Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
11-19-12 CEB Exhibits 1-26.pdf
POLICE AEPARn ENT $50 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 2474859 FAX; (904) 205899 h___p: /1www.coaU,ua Animal Complaint Affidavit •I I have been advised of my constitutional rights and know that, I -do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily malting- the following statement, kmw3ng full well that this statement, or, any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at ahy time in any court, trial, or other issue. I :Finer state that T have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. 4 y lime is w 4 t , Iliveat 1�_ i'S'' A`�'tc� "tGr ' FL 322:331.4 ddress City state and my telephone number is Name/Description of AnimaL y a b vow n 101 " cJ 1 t'Yl 1 x. � Name %Address of Owner; Time and Date of Incident: Describe the incident: 'Aram of M e I r/ IN car as ffsLi 1�n i n o.LJ�*g4n 'keeL aQk Loddexd eY6 f ruin Wd me, W10 hi n 11 OVER r wir :caaram r„ •.,,. as ,.A• I Continuation of Statement Wage Z of CK0F7,�( [ pages lJ 1111S Know War i) b I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief \ n „n STATE OF FLORIDA - of Parent or Guardian if Mnor Sworn to and subscribed Before me this 304`' day of�-w by (Name of person malong iement) Notary Seal: JOHN MEEKS ccmm# D00560,835, r • • Ef p1rsa 71112010 Florida hc'a, /Ass,l „Ina Notary Public/Officer M k vn Ntmb print, 'fie, or Stainp Dame Personally Known„✓ OR Produced M M., type & numbe r W I oq� .6ii 2- Page b of 12 gency ORI Ine1_ At Offense Report Agency Report _fnbar L0160100 Additional Narratives 12 -17086 Title: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVIT (JULY 26, 2012) ACO K. CATON #309 10/02/2012 On September 25th, 2012, I, ACO Kelley Caton, received a signed City of Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint Affidavit from Ronelle L. Davis in reference to an incident that occurred late morning on July 26, 2012. According to the affidavit completed by Ms. Davis, she stated that she witnessed a black dog from 330 Magnolia Street run through her yard and into the yard of 346 Magnolia Street, The dog "charged and bared its teeth" at the pet sitter (later identified as B.J. Lester). As the pet sitter was with the black pit bull in the yard of 346 Magnolia Street, a young girl (kindergarten or first grade age) and her grandmother were riding their bikes down the street. The black dog then "quickly approached" the little girl and growled at her. The owner came out of 366 Magnolia Street and called multiple times to the black dog. Ms. Davis stated that the owner of the dog, "Willi" (Cecilia Babillis), carried the dog back to 330 Magnolia Street. Shortly thereafter, Ms. Davis witnessed Ms. Babillis' other dogs, Jack and Lola, aggressively approach and growl at the same woman and child riding bicycles south on Magnolia Street. Ms. Davis stated that the pet sitter placed herself between the dogs and the child before Ms. Babillis retrieved her dogs. On October 1st, 2012, I initiated a follow -up investigation into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Ms. Davis. I advised Ms. Davis that I had a few clarifying questions regarding her affidavit and she agreed to speak with me. During our conversation Ms. Davis provided additional details in reference to her affidavit. Ms. Davis said she was inside her home on the morning of July 26, 2012. From her second floor kitchen window she witnessed a black dog run north through her yard and run into the back yard of 346 Magnolia Street, one house to the south of hers. The back yard of 346 Magnolia Street Is fenced, but the gate was opened. Ms. Davis recognized the dog as one of three dogs residing at 330 Magnolia. She said that she recognized that the black dog is from 330 Magnolia Street because she frequently sees it on the front porch when she walks by. Ms. Davis observed pet sitter B.J. Lester stop her car in front of 346 Magnolia Street, Ms. Davis stated that her view was partially blocked by trees. She could see the back end of Ms. Lester's car, but doesn't know exactly when Ms. Lester exited the car. Ms. Davis stepped outside onto her front porch to warn Ms. Lester about the dog. Ms. Davis saw the black dog circle Ms. Lester's car. She also witnessed the dog charge and bare its teeth. She could not see what Ms. Lester was doing when she was approached by the dog. Ms. Davis said that Ms. Lester grabbed a stick to prevent the dog from re- entering the back yard of 346 Magnolia Street and tried to close the gate. Ms. Lester also yelled at the dog to go home. At that point the dog growled at Ms. Lester. While this was going on, Ms. Davis observed a girl approximately five or six years old and a woman she believed to be the child grandmother riding bicycles south on Magnolia St. At this time Ms. Davis was on her front porch. She stated that her view was blocked by trees and she did not see the Iittle girl and woman until they were in front of her house. Ms. Davis does not know the woman or child and has not seen them before. However, she feels that Ms. Lester did know them. Ms. Lester approached the woman and child, Ms. Davis stated it appeared that Ms. Lester wanted to warn them about the dog, Ms. Davis saw the black dog approach the group and observed Ms. Lester step in front of the child. The dog was approximately 5 feet from Ms. Lester and 8 feet from the woman and child. Ms. Davis said in her affidavit that the black dog growled. I asked her if she could remember hearing a growl or seeing bared teeth. She said no. Ms. Davis said that saw the owner, Cecilia Babillis, come from 366 Magnolia Street, which is a vacant house north of hers. Ms. Davis does not know why Ms. Babillis was at 366 Magnolia Street. Ms. Davis knows Ms. Babillis from the neighborhood and has had positive interactions with her in the past. Ms. Babillis called the black dog and it returned to her right away. I asked Ms. Davis to clarify W h Z 04W111 , Pegg 7 of 12 geneyoitt Inc,_.rnt Offense Report AnencyRepo�, ,mher L0160100 Additional Narratives 12 -17086 Tift SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVIT (JULY 26, 2012) this, because her affidavit says that the dog did not come right away. She said she definitely remembers the black dog came right away. Ms. Davis cannot remember the dog's name. Ms. Davis said that Ms. Babillis apologized to the group and took the dog to 330 Magnolia. Ms. Lester was in the street talking to the