1748 Ocean Grove Drive TREE 14-DRTV-1003 PacketCITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH
800 SEMINOLE ROAD
ATLANTIC BEACH, FL 32233
INSPECTION PHONE LINE 247-5814
TREE PERMIT
MUST CALL BY 4PM FOR NEXT DAY INSPECTION: 247-5814
]OB INFORMATION:
Job ID: 14-DRTV-1003
SCAA
]ob Type: DEV REV TREES/VEGETATION�
Description: Tree Removal Application
Estimated Value:
/1
Issue Date: 12/3/2014
Expiration Date: 6/1/2015
PROPERTY ADDRESS:
Address: 1748 OCEAN GROVE DR
RE Number: 169616-0000
PROPERTY OWNER:
Name: LOTOWYCZ, WILLIAM W
Address: 1748 OCEAN GROVE DR
PERMIT INFORMATION: PLANNING AND ZONING:
12/03/14
CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL:
REMOVING 11" HARDWOOD TO BE MITIGATED WITH 11" BECAUSE OF TREE
REMOVAL BEFORE A PERMIT.
CREDIT FOR TREES PLANTED: 1 l+ INCHES: 6" PALM, 6 SUGAR PALMS OF
VARIOUS SIZES.
FEES:
TREE REMVL SNGL/TWO FMLY $125.00
TREE REMVL SNGL/TWO FMLY $125.00
Total Payments: $0.00
PERMIT IS APPROVED ONLY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ALL CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH ORDINANCES AND THE FLORIDA
BUILDING CODES.
TREE AND VEGETATION REGULATIONS: General Provisions
Sec. 23-30. Minimum tree requirements.
Sec. 23-31. General prohibitions.
Sec. 23-32. Tree protection during development and construction.
(a) Restrictions during construction.
(1) Placement of materials, machinery, or temporary soils. It shall be unlawful for any person(s) to cause or
allow the storage of construction materials, the use of heavy equipment or machinery, or the temporary storage of soil
de os within the tree protection zone of any tree or group of trees to be retained.
Y'41
D3A11 of waste materials. It shall be unlawful for any person(s) to cause or allow the disposal of waste
is int, oil, solvents, asphalt, concrete, mortar or any other material harmful to the life of a tree within
the tree protection zone of any tree or groups of trees, or where planting beds are to be situated.
(b) Burden of tree protection on property owner. The property owner(s) and their agent(s) shall ensure that any tree
shown on the vegetation inventory for which a tree removal permit has not been obtained is to be protected. The property
owner shall guarantee survival of retained trees and replacement trees for three (3) years from the date the city accepts the
trees and landscaping as complete, unless a greater time period is required by a development order. If a retained or
replacement tree dies during that time period, the property owner shall replace the tree in accordance with a remedial
action as required by this chapter.
(c) Protective barriers and signage required. Protective barriers and signage shall be installed around every tree or
group of trees to be preserved prior to commencement of construction, in compliance with the guidelines in the Tree
Protection Guide for Builders and Developers, published by the Florida Division of Forestry and/or any other reasonable
requirements deemed appropriate by the administrator to implement this part.
(1) Temporary protective barriers shall be placed at least six (6) feet from the base of any tree, and shall
encompass at least fifty (50) percent of the area under the dripline of any tree or trees to be preserved or retained for
mitigation credit, unless otherwise approved by the administrator.
(2) Temporary protective barriers shall be at least three (3) feet high, and shall consist of either a wood fence
with two-by-four posts placed a maximum of eight (8) feet apart with a two-by-four minimum top rail, or a mesh
fence, or other similar barrier which will limit access to the protected area, unless otherwise approved by the
administrator.
(3) Waterproof, rigid sign(s) shall be affixed to each individual barricade, such that there is one (1) sign every
fifteen (15) feet along the length of the barricade. The signs shall contain the following words, and will be made
available by the city at the time of permit issuance:
(d) Adjacent properties. The property owner(s) or their agent(s) shall ensure protective barricading of all trees located
on adjacent properties, that have root or branch systems that encroach upon the subject property, and that may potentially
be impacted by development activities.
