Agenda Item 8BAGENDA ITEM # 8B
JULY 23, 2012
CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH
CITY COMMISSION MEETING
STAFF REPORT
AGENDA ITEM: Proposed Change to Chapter 16 Solid Waste and Recycling
SUBMITTED BY: Rick Carper, P.E., Public Works Director
DATE: July 10, 2012
BACKGROUND: In March 2007, in conjunction with the new solid waste contract, the
Commission approved a rewritten Solid Waste and Recycling Ordinance. Included in this
ordinance was a new requirement for franchise permits for haulers providing construction and
demolition debris removal services (construction roll off containers). The requirements for Private
Refuse Collectors: Collection of Commercial Recycling and Construction and Demolition Debris
(Sec. 16 -18 to 16 -22) have not been updated since implementation. Staff proposes to bring a
draft ordinance to the Commission including the following changes:
Reduce the Total Umbrella Insurance Policy. requirement from $5,000,000 to
$1,000,000.
Reduce the renewal fee of $250 per year in place of the current $2,500 (currently pay
same fee as initial application for renewal).
Clarify the enforcement provisions of the Franchise Permit section of the Ordinance
by specifying the fine amount ($250 /day).
The original purpose for including this Franchise Permit requirement in the new Sanitation
Ordinance was to improve the material condition of the containers being used on construction
sites in Atlantic Beach. This has been accomplished, but the financial requirements have
generated a number of complaints from contractors and residents about limiting the pool of
haulers available. Proposed changes 1 and 2 address these concerns. Additionally, there have
been a significant number of violations caused by builders and homeowners using non - Franchise
haulers, but it has been difficult to enforce the permit requirements with the existing language in
the ordinance. Proposed changes for enforcement allow processing of fines directly by Atlantic
Beach staff without referral to the courts.
BUDGET: Revenues from Franchise Permit fees have been $7500 per year the last three
years, with average franchise fees (based on cost of service) of approximately $20,000 / year.
There are currently three approved haulers and Advanced Disposal, with a fourth application
pending. Future renewal fee revenue will be reduced from current permit holders, but Staff
anticipates the changes to the Code will result in new Franchise applications to offset the
reductions.
RECOMMENDATION: Direct Staff to prepare a draft ordinance to modify Chapter 16 as
proposed.
ATTACHMENT: CHAPTER 16 SOLID WASTE AND RECYCLING, Sections 16 -18 to 16-
22 and 16 -29 to 16 -30
REVIEWED BY CITY MANAGER:
AGENDA ITEM # 8B
JULY 23, 2012
Sec. 16 -18. Private Refuse Collectors: Collection of Commercial Recycling and
Construction and Demolition Debris
All persons and organizations desiring to engage in the business or activity of collecting
Construction and Demolition (C &D) materials or commercial recycling within the City
shall, as a prerequisite to doing so, obtain a Construction and Demolition and/or
Recycling Collection Franchise Permit from the City Manager or his designee. No
person or organization shall engage in such business or activity within the City without
first having obtained such a permit. This service will be performed under a separate
contract between the Contractor and the user. The Contractor will bill the user directly
for delivery, rental, collection and disposal. The rates for this service shall be agreed
upon in advance including per pull and delivery costs, and costs for disposal. Contractors
will pay a 20% Franchise Fee to the City and will submit the Fee to the City quarterly.
Contractors shall provide the City records identifying the address, volume of collection,
and such other information as requested by the City on the first (1 st) of each month.
Sec. 16 -19. City's collection exempt from Sections 16.10 through 16.18.
The provisions of these sections shall not apply to refuse, C &D materials or recycling
collection services performed by the City whether directly or indirectly or by contract.
The City's franchise service provider is exempt from this article.
Sec. 16.20. Application: fee action by City Commission
Persons other than the City's franchise Contractor desiring Construction and Demolition
or Recycling Collection Permits shall complete and submit to the City Manager or his
designee a Franchise Application form, together with an application fee in the amount of
Two Thousand Five Hundred and 00 /100s Dollars ($2,500.00). The form of application
shall be prescribed by the City Manager and furnished to applicants by the City Manager
or his designee. Sufficient information shall be provided to give the City reasonable
assurance that proposed hauling activities will not create noise, dust, odor, litter or other
noxious conditions, that materials collected will be properly disposed of at authorized
facilities and that the applicant has sufficient resources to carry out the proposed hauling
activities. Any permit granted by the City Manager pursuant to this section shall not
exceed one year in term.