woman and child when Ms. Babillis walked north, retuning to 366 Magnolia Street. Ms. Babiliis walked past the group and did not interact with anyone. When Ms. Babillis was halfway down the driveway of 366 Magnolia Street, Ms. Davis heard a banging noise that she thinks was the side gate 330 Magnolia Street. Ms. Davis saw Ms. Babillis's two other dogs - a brown pit bull and a brown & white pit bull - and aggressively approach the group, circling the little girl on the bicycle. I asked Ms. Davis to clarify this, because her affidavit says that the dogs "approached aggressively ". I asked her to define what she meant. She had trouble defining the dogs' behavior. I asked if the dogs were barking or growling. She said the dogs were not growling and appeared curious. Ms. Lester tried to shoo them away with a stick. Ms. Davis said that Ms. Babillis got there about same time "we're talking seconds." Ms. Babillis and Ms. Lester exchanged words. Ms. Davis could not hear most of the exchange, but remembers Ms. Lester mention leash laws and Ms. Babillis call her an "old cow." Ms. Babillis picked up one dog and headed towards 330 Magnolia Street and the other dog followed. Ms. Davis cannot remember which dog was carried, and stated that "from the back end both dogs look the same." Ms. Davis stated that she did not leave her property during the incident. She did not run out to help with the dogs because she felt that an extra person might upset the dogs. She also stated that she has known Ms. Lester for years, knows that she was an animal control officer at one time and felt that Ms. Lester could handle the situation. I then attempted to make contact with Ms. Lester via phone on October 1st, 2012 at approximately 5:22 p.m. and 5:47 p.m., but received no answer. I left a message requesting her to call me back. On October 2nd, 2012 at approximately I attempted to contact Ms. Lester via phone but received no answer. I left a message for Ms. Lester to contact me. Sergeant Jevic advised Sergeant Tusing and I that he observed Ms. Lester's vehicle parked at the Beaches Branch Library in Neptune Beach. Sergeant Tusing and I met up with Ms. Lester at the Beaches Library. Ms. Lester initially stated that she had received my calls, did not recall when the event occurred, and did not want to talk about the incident. I continued to speak with her and she stated that she remembered there were three dogs loose on Magnolia Street. One was a short - haired black dog that she described as "fearfully aggressive." She said that it bared its teeth and barked at her. Ms. Lester said she grabbed a palm frond to keep it away from her. Sergeant Tusing asked Ms. Lester if she was afraid and she stated no, and she was an animal control officer for 10 years in Atlantic Beach. She stated that someone without her experience would probably be nervous and afraid when confronted with the dog's behavior. Ms. Lester stated that the dog cowered when the owner, a young white female, came to get it. She stated that the owner gave it verbal commands and the dog became compliant I asked Ms. Lester if she knew the names of the woman and child who rode by on bicycles. She said that she did not. Ms. Lester remembered that while she was speaking to the woman, two other dogs ran north on Magnolia Street and circled her, the woman, and the child. I asked about the dogs' behavior and she stated that they were not growling or baring their teeth. Ms. Lester said that the same owner came back with leashes and took the dogs away. I asked her if she spoke with the owner. She said yes, but cannot remember exactly what was said. Sergeant Tusing asked Ms. Lester if she would fill out an Animal Control Affidavit about the incident and she refused. s i- a W i z ift d ti ui A.. U) tJ! • U) N 0 a Q ❑ Juvenile Page 1 of 12 F Original C SupptementtCurrent OFFENSE INCIDENT REPORT Agency Report Number 12 -17086 Agency ORI FLO160100 Reported: Day Date Time (mil) Wednes ay 09/19/201212:45 Time Dispatched (mil) 12:45 Time Arrived (mll) 12:45 Time Completed (mil) #Victims #Offenders #Prem.£nt 0 #Veh.Stolen Incident: Day Date Time (mil) Day Date Time (mil) From Wednesday 09/19/2012 12:45 Wednesday 09/19/201212 :55 Incident Location 330 MAGNOLIA Street ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233- Geographic Indicator SALT AIR Tract Method of Operation DANGEROUS DOG INVESTIGATION Description of incident DANGEROUS DOG Location Typo Occupancy C w-enify Type Description AttempAomolete NOICIUCR Code Forced Entry ORDINAI Dangerous Dog A 00 N/A Statute %notation Number: 1 Weapon Code: Offense indicator VAN Coda # V. Typo Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix WITNESS No LESTER, BETTY JO Address (Street, Apartment Number) 907 SECOND Street City NEPTUNE BEACH State FL Zip 1 32266 - Residence Phone Other Contact Info (Time Available, interpreter) Synopsis Of Involvement Business Phone Race WHITE Sex FEMALE DOB 06/14/1931 Age 81 Res. Type Rea. Status Extent of Injury TlZitirvTypo Relationship Occupation Employer /Schooi Address SSN Drivaes License (State and Number) Other ID (Numberand State) Scare, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCIC /NCIC Height Weight 0 Eye Color Hair Color WHITE Hair Length Hair Style Complexion Build Faclai Hair Teeth SpeachAfolce Ethnicity Offense Indicator Involvement Typo Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Cade Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State Zip Residence Phone Maiden Name NlcknamelStroetname Place of Birth Business Phone Race Sex DOB Age Clothing Rea. Typo Rea. Status Occupation Empioyedschool Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) care, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIO Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Tooth SpoechlVoice Ethnicity Special identftiem ImmigrationlNaturalization # Incident Type Foul Play? Musing Before? Fingerprints? Photo Available? Dental Record? MCIC Forth? Date Last Seen Time Last Seen Location Last Seen ( Addreas, City, St.) Accompanied By Mental /Physical Condition Medication Required/Typo DoctoriDentiat (Name, Phone Number) Property Carried Recovery information Type Description Status quantity Measure Street Value Activity 1 Activity 2 Activity 3 Ui 0 �Tk , Extf t P° Page 2 of 12 Related To: Statue Cade Damage Code Type Veh.