Sec. 23-33. Mitigation to be assessed.
Sec. 23-34. Maintenance and monitoring requirements.
The applicant shall be responsible for maintaining the health of any replacement or relocation trees for three (3)
years from planting.
(1) Determination of success. The applicant shall determine the condition of each tree, three (3) years after the tree
was relocated or planted. This determination shall be submitted to the city for approval within thirty (30) days of being
made. Should any tree die or be in a state of decline within three (3) years of being planted or relocated, the applicant shall
be required to replace the tree within sixty (60) days of that determination. The three-year monitoring and approval period
shall begin anew whenever a tree is replaced. If that replacement tree is found not to be viable at the end of the second
monitoring period, the applicant may pay the appropriate amount into the tree fund in lieu of planting a third replacement
tree. If the applicant fails to replace the tree or to pay the appropriate amount into the tree fund within sixty (60) days, the
applicant shall be in violation of this chapter.
Sec. 23-35. Elimination of undesirable species.
Sec. 23-36. Elimination of contagious diseased and pest -infested trees.
Sec. 23-37. Payment in lieu of replacement/relocation.
I, Terri Ray, MH tpiant'11 inches of new trees at 1748 Ocean Grove Drive, as required by the Tree
Removal Permit 14 -:DR W-1003. ,prior to :the final inspection of the pool permit 14 -POOL -236 at the same
location. If I choose not to. plant -al 1 11 inches of new trees then I will pay the balance into the City's Tree
Fund. I also understand that the final inspection for the pool permit will not be approved until the
mitigation required in the Tree Removal Permit is complete and approved by city staff.
Signature
Date—
TREE & VEGETATION REMOVAL PERMIT A
INSTRUCTIONS
(1) Complete and sign this form.
(2) Attach the required supporting exhibits as listed on the application
checklist.
(3) Contact the Department of Community Development if you have
questions or need assistance completing the application or
determining which exhibits are required for your particular project.
(4) Submit this form, along with all required exhibits and payment to
the City of Atlantic Beach, and in the appropriate amount according
to the application fees listed to the right, to the reception desk at
the Building Department.
SECTION I - SITE INFORMATION
PHYSICAL ADDRESS
SUBDIVISION
OCT 9.9 2014
City of ALERoad
� U �
e>epartmmunity Developm
800 SemAtlantic Beach, FL 32 3;
(P) 9042-
Single-, Two -Family Residential $125.00
F_ Multi -Family Residential $250.00
F_ Comm^rcial./ Industrial $250.00
Institutional / Other Non-residential $250.00
Application # TREE 14 vo3
I 1 `-1 1-� UC e C,41&OCA�)J e i - XI
If an address has not been assigned to this property, contact the AB Building
BLOCK LOT
SECTION If - APPLICANT INFORMATION
NAME OF APPLICANT
ADDRESS OF APPLICANT
PHONE CA AeELL
at (904) 247-5826 to request an address.
RE #
MOWNER f— LEGAL AUTHORIZED AGENT
3 D023
iMAIL cur1-
SECTION III - TREE & VEGETATION REMOVAL REQUEST
I REQUEST THAT THE TREES & VEGETATION ON THE ABOVE DESCRIBED PROPERTY AND INDICATED ON THE ATTACHED REQUIRED
EXHIBITS BE APPROVED FOR REMOVAL, AS PROVIDED IN THE CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH VEGETATION CODE, CHAPTER 23, FOR THE
FOLLOWING REASONS (check all that apply):
j- Vegetation (trees) are difficult to maintain /ownerdislikes.
j Trees are dead, diseased or so weakened by age, storm, fire, or other injury so as to pose a danger to persons, property,
improvements or other trees.
F- Vegetation (trees) pose a safety hazard to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or cause disruption to public utility services.
Vegetation (trees) pose a safety hazard to buildings or structures.
F- Vegetation (trees) completely prevent access or cross access to a lot or parcel.