Sec. 16.21. Issuance of permit.
The City Manager or his designee shall issue Franchise Permits for Construction and
Demolition or Recycling Collection subject to the following requirements.
AGENDA ITEM # 8B
JULY 23, 2012
Sec. 16 -22. Permit requirements and rules.
All Franchise Permit holders shall comply with the following requirements and
rules:
(a) Liability insurance. Each permit holder shall secure and maintain a public
liability insurance policy in the amount of not less than $1,000,000.00 for one
(1) person injured, and $2,000,000.00 for more than one (1) person injured, and
property damage liability insurance of not less than $1,000,000.00. In addition
each permit holder must secure a total umbrella insurance policy of not less than
, 5,W0,000,00% LOW 000.00. All policies must have the City listed as additional
insured. Evidence of such insurance shall be deposited with the City Manager
or his designee prior to issuance of the permit. Upon request by the City,
the permittee shall produce evidence of such continued coverage during
the term of the permit.
(b) Equipment. Permit holders within the City limits shall use only packer -type
equipment or appropriate trucks for safely hauling roll -off type containers.
(c) Sanitary conditions. Each permit holder shall clean the trucks and all
containers from which they collect refuse as needed, but in no event less
than once each month.
(d) Customers. Permit holders shall serve only those customers who have signed
an agreement for services provided. Such agreement shall specify the fee to be
charged and any extra charges that may occur as a result of services being
provided.
(e) Identification of equipment. Each permit holder shall place and maintain the
name, telephone number and permit number in a conspicuous place and
display the same in a conspicuous manner on each vehicle operated by the
company and each container serviced by them within the City.
(f) Inspection The City shall have the right to inspect all equipment used and all
containers serviced by permit holders within the City. In the event any such
equipment or containers are determined to be unsafe or unsanitary, the
permit holder shall have twenty -four (24) hours after notice of the deficiency
within which to correct the deficiency. The permit holder shall have the right
to appeal the decision of the City's inspector to the City Commission. The
safety requirements referred to are not meant to suspend any other require-
ment of the City code or state law.
(g) Personnel. Each permit holder shall devote sufficient personnel, time and
attention to his refuse operation to assure a sanitary and safe operation within
the City. To this end, the permit holder shall employ competent and sober
personnel within the City. The permit holder shall employ no person convicted
of a felony crime within two (2) years. Each permittee will prepare a written
policy as part of its application, addressing hiring and retention of its
employees with regard to driving violations and random testing for use of
illegal substances.
AGENDA ITEM # 811
JULY 23, 2012
(h) Compliance with laws. Each permit holder shall comply with all applicable
state and federal laws and regulations and especially those relating to
wages and hours, and all other applicable laws pertaining to employment
and protection of employees, now or hereafter in effect.
(i) Disposal of construction and demolition materials and recyclables. Each
permit holder shall dispose of all construction and demolition materials or
recyclables collected within the City at an approved and licensed
disposal site. An alternate site may be used if approved the City Manager
or his designee.
(l) 1 -er i1il_ �ieneitwl � eq for ren�.iUg1 f an active ` ernlii Shall be tvvo fialli&e -c` f riy
- -- --
cloll aled insurance
a3Z c rasle is r e_aui e_ }_toy 1errni1 re €_2 tiyaL If th(e t t ra12 ili >t pi= _[ 7lii� = 4�3� P:S ��I
iii:( icat incl inL fee, .11 lac rear r .cl..
Sec. 16 -29. Enforcement
The Police Department, the Public Works Department, the Commission, the City
Manager or his designee, the Building Official and the Code Enforcement Officer, shall
enforce this chapter. All parties herein referred to are hereby authorized to sign
complaints for a violation of this chapter.
Sec. 16 -30. Violations and penalties.
The violation of any provision of this chapter shall be punished by a fine inot edinuof
3 t�vo hundred itv dollars ($ 500250.00) 1)er �iaw_ Or gin- nso e -ki o <_.. tee" -k not
xc.,;edha sixty (60) days, or by both fine and Ecicll calenciar dpi '� may
be car }rlsi Bred a separate violation. Said file n1ay bg rr1_ t o yeti � l�_rl r C'oncrac tor i
PcmDert ✓ ON ner hirML, the non- Fninchised hauler _and wariest tic -haider -harder for _olae" «n
tintatitlroFized container within the City l irnits of'_f4dmitic Beach.