# Year Make Model Style VINMuilNumber Tag Reg.IDoc. # Plate State Plate Year Reg. State Rag. Year Decal Number Tag Typo Condition Insurance Company Lien Holder Eatima led Value Color Description (tdentifying Characteristics Noticeable Damage, Interior Color, Etc.) Vessel Name Length Hull Material Propulsion Boat Type Recovery Loc. Recovery Code Recovery Address /Geographic Indicator Date Recovered Value Recovered Method Of Theft Original Reporting Agency Report Number Hold Reason/Authority Components Stripped Towed By Storage Location FCICINCIC Person Code item # Damage Code Type Poo Status Quantity Name Brand Make Model Serial Number Owner Applied Number Description (Size, Color, Caliber, Barrel Length, Etc.) Value Value Recovered Date Recovered FCICINCIC Related To: Status Type BanklCard Issuer Account Number Documant7Serial Number Printed Name Payable To Face Signature Endorsement Other Names) Service/Property Received ID. Type ID, No, Document Date Amount Title: ANIMAL COMPLAINTS K. Caton, #309 12 -17086 10/09/2012 On September 19, 2012 a Dangerous Dog investigation was initiated in reference to three dogs residing at 330 Magnolia Street. Multiple complaints have been received by the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Department via notarized affidavits which meet the requirements of City Ordinance 4 -10 defining dangerous dogs. This investigation is regarding Jewel, the black, intact (not spayed) female pit bull. Supplemental investigations to follow. [END] Report Contains Related Report Number(s) Reporting OrMcerAD Reporting OfticerAO Unit Date 309 CATON, KELLEY 309 CATON, KELLEY AC 10/9/2012 3:05:40 PM OtAoerRaNeuivg(yAppicabb) ELAnt r Routed To Referred To Assigned To By GUALILLO, 1401 Case Status FURTHER Clearance Type Data Cleared Number Arreated a W Z ti• 6 u G W Z Imo+ g V rT` ! W Z h- C� 7 gency ORI L0160100 Inc I_.at Offense Report Additional VictimsMitnesses Agency Report._attbor 12 -17086 oil h t2- Offense Indicator I VIW Code # WITNESS V. Type I Juvenile Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) I I Mills, Kathy Suffix Address (Street, Apartment Number) City Cfly State FL Zip Zip Residence Phone 000- 000 -0000 other Contact Into (Time Available, interpreter) Other Contact info (Time Available, Interpreter) Synopsis Of Involvement Synopsis Of Involvement Business Phone 000 -000 -0000 Race Sex FEMALB DOB Age 00 Res. Type Roo, Status Extent Of injury Injury Type Relattonshlp Occupation Empioyeri$chool Occupation Address SSN DrivePs License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) SSN Scam, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC Haight Weight Eye Color HalrColor HoirLongth HalrStyte Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth Build Speech/Voice Ethnicity Speech/Voice Ethntctty Offense Indicator VNV Code # V. Type V. Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Address (Street, Apartment Number) City Cfly State Zip Zip Residence Phone Other Contact Info (Time Available, Interpreter) Other Contact info (Time Available, Interpreter) Synopsis Of involvement Synopsis Of Involvement Business Phone Race Sex DOB Age Rea. Type Res. Status Extent Of Injury injury Typo Relationship Occupation EmpioyerlSchooi Occupation Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) SSN Scars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Halr Styto Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth Build SpeachNoice Ethnicity Speech/Voice Ethntctty Offense Indicator VNV Code # V. Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Address ($treat, Apartment Number) Cfly State Zip Residence Phone Other Contact info (Time Available, Interpreter) Synopsis Of Involvement Business Phone Race Sex DOB Age Res. Type Rea. Status Extent Of Injury Injury Type Relationship Occupation Employer /School Address SSN driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) Scars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC Haight Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Tooth Speech/Voice Ethntctty d .s.+ 9 ts 0 sncy ORI L0160100 0 -J Inct,.dnt Offense Report Other Persons Involved Agency Repott...,mber 12-17086 t NM PA i P- Offense indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Suspect Code Address (Street, Apartment Number) 354 MAGNOLIA Street OTHER No BABILLIS, CECILIA WILLEEN state FL Yip 32233- Address (Street, Apartment Number) Residence Phone 904 - 703 -0314 City I State Zip Place of Birth Residence Phone 330 MAGNOLIA Street Business Phone ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233 - DOB 01/03/1958 Age 54 Malden Name Nickname /Strootname Place of Birth j Business phone Occupation Employer /School Address FLORIDA SSN SSN Race Sex OOii Age Clothing FCICINCIC Rea. Typo Weight 0 Ross Status WHITE FEMALE 08/01/1992 20 Hair Style Hair Style Complexion Complexion Build Facial Heir Tooth Occupation Empioyar /School SpoaolWolce Ethnicity Address SSN STUDENT Drivers License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) ftam, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC B142119927810 FL Height Weight EyeCOfor Hair Color Hair Length Hairstyle 507 0 Complexion Build Facial Hair Tooth SpeechNolce Ethnicity Offense Indicator Involvement Type OTHER involvement type IREPORTEE Juvenile No Name (Last, First, Middle) LEVISEUR, SUZANNE Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street, Apartment Number) 330 MAGNOLIA ST Address (Street, Apartment Number) 354 MAGNOLIA Street City I ATLANTIC BEACH City ATLANTIC BEACH state FL Yip 32233- Residence Phone 904 - 703 -0314 Maiden Name NleknamolStreetname Place of Birth Place of Birth PENNSYLVANIA Business Phone Business Phone Race WHITE Sex FEMALE DOB 01/03/1958 Age 54 Clothing 1 Rea. Type Res. Type j Res. States Occupation Employer /School Address Address SSN SSN rs License (State and Number) 0720565630 FL Drivers License (State and Number) L126557585030 FL Other ID (Number and State) Scam, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC Height 504 Weight 0 Eye Color Hair Color Hair Color Halt Length Hair Length Hair Style Hair Style Complexion Complexion Build Facial Heir Tooth Teeth SpeechNolce SpoaolWolce Ethnicity Ethnicity Offense indleator involvement type IREPORTEE Juvenile No Name (Leaf, First, Middle) DAVIS, RONELLE Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street, Apartment Number) 354 MAGNOLIA Street City ATLANTIC BEACH State FL 7322337 Yip Residence Phone 904 - 249 -1484 Malden Name N[ckname /Streetname Place of Birth Business Phone TE Sex FEMALE DOB 02/23/1956 Age 56 Clothing Rea. Type Res, Status FRa pation Employer/School Address