded by Board Member
Shaughnessy, and unanimously carried to deny the Tree Removal Application.
Minuses of Trce Conservation Board
August 13, 2003
Page 3
5. Old Business
1) East 100 feet of Lot 70A, Nortlt Atlantic Beaclt, Unit No. 3 (2038 Beach Avenue):
Board Member Shaughnessy advised that the applicant was able to save the secondary dune
thereby saving the trees on the dune. Therefore, she stated that the original permit indicating
57.2" of oak to be removed needed to be revised to reflect 31.25" of oak to be removed. The
applicant's letter indicated that he would like to mitigate the 31.25" of oak with 39.5" of oak on
site.
A motion was made by Board Member Permenter, seconded by Board Member
Shaughnessy, and unanimously carried to issue a revised permit to remove 31.3" of oak to
be mitigated with 39.5" of oak on site. The applicant is to provide the city with an updated
tree survey.
7. Reports and Announcements
Chair Mears stated that she, called the Department of Forestry to determine. the process to dec]are
a "champion" tree. She stated that a "champion" tree was determined by several criteria. In
addition, she advised that there are only 20 "champion" trees in the state of Florida because a
"champion" tree is a phenomenon, not a 36" oak. However, she stated that she found a
designation of "challenger" which would fit the category of a 36" oak. Chair Mears suggested
that the board look to change the ordinance to include a designation of "challenger" tree. Board
Member Permenter suggested that Chair Mears put this in writing so that it could be submitted to
the Commission.
8. Adjournment
There being no other business or discussion, the meeting was adjourned at 8:05 p.m.
_~~ c~it~~c~f~
Barbara Mears, Chair