14 Vegetation and/or trees prevent development or physical use. It is the intent of this provision that a permit shall be granted for
the removal of vegetation and/or trees when the applicant has demonstrated an effort to design or locate the proposed
improvements so as to minimize the removal of vegetation and/or trees.
I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT ALL INFORMATION PROVIDED WITHIN THIS APPLICATION IS CORRECT AND I AGREE TO COMPLY
WITH ALL PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 23, PROTECTION OF TREES AND NATURAL VEGETATION, AND ALL OTHER APPLICABLE
CODES AND ORDINANCES OF THE CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH.
OF APPLICANT
rola����
DATE
FOR INTERNAL OFFICE USE ONLY
FRONTAGE FLU ZVAR ESA SR- I
DEPTH ZONING UBEX H/H 55R-2
ATEA ISA I M1V OAS CR
Tree & Vegetation Removal Perm it App lication_versionoi.oi.og
EXHIBIT B. 'TREE & VEGETATION INVENTORY Application # TREE
For the removal of 25 trees or less associated with major development, redevelopment or renovation of or addition to single-
family or two-family structures, or the removal of 25 trees or less associated with the renovation of or addition to all other non-
residential uses, use the grid below to create a Tree & Vegetation Inventory. Note the scale on the bottom of the page. Plot the
boundaries of the subject property, as well as existing and proposed structure(s). Label all adjacent streets. Note the location of
trees to be removed with an "X". Note the location of trees to be preserved with "[ ]". Note the proposed location of replacement
(mitigation) trees with "0". Number all trees, whether to be removed, preserved or replaced, and list on EXHIBIT C. Tree &
Vegetation Mitigation Worksheet.
ORDERED BY:
The Law Offices of Rod Schloth
2187 S Third St
Jacksonville Bch, FL 32250
904-372-9351
beach@rod-law.com
PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1748 OCEAN GROVE DRIVE ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233
FIELD WORK DATE: 9/312014 REVISION DATE(S): (REV.0 9/512014)
FL1409.0062
BOUNDARY SURVEY
DUVAL COUNTY
TABLE:
L-1 5 03°46'42" E 30.00' (D)
5 04"4&22• E 29.77'(M)
L-2 5 03'46'42' E 30.00' (D)
5 04.48'25' E 30.001M)
L-3 N 03°4642' W 30.00 (D)
N 05°03'25' W 30.02'(M)
SURVEY NUMBER: FL1409.0062
NOTES:
LOT AFFEAR5 TO DE SERVICED DY CITY WATER AND 5EWER:
FENCE OWNERSHIP NOT DETERMINED
O.R.B. 14799, FG. N
72
g I /2 OF LOT 222
N 856-000
6-� 8' E 1125'00 P) V,
�lul`�
O � '
z.a - 1577 1, PG. 1045
RB
;\5 Q N. 1/2 OF LOT 21
41 2 51Y.RM1174E aro
� 2.o i
/ j� 4z 2'
1 h -by 03351 air
been meds w w n
e true end ecareb
pedka set bM by
ChwWS -17dbM
g4°59'39' W 124.92 (M)
O. 5V 1/2 OF'LOT 21 8
(NOT INCLUDED)
dnalbed pq" ho
ow. IQ an4b8IW AI&
btheIdmde I d
Wnry a. Hen
&AbdFim PMbW1WW&rAWedMpw
Lkwwra.ene
We alThh survey ym Pmpows of im
125.00' (r)
a+�N
70
I0
< '.
30.0
w ZZ
Irn
�Np
N �rn�1
NN
N�
P _
3'9
n0�
17th 5TREET
-7 1
0 10 0 15' 30
GRAPHIC SCALE
1 inch - 30 feet
1
{
E%IIIBI`i C. rI'RI;I; VEGETATION MITIGATION W®IgICSI-$EET Application #TREE
1 of Z EXHIBIT C Tree & Vegetation Mitigation Worksheet_versionoi.oi.og
J
l.... i i
4
n
V
6
7-
9-
9to
10
11
_
12 O. /�►
13
14
1
16
17
18
19
ao
I
21
az
i
24
a
26
�7
-,8
a9
'o
31
_
32
3
34
35
6
7
38
9
40
41
42
4
44
45
46
47
48
i
49
1 of Z EXHIBIT C Tree & Vegetation Mitigation Worksheet_versionoi.oi.og
EXHIBIT A. LETTER OF AUTHORIZATION Application # TREE
is hereby authorized to act on behalf of
the owner(s) of those lands described within
the attached application, and as described in the attached deed or other such proof of ownership as may
be required by the City of Atlantic Beach in applying for a development permit.