SSN rs License (State and Number) 0720565630 FL Other ID (Number and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCiC/NCIC Height 506 Weight 0 Eye Color Hair Color Halt Length Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Tooth SpeechNolce Ethnicity E .0 T d .0 0 gency ORI L0160100 Inc►....nt Offense Report Other Persons involved Agency Report ....tuber 12 -17086 l9ah b �f M Offense Indicator involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Suspect Code REPORTEE No DETERS - SMITH, GRETCHEN ROSS, WILLIAM ERIC Address (Street, Apartment Number) Maiden Name Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State zip City Residence Phone 346 MAGNOLIA Street Sex Residence Phone ATLANTIC BEACH FL Age Clothing 904 - 247 -9939 Malden Name 32233- Nicknametstrestnome Place of Birth 904- 382 -0854 Business Phone Nickname/Stmetname place of Birth MAINS Business Phone Driver's License (State and Number) Race Sex DOB FLORIDA Age Clothing Race Res. Type DOB Res. Status WHITE FEMALE 05/11/1952 60 Res, Status WHI MALE 02/02/1983 29 Full Year Occupation EmployeriSchoo! 1 Address Occupation SSN UNKNOWN OR Address SSN MARION COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT Driver's License ($tats and Number) Other ID (Number and State) Sears, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICiNCIC D362280526710 FL Marks, Tattoos (Location and Desoription) FCICiNCiC 8200925830420 FL Height Weight Eye Color Eye Color HalrCotor Hair Length Hairstyle 508 0 160 BROWN BROWN SHORT Complexion Build Facial Hair Facial Hair Teeth SpeachNoice Ethnicity Ethnicity Offense Indicator FREPORITEE volveent Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street Apartment Number) City No ROSS, WILLIAM ERIC Residence Phone Maiden Name Address (Street, Apartment Number) Nloknome /Streetname Place of Birth City State Zip Sex Residence Phone 301 MAGNOLIA Street Age Clothing ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233- Res. Status 904- 382 -0854 Maiden Name Nickname/Stmetname place of Birth SSN Business Phone Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Numberand State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FLORIDA Height Weight Race Sex I DOB Hair Length Age Clothing 1 Res. Typo Res, Status WHI MALE 02/02/1983 29 Ethnicity 1 Full Year Occupation Employer /School Address SSN MARION COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) Sears, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Desoription) FCICiNCiC 8200925830420 FL Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Hairstyle 508 160 BROWN BROWN SHORT STRAIGHT Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth SpeachNoice Ethnicity NON - HISPANIC Offense indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street Apartment Number) City State Zip Residence Phone Maiden Name Nloknome /Streetname Place of Birth Business Phone Race Sex DOB Age Clothing Rea, Type Res. Status Occupation Employer /School Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Numberand State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCICINCIC Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length HalrStylo Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth Speech1voice Ethnicity Page 8 of 14 gencyORI Inc,_.,nt Offense Report AgencyRepoi, mber FL0160100 Additional Narratives 12 -17085 :1 Title: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVIT tAUG 10, 2012) SGT. J. Tusing #1408 ` — 10/03/2012 On October 2nd, 2012, at approximately 3:25 p.m., I (Sgt. J.N. Tusing #1408) initiated a follow -up investigation into the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavit received from Mr. Robbins in reference to an incident that occurred on August 10th, 2012, at approximately 4:45 p.m. at 310 Magnolia Street. Mr. Robbins stated in his affidavit that the brown and white pit bull mix nipped a roofing contractor that was working at his house. Mr. Robbins stated that the dog ran at the contractor and the contractor grabbed a hammer to back it down. Mr. Robbins stated that he then observed a dog growling at the contractor. He stated that "the nip was minor only due to the contractor's quick action." At approximately 3:30 p.m., I contacted Mr. Robbins via phone and requested he provide the name of the roofing company he contracted with when this incident occurred and he advised Romano's Roofing. A Google search located a phone number of 904 - 246 -5649 for Romano Roofing. I contacted the number and spoke to Danny Romano who advised that his brother Joey Romano handled the roofing jobs at the beach, and he was unaware of any employees complaining of being bitten by a dog. Danny Romano provided with the phone number (904- 838 -5559) to his brother Joey Romano. I then contacted Joey Romano via phone who recalled doing a roof repair for Bruce Robbins on Magnolia Street. Mr. Romano stated that he had two employees with him at the job site Randy (unknown last name) and Aaron (unknown last name). He recalled seeing several dogs running loose while they were there but could not provide a description. He further stated that Aaron may have approached him regarding one of the dogs either biting him or was trying to bite him but was not able to provide details. I asked if he could provide a last name or contact number for Aaron and he advised he would call me back. He stated that Aaron only worked for him for approximately one week. On October 3rd, 2012, at approximately 1 :37 p.m., I received a phone call from Joey Romano who advised that he does not know Aaron's last name and provided his phone number of 904 -327 -2089. At approximately 3 :15 p.m., I attempted to contact this number and it went straight to voicemail. The voicemail was automated and did not indicate who the number belonged to. I left a message for Aaron to contact me. I then ran a database search of the phone number to attempt to identify any persons listed using this number in any police contacts and the results were negative. At approximately 3:30 p.m., I contacted Mr. Robbins in reference to the affidavit he completed and advised him that I had a few clarification questions and he agreed to speak with me. During our conversation Mr. Robbins stated that he was not present when the roofing contractor was bitten. He stated that he was coming out of the side gate and observed the brown pit bull which he believed to be "Jack," growling at the contractor. He stated the dog quickly fled the yard, then the contractor told him