Exh 8DAGENDA ITEM #3D
JAi~1UARY 10, 2005
' CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH
CITY COMMISSION MEETING
STAFF REPORT
AGENDA ITEM: Five Points Intersection Improvements Project
RFP #OS-04
SUBMITTED BY: Rick Carper, P.E. ,/~ ~(~/
Public Works DirectoY
DATE: December 28, 2004
. BACKGROUND: The Public Works Department solicited an advertisement for
Request for Proposals (RFP) for Professional Engineering Services
' for the Five Points Intersection Improvements Project, and on
,December 13, 2004 we received five proposals. The five firms
that submitted proposals were Bowen Civil Engineering; C3TS
• (Corzo, Castella, Carballo, Thompson, Salman); Edwards &
.. Kelcey, GAI Consultants, and HDR Engineering.
• After staff evaluation, the firms were rated in the following order:
I S` -HDR Engineering
2nd -Bowen Civil Engineering
3`d -GAI Consultants
4`~ -Edwards &Kelcey
• 5~' - C3TS
RECOMMENDATION: Authorize staff to begin negotiations with the top-ranked firm,
HDR Engineering, for engineering services for the Five Points
Intersection Improvements Project.
ATTACHMENT: Evaluation of Proposals Rating Sheet
. Proposals are on file at the City Clerk's Office
REVIEWED BY CITY MANAGER:
~~ z~ ~d W zzo ~~
~
~
~
~
~ _.
~
y ~
K~ ~~ ~
~z ~
~ ~r ,
~~
,
~ ~
~ ~ z
r
o ~_
~~ ~ ,
N ~'
o
~
~, ~ '~
a
o O
~...
,
W ~ ~
o
W ~ ~.~ ~
o
`~ ~- ~ ~ '
.~ ~ r
~• n ~ ~.
CD ~
0 ,
... m ~
.-+ .tom ~, ~s ., r-.
O O O NO N ~ ~ • ~' ~
O
n ~ -~r
~
^*
• Z
• ~
~ ~ V
F~
O p O
O O
~ ~ ~ n' ~
~ ~
n
~ ] ,
~
a °° ~ <
~ `.
~- Ch
oN _
°
o o o° ~ ~ o ~,
O ~. ~ ~ ..,
~ ~
.
. a
ti
. -, . ,
n'
O
~ ~
¢. ~'
~
p
O
~
~
W ,~
.7 i-r
~ N
VI ' ,
~
~ .
O
O
N
~
v ~
1
O ~ ~ ~ .7 _.
~, .
O ~. ~
.
O ~ ~
~ ~
~
~ ~ ..~
N
~
~
p.
O O p .r
O
O O o l~ ~~
~ ` ,,
' O
y C].. cD ~_
,gyp
O~
~
v
~
~
O
~ Cr1 ...~ 0
~ ,
~
W C11
~
~-'
~
~
W OA ~
~
W
~ `
h ,
~
. .
N N ~ n
~: ~.
soot `or ~x~n~r ~'
bq
Q8# L1I~.LI t~Qt~i~~t~ _...