BY:
Signature of Owner
Printed Name
Mailing Address
Phone
Cell Ema
Signature of Owner
Printed Name
Mailing Address
i
Phone Cell Email
i
Signed and sworn before me on this day of by
E
I
Identification verified:
Oath sworn: ( Yes r No
Notary Signature
My Commission expires:
State of Florida
County of Duval
EXHIBITA_Letter ofAuthorization_versionoi.oi.og
Reeves, Derek
From:
Terri Ray [terrilray@icloud.com]
Sent:
Thursday, October 30, 2014 10:15 AM
To:
Reeves, Derek
Cc:
David Benjamin
Subject:
Re: trees 1748 Ocean Grove Drive
Importance: High
Follow Up Flag: Follow up
Flag Status: Flagged
Derrick
Thanks and find attached the letter stating that as soon as I can, but before final pool inspection, I will plant a
tree of at least 11 inch diameter in the back yard.
Please let us know asap as to the status of the pool permit readiness to be picked up by Surfside Pools!
Thank you!
I, Terri Ray, will plant 11 inches of new trees at 1748 Ocean Grove Drive, as required by the Tree
Removal Permit 14-DRTV-1003, prior to the final inspection of the pool permit 14 -POOL -236 at the same
location. If I choose not to plant all 11 inches of new trees then I will pay the balance into the City's Tree
Fund. I also understand that the final inspection for the pool permit will not be approved until the
mitigation required in the Tree Removal Permit is complete and approved by city staff.
Signature ( ��
Date > U ` t
October 29, 2014
City of Atlantic Beach
Building and Zoning
800 Seminole Road
Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233
Telephone (904) 247-5826
Fax (904) 247-5845
http://www.coab.us
Tree Removal Without a Permit
To whom it may concern,
The city contacted the property owner of 1748 Ocean Grove Drive, Terri Ray, with a letter dated
October 23, 2014 regarding trees removed from her property without a permit. Subsequent
conversations with Ms. Ray have led to the city updating the previously mentioned letter.
Ms. Ray has admitted that another tree has been removed from the rear of the property that staff
was not aware of at the time of the first letter. Ms. Ray provided a photo of the tree in the rear
yard prior to removal. This photo was used to aid estimations of the size of the tree for mitigation
purposes. Staff estimates the size to be 11 inches in diameter at breast height. Ms. Ray also
provided photos of the tree in the front yard that were more recent than those used in the first
letter. Those photos showed further reductions in live growth on the tree compared to those used
by staff in the previous letter. Based on those more recent photos of the tree, staff has determined
that tree removed in the front yard was dead or flying and posing a potential hazard related to its
condition and severe lean. This determination results in no mitigation required for the 16 inch
tree removed from the front yard.
While the 16 inch tree could have been taken down with no mitigation necessary, the removal of
the 11 inch treadn the rear yard and the subsequent pool permit means that the conditions of the
previous letter, still apply. A Tree Removal Permit is required with a fee twice the normal
application fee and mitigation will be assessed at twice the normal rate. In addition, no permitted
work may take place until the Tree Removal Permit is approved.
Derek W. Reeves
Zoning Technician
Attached: After Pictures
Before Pictures
Tree Removal Permit
i
m
. I �l�Rll vUU
'��" 7 � �•�1 •' � C.,.l� V'A`C ' �.,# � (� 1 /,
� � .✓ ter_ °,� "�►. �%�. �'�/. AI �.���� X641, _
• �, �� �I. 1'a%ar fir. 1 ^���\'� ��'
r• � ' 1T�t �,w' \ � ,; �*. ",� � -moi r' � �' - � >K �` . i
rd �$,�� `J' P\ '¢+ IVB" •� J'•1� �. .l l• ...