the dog just bit him. The contractor stated that the dog just bit him on the forearm. He stated that the dog was unleashed and the owner was not present. I asked Mr. Robbins to describe the injury the contractor sustained and he advised that it was a "small break in the skin." He further described it as similar to a scrape sustained from walking through a "briar bush," and that the wound did not appear to be a puncture wound. Q C1 83 LU V S Z Z 1w1�� IG 0 till EL to iL O. Z r Ci obi[ 3 Pagel of14 �? Original 0 Juvenile OF Sui►Dfement/Current Agency ORI FLOI60100 OFFENSE INCIDENT REPORT Agency Report Number 1247085 Reported: Day Date Time (mll) Wednesday 09/19/201212:45 1 Time Dispatched (mill 12 :45 Time Arrived (mil) 12:45 Time Completed (mil) #Off. # Victims # Offenders # Prom. Ent 0 # Vohs Stolen incident: Day Date Time (mil) Day Data Time (mil) From Wednesday 09 /19/201212:45 Wednesday 09/19/201212 :55 incident Location 330 MAGNOLIA Street ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233- Geographic indicator SALT AIR Tract Method ofOper at] on DANGEROUS DOG INVESTIGATION pascriptionofinckient DANGEROUS DOG Location Type RESIDENCE - SINGLE Occupancy OCCUPIED 02nie TIM Rossi iiltioll AttemaUComnlete NCICJUCR Code Forged grttry ORDINAINon- Criminal Reports A 00 N/A Statute Violation Number: 1 Weapon Code: Offenso indicator VM Code# V. Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix WITNESS No LESTER, BETTY O Address (Street, Apartment Number) 907 SECOND Street City [NEPTUNE BEACH state FL Zip 32266- Residence Phone 904- 249 -2015 Other Contact Info (77mo Available, interpreter) Synopsis Of involvement Business Phone Race WHITE Sex FEMALE DOB 06/14/1931 Age 81 Res, Typo Res, Status Extant Of Injury injury Type Relationship Occupation SELF EMPLOYED EmptayerlSchooE Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) L236090317140 FL Other ID (Number and State) Sears, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCfC /NCIC Haight 505 Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Tooth speech/Voice Ethnicity NON- HISPANIC Offense Indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State Zip Residence Phone Malden Name Nickname /Stmetneme Place of Birth Business Phone Race Sex 000 Age Clothing Res. Type Res, Status Occupation EmpioyedSchool Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCtC /NCtC Helght Weight Eye Color Hair Color • Hair Length Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth SpeechNoloe Ethnicity Special Identifiers immigration/Naturaiization # Incident Type Foul Play? Missing Before? Fingerprints? Photo Available? Dental Record? MCIC Form? Date Last Seen Time Last Seen Location Last Sean (Address, City, St.) Accompanied By Mental/Physical Condition Medication Requiredrrype DoctoriDentiet (Name, Phone Number) Property Carried Recovery Information Type Description Status quantity Measure Street Value Activity 1 Activity 2 Activity 3 LL U • • Page 2 of 14 Related To: Status Code Damage Code 7MN/Hull po oil Veh. # Year Make Model Style Number Tag Ro9JDoc, # Plate State Plate Year Reg. State Reg. Year Decal Number Tag Type Condition Insurance Company Lien Holder Eatimate l Value Color Description (fdentitying Characteristics Noticeable Damage, interior Color, Etc.) Vessel Name Length Hull Matoriat Propulsion Boat Type I Recovery Loc. Recovery Code Recovery AddreaslGeographic Indicator Date Recovered Value Recovered Method Of Theft Original Reporting Agency Report Number Hold ReasonlAuthority Components Stripped Towed By 5forage Location FCICINCIC Person Code kem # Damage Code Type Statue Quantity Nam& Brand Make Mode! Serial Number Owner Applied Number Description (Size, Color, Callbor, Barrel Length, Etc.) Value Value Recovered Date Recovered FCICINCIC Related To: Status Type Sank/Card issuer Account Number Doe umanUSerial Number Printed Name Payable To Face Signature Endorsement Other Nama(aj Service/Property Received ID* Type ID. No. Document Data Amount iltie: ANIMAL COMPLAINTS K. Caton, #309 12-17'085 10/09/2012 On September 19, 2012 a Dangerous Dog investigation was initiated in reference to three dogs residing at 330 Magnolia Street. Multiple complaints have been received by the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Department via notarized affidavits which meet the requirements of City Ordinance 4 -10 defining dangerous dogs. This investigation is regarding Lola, the brown brindle and white, spayed female pit bull. Supplemental investigations to follow. [END] Report Contains Related Report Number(s) Reporting OfHoerllD Reporting OfBoernD Unit Date PtCas309 CATON, KELLEY 309 CATON, KELLEY AC 10/9/2012 3:01:33 PM e G(1fAPpicab1a) D.Nwnber Routod To Referred To Assigned To By LILLO, 1401 Stat us Clearance Type Date Cleared Number Arreated FURTIiER /R i 94 Q1 .r+ 0 page 3 of 14 goncy ORI Im ent Offense Report Agency Repor,. ,mbar IF L0160100 Other Persons Involved 12 -17085 I �j Offense Indicator Involvement Type iNo Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code OTHER BABILLI% CECILIA WILLEEN Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State Zip 330 MAGNOLIA Street ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233 - Residence phone Maiden Name NicknamelStroetname Place of Birth Business Phone FLORIDA Race Sex DOB Ago Clothing Res, Status WHITE FEMALE 08/01/1992 20 Occupation EmptoysdSchool Address SN STUDENT PLETCHER nDescrlptlon) Drivers License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and FCICINCIC 8142119927810 FL Height Weight Eye Color Hair Cator Hafr length Hair Style 507 p Complexion Build Facial Halr Teeth Speech/Voice Ethnlatty 11 Lr g o 6 L01601100 0 Inc._ent Offense Report Other Persons Involved Agency Repai, ,ember 12-17085 �iCF(Igf T Offense indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First Middle) Suffix Suspect Cade REPORTEE No ROSS, WILLIAM ERIC Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State Zip Reafdencephone 301 MAGNOLIA Street ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233- 904 - 382 4854 Malden Name Nicknama/Streetname Place of Birth Business Phone FLORIDA Race Sex Dos Age Clothing Res. Type Stat us WHITE MALE 02/02/1983 29 7fts, Year occupation Employer/School Address SSN MARION COUNTY FIRE DEPARTMENT Drivers License (State and Number) Other ID (Numberand State) cars, Marks, Tattoos {Looatlon artd Description) FCiC /NCIC R200925830420 FL Haight Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length Hair Style 508 160 BROWN BROWN SHORT STRAIGHT Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth Speecwotce Ethnlcfty NON - HISPANIC Offonse Indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) suffix Suspect Code REPORTEE Na PORTER, SHANNON Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State Xip Residence Phone 525 N 3RD Street #214 JACKSONVILLE FL 32250- 904 - 566 -5715 Malden Name NlcknsmalStreetname Place of Birth Business Phone FLORIDA Race Sex DOB Age Clothing R. Status WHITE FEMALE 10/09/1966 46 Occupation Employer /School Address Driver's License ($fate and Number) Other ID (Number and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location a P636793668690 FL Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color HelrLongth Hair Style 503 120 UNKNOWN BROWN MEDIUM WAVEY Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth SpeschlVolce Ethnlcfty UNKNOWN MEDIUM .... °-•_ -•- -- V S gency oRi r.L-01 Inck...int Offense Report Other Persons Involved Page 5 of 14 Agency Rapor. Amber 12-17085 1 11 Offenso Indicator Involvement Type Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) suffix SuspootCods REPORTEE No REDFERN, L 1434 Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State ZIP Residence Phone 850 SEMINOLE Road .] ATLANTIC BEACH FL 32233- 904 -247 -5859 Malden Name Place of Birth Nickname /Streatname Business Phone Place of Birth Business Phone Race Sex DCB Age Clothing MALE 08/20/1964 48 Res. Type Rea. Status WHITB FEMALE ffDriver's Employerischool 28 Address SSN Occupation Employor /School Address Marks, Tattoos (Location and SSN MILITARY /POLICI ATLANTIC BEACH POLICE 850 SEMINOLE RD ATLANTIC Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCIC/NCIC Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hatt Length Hair Style 505 130 BROWN BROWN MEDIUM STRAIGHT Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth SpeechNOlae Ethn[city LIGHT LIGHT NON - HISPANIC Offense Indicator Involvement Typa Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code REPOI2TEE No HUFFMAN, ANDY Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State ZIP Residence Phone 11447 HARLAN Drive JACKSONVILLE FL 32218- Malden Name Nlckname /Streetneme Place of Birth Business Phone ALABAMA 904438-9920 Sex DOB Aga Clothing Rea. Type Res, Status MALE 08/20/1964 48 ffDriver's Employerischool Address SSN e (State and Number) Other lD (Nu mber and State) cars, Marks, Tattoos (Location and Description) FCIC /NCtC 000 FL eght Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Length HarrStyie Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth SpeechNOice Ethnicity Offense Indicator Involvement Typo Juvenile Name (Last, First, Middle) Suffix Suspect Code Address (Street, Apartment Number) City State 21p Residence Phone m Maiden Name Nickname /StreoMae place of Birth Business Phone Res. Type I Rea. Status Occupation Employor /School Address SSN Driver's License (State and Number) Other ID (Number and State) ca7zFiF! tion) FC(CiNCIC Height Weight Eye Color Hair Color Hair Style Complexion Build Facial Hair Teeth Ethnicity i ( oca.4 ec- 0 k) -� �d'j .` n 3 3c) me, Ka� On October 4th, 2012,1(Sgt, L. Jevie #1407) initiated a follow -up investigation into the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavit received from Vanessa Chamberlin in reference to an incident that occurred in August 2011 in Howell Park. Ms. Chamberlin stated in her affidavit that her wheaten terrier, "Kingston" approached pit -bulls and was immediately and viciously attacked. Ms. Chamberlin further stated, the pit -bulls were being walked by their owner (older lady with white hair — Suzanne LeViseur), when they broke away from the owner, who clearly had no control over them. Ms. Chamberlin stated "Kingston" was bitten by the pit bulls multiple times and suffered severe lacerations, which required sutures and underwent surgery at her Veterinarian's (Pet Doctors of America; 1103 aid Street South, Jacksonville Beach, Fl 32250) office and has permanent scarring as a result of the attack. Ms. Chamberlin also submitted three (3) photos of Kingston's wounds. At approximately 8:20 p.m., I made contact with Ms. Chamberlin at 850 Seminole Rd, after I asked her if she was willingly to talk with me. I advised Ms. Chamberlin that I received her Animal Control Affidavit and had a few questions that needed clarification and she agreed to speak with me. Ms. Chamberlin was unable to provide me with an exact date or time of the attack, however; she said would call her veterinarian's office and provide me with the exact date of the attack in August 2011. Ms. Chamberlin said the time was between 6 — 7 pm. Ms. Chamberlin advised me that she had Kingston off leash in Howell Park on the day of the attack and was they were approaching the Pine Street entrance of Howell Park, walking from the east. Ms. Chamberlin said she saw a woman she described as being in her 60's, approximately 512" to 5'3 "with whitish/gray hair walking two pit - bulls, described by Ms. Chamberlin as one brown and tan and the other white /tan) with leashes attached to them in Howell Park on the west side of a walkway bridge near Pine Street, Ms. Chamberlin stated she was on the east side of the walkway bridge when Kingston crossed over the bridge and approached the two pit -bulls still on their leashes under control of the woman. Ms. Chamberlin said as Kingston reached the two pit - bulls, they immediately and viciously attacked Kingston. Ms. Chamberlin said during the attack the two pit -bulls both came out of their collars, out of the control of the woman and continued to attack Kingston. Ms. Chamberlin said the pit -bulls were biting Kingston and she thought they would kill him. Ms. Chamberlin crossed over the bridge and when she saw an opportunity she reached down and grabbed Kingston and turned her backs to the pit -bulls and started to walk towards the north to get distance from the pit- hulls. Ms. Chamberlin said the woman asked if her dog was ok she said she told her to just go. Ms Chamberlin said she was very shaken by the incident not thinking that any dogs would attack another dog in that manner. Ms. Chamberlin said she did see where the woman and the pit -bulls went as her concern was to get Kingston to safety. Ms. Chamberlin said Kingston was treated at her veterinarian's office and the cost of treatment was approximately $900.00. Ms. Chamberlin said she lived at 160 Magnolia Street, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 at the time of the incident. Ms. Chamberlin said when she described the woman walking the dogs to Lindsey, Lindsey said it was Suzanne LeViseur, however, Lindsey was not with Ms. Chamberlin at the time of the attack. 