�,i Ili fI
Y �4 �r1{� j ,+.,,,, ,�ry• � � ,fir'
• � q i R ,f� ii ' a iS i
oo
yr-�' �✓� ,{ �`' •:� �� {� , ,1,
ak
Al
YAP
a�
0
a�
cz
3
cz
c�
a�
0
a�
V)
3
0
V)
4
0
N
O
bio
O
C/1
O
It..
O
O
u
U
i1
0
"72
TREE REMOVAL PERMIT
City of Atlantic Beach
Building and Zoning Department
800 Seminole Road Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233-5445
Phone: (904) 247-5826 Fax: (904) 247-5845 Email: Building-Dept@coab.us
Permit: 14-DRTV-1003
Site Address: 1748 Ocean Grove Dr
RE#: 169616-0000
Applicant: Terri Ray
Address: 1748 Ocean Grove Drive, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233
Phone: (904)625-2218
Email: terrilray@icloud.com
TREE REMOVAL CALCULATIONS
Protected Trees Removed:
Trees Removed:
Mitigation Needed:
Credit for Trees Preserved:
Trees Preserved:
Credit for Trees Relocated:
Trees Relocated:
Credit for Trees Planted:
Trees Planted:
Total:
11 inches
11" Hardwood
11 inches (1 inch for every 2 inches removed*)
0 inches
None
0 inches
None
MITIGATION REQUIRED
New Trees Planted:
or
Payment Into Tree Fund:
or
A Combination of the Above
0 inches
inches
11 inches
11 inches X $49.00 = $539.00
Additional Notes: Required to pay twice the normal permit fee for tree removal without a permit as required
by Section 23-51. Total permit fee will be $250.00. Also removed a 16 inch tree in front determined to be dead.
* Normal rate for mitigation is 1 inch for every 2 inches removed. However, because trees were removed
without a permit, removed regulated trees will be assessed at twice the normal rate.
Status is in accordance with the City of Atlantic Beach code of ordinances in effect at the time of review.
APPROVED
DENIED
to 30 I
remy H sch, TPO ADMINISTRATOR 6AIt
TREE REMOVAL PERMIT
City of Atlantic Beach
Building and Zoning Department
800 Seminole Road Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233-5445
Phone: (904) 247-5826 Fax: (904) 247-5845 Email: Building-Dept@coab.us
Permit: 14-DRTV-1003
Site Address: 1748 Ocean Grove Dr
RE#: 169616-0000
Applicant: Terri Ray
Address: 1748 Ocean Grove Drive, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233
Phone: (904)625-2218
Email: terrilray@icloud.com
TREE REMOVAL CALCULATIONS
Protected Trees Removed:
Trees Removed:
Mitigation Needed:
Credit for Trees Preserved:
Trees Preserved:
Credit for Trees Relocated:
Trees Relocated:
Credit for Trees Planted:
Trees Planted:
Total:
FILE carr
1 1 inches
11" Hardwood
11 inches (1 inch for every 2 inches removed*)
0 inches
None
0 inches
None
11+ inches
6" Palm, 6 sugar palms of various sizes
11+ inches
MITIGATION REQUIRED
New Trees Planted: 0 inches
or
Payment Into Tree Fund: 0 inches X $49.00 = $0.00
or
A Combination of the Above
Additional Notes: Required to pay twice the normal permit fee for tree removal without a permit as required
by Section 23-51. Total permit fee paid $250.00. Also removed a 16 inch tree in front determined to be dead.
* Normal rate for mitigation is 1 inch for every 2 inches removed. However, because trees were removed
without a permit, removed regulated trees will be assessed at twice the normal rate.
Status is in accordance with the City of Atlantic Beach code of ordinances in effect at the time of review.
APPROVED VN
DENIED ❑ �� y
4e4Huu T O AD IRATOR A E