0 POLICE DEPARTMENT 854 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX (904) 247 -5899 htto: /h"NNv.coab.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Vanessa Chamberlin 1 live at 901 Ocean Blvd 998 Atlantic Beach FL 32233 Address City State and my telephone number is (904) 993-9197 Name/Description of Animal: 2 Pitt Bulls — one tan Uack) and one wbite/tan (Lola) Name /Address of Owner: 330 Magnolia Street Time and Date of Incident. August 2011(co hrm exact date and time with Veterinarian's Office) Describe the incident: he was immediately and viciously attacked At the time the i)itt bulls were being walked by their owner older lady with white hair - Suzanne LeViseurl, when they broke away from the owner, who clearly had no control over them. Kingston was bitten by the nit Veterinarian is Pet Doctors of America located at 1103 3rd Street South. Jacksonville Continuation of Statement Lf Page _2. of 2 pages Beach FL .32250 and I authorize the City to obtain the records, as needed The sure included his body being shaved and tubes being i merted to drain an infection that had occurred due to his bite wounds. He wore - a cane around his head and took over a month to recover from the severe injuries. That .day was horrify'n as I t3gy believed my beloved net was being killed. I am so thankful that the ye. terinarian was able to save his life. His veterinarian chid say he was very lucky to be alive! I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. STATE OF FLORIDA Notary Seal: this . Signature of Person Making Statement Parent or `T , day of _U( IV �X 20J_ by (N e. of person making statement) Notary Print, Type; or Stamp Name Personally Known ' �' OR Produced ID. If Produced ID, type & number 4 If S -Y b r � � Q�CEf 3 7 Cf 4 F f Y �y r y'f AS L� c Page 8 of 12 aoyORI lnc►, _at Offense Report AgeneyReport, .nber L0160100 Additional Narratives 12 -17086 M18%. SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVIT (AUG 21, 2012)�.r ACO K. Caton #309 'mmT ^m 10/3/2012 .- On-- September 21stry2012, I (ACO K. Caton #309) received a signed City of Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint Affidavit from Gretchen Deters -Smith in reference to an incident that occurred on August 21, 2012, at 346 Magnolia Street. According to Ms. Deters - Smith's affidavit two dogs from 330 Magnolia Street, a black pit bull and a red pit bull, were off -leash and in her driveway at 346 Magnolia Street, Ms. Deters - Smith's friend, Kathy Mills, left at approximately 12:00 p.m, The black dog stood between Ms. Mills and her car and "barked at her in a menacing way." Ms. Deters -Smith asked the dog owner, Willie Babillis, to remove her dogs. Ms. Smith stated that Ms. Babillis could not grab the dogs because they did not have collars, and the dogs did not respond to her commands. Ms. Deters - Smith said that Ms. Babillis finally chased the dogs away. Ms. Deters- Smith's affidavit also stated that she did not report the incident because she thought she "would handle it neighbor to neighbor." On September 24th, 2012, 1 initiated a follow -up investigation into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Ms. Deters - Smith. I advised Ms. Deters -Smith that I had a few clarifying questions regarding her affidavit and she agreed to speak with me. I asked her what she meant by "menacing." She stated that while barking, the dog was not more than 6 inches from her friend, blocking the entrance to the car and did not back up. Ms. Deters -Smith told me that she changed her mind about reporting the incident after receiving a Ietter from Lindsay Cole. Based on this affidavit, Animal Control Citation #4029 was issued to Cecilia Babillis on September 26, 2012 for Running -at- Large. This affidavit was revisited during a Dangerous Dog investigation. I initiated another follow -up investigation on October 2nd, 2012 into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Ms. Deters - Smith. I advised Ms. Deters -Smith that a Running -at -Large citation was issued to Ms. Babillis based on her affidavit. However, now we were looking at the affidavit for a dangerous dog investigation and I had a few more clarifying questions. She agreed to speak with me. Ms. Deters -Smith said she was inside her house and did not see the initial encounter between Ms. Mills and the dog. Ms. Deters -Smith said she heard barking and went outside to see what the commotion was about. She saw the black pit bull standing in her driveway between Ms. Milts and the driver's side of Ms. MiIl's car. She said that there were two other dogs running back and forth between her yard and 354 Magnolia Street, the house to the north of hers. I asked Ms. Deters -Smith to clarify this, because her affidavit says that the there were only two dogs. She said she definitely remembers three dogs: the black dog in her yard, the brown dog "Jack" and the brown & white dog. Ms. Deters -Smith said she knew the owner Willie and the dogs from the 330 Magnolia Street. She knew the brown dog was named "Jack" but didn't know the names of the other two. I asked her if she or Ms. Mills did anything to make the dogs back asked her if she or Ms. Mills tried to retreat to the house. She said Ms. Deters -Smith said she yelled at Ms. Babillis to "Get your dogsl stated that Ms. Babillis was at the end of the driveway calling her Babillis finally walked up and grabbed the black dog and carried it dogs followed Ms. Babllis to the address, away from the car. She said no. I no, Ms. Mills "stood her ground." Get your dogs!" Ms. Deters -Smith logs but they didn't listen. Ms. to 330 Magnolia Street. The other f lncl.,dnt Offense Report Additional Narratives TIOe: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVIT (AUG 21, 2012) Agency Ropo a .mbar 12-17086 Page 9 012 I asked Ms. Deters -Smith for Ms. Mill's contact information, Ms. Deters -Smith said she did not want to get her friend involved. I explained that since Ms. Mills was the one actually confronted by the dog, her statement would be very helpful and I was especially interested in the dog's behavior at the initial encounter. Ms. Deters -Smith said that if I faxed her affidavit form she would pass it on to her friend, I attempted to fax an affidavit form to (904) 2424105 four times between 5 p.m. and 6 p.m. on October 2nd, 2012. Each time the fax machine returned a "no answer" error, At approximately 6:20 p.m., I left a message on Ms. Deters - Smith's home phone explaining the problem and asked her to call me back and verify the number. I was able to make contact with Ms. Deters -Smith at approximately 8:25 a.m. on October 3rd, 2012. She stated that her fax machine did not turn on automatically, but she would manually turn it on if I could resend the fax immediately, I did, and the fax went through. & (-t � o -� - gencyoRI IncL.tt Offense Report Agency Report. Aber L0160100 Additional Narratives 1247086 Title: SUPPLEMENT AFFIDAVIT f(SEPT 6, 2012) ACO K. Caton #309 10/02/2012 On September 26th, 2012, 1, ACO Kelley Caton, received a signed City of Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint Affidavit from William Ross in reference to an incident that occurred on September 6th, 2012 at approximately 2:00 p.m., at 301 Magnolia St. According to Mr. Ross' affidavit he was driving home from the beach and turned south on Magnolia Street from Palm Avenue. Mr. Ross stated that he drove past 330 Magnolia St. he observed 3 unleashed dogs that were being walked by his owner. When he arrived home and parked in his driveway. He removed one of his surfboards from his vehicle and turned around and saw one of the three dogs lunging at him. The other two dogs were in his front yard barking aggressively and also lunging at him. Mr. Ross stated that he swung his surfboard at the dogs and stated, "the only thing that kept these dogs from biting was swinging my surfboard to keep them away." After approximately 2 -3 minutes the.dogs retreated to their property. He stated that he will not walk his dogs down Magnolia Street from a past incident of one dog attempting to attack his dog as he walked down the street. Mr, Ross stated, "...combined with the constant aggressive barking and these 2 incidents I fear for my fiance, mine and our dog's safety." On October 1st, 2012, I initiated a follow -up investigation into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Mr. Ross, Mr. Ross did not leave a phone number on his affidavit for me to contact him. I checked the white pages and his number was not listed. I followed up with the Atlantic Beach Water Department and obtained his phone number (904- 382 - 0854). At approximately 5:06 p.m., I attempted to contact Mr. Ross via phone and a female answered the phone and hung up, after I identified myself as Officer Caton with the Atlantic Beach Animal Control. I immediately called the number back and the phone went straight to voicemail (which identified the number as belonging to Mr. Ross). I left a message for Mr. Ross to return my call. At approximately 5:40 p.m., I attempted to contact Mr. Ross at his residence (301 Magnolia Street), but no one answered. I left an orange door hanger on his door requesting he contact me in reference to his affidavit. On October 2nd, 2012, at approximately 9:00 a.m., I made contact with Mr. Ross via phone in reference to the Animal Control Complaint Affidavit he submitted on September 26th, 2012. I advised Mr. Ross that I had a few clarifying questions regarding his affidavit and he agreed to speak with me, Mr. Ross stated that he did not intend on reporting the incident initially and changed his mind when he received a letter from his neighbor (Lindsay Cole). He then decided to report the incident. During our conversation Mr. Ross provided additional details in reference to his affidavit. Mr. Ross stated he drove south on Magnolia Street from Palm Avenue. He passed 330 Magnolia Street and saw three unleashed pit bulls. He could not remember what they looked like, but when asked to describe the pit bulls he said one was spotted, and one may have been brown. He advised that they looked liked they could have been pit bull mixes. Mr. Ross stated as he passed the dogs they were located mid -block in the grass area (east side of the street) across from houses. They were being walked without leashes by a white female with dark hair in her mid twenties. Mr. Ross did not notice if she had leashes in her hand. He assumed she was the owner and she waived as he drove by. Mr. Ross pulled into his driveway at 301 Magnolia Street. He was removing his surfboard from the car when one of the dogs lunged at him from approximately 1 foot away. He could not remember or describe which one of the dogs lunged at him. The other two dogs were in his yard approximately 3 ft to 10 ft. away from him, barking aggressively which he defined as "growling, deep, loud barking, and showing teeth." Mr. Ross feels that he would have been bitten if he had not had his surfboard. He stated that he had to swing his surfboard back and forth to keep the dogs at bay. Mr. Ross stated that Q Z gency ORt L0160100 inciaant Offense Report Additional Narratives T10e4 SUPPLEMENT AFFIDAVIT (SEPT 61 2012) Agency Report. .nber 12 -19086 0 when the dogs were in his yard the owner was standing in the street snapping, clapping, and calling the dogs' names trying to get them to return. She called the dogs approximately five times before they returned. Mr. Ross could not recall what the dogs' names were. Mr. Ross originally stated in his affidavit that this incident took approximately 2 -3 minutes. I asked him if this incident took 2 -3 minutes and he stated that it probably Iasted approximately 15 seconds. He observed the dogs and the owner walk to 330 Magnolia and turn into the property. Nobody else witnessed the incident. Mr. Ross also mentioned a past incident in his affidavit. I asked him to describe it and he stated that approximately 3 months ago he walked his dog to Howell Park from his residence. When he passed 330 Magnolia Street and a dog lunged and barked at his dog. Mr. Ross stated the dog (from 330 Magnolia Street) was leashed at the time. I asked him which dog and he said it might have been the brown dog, but he was not positive. I asked him if he had reported the incident and he said no. 9 >aa tlV' Z gency ORI L0160100 inair.ant Offense Report Additional Narratives Agency Roper, tuber 12 -17086 f "i5�f h Page 12 of Tote: SUPPLEMENT - JEVIC 10/10/212 Sgt L. Jevic #1407 On this date, at approx. 8:00 pm, I made contact with Suzanne Leviseur at 330 Magnolia St and issued dangerous dog classification notices to her and explained they were for her and her daughter, Cecilia "Willi" Babillis for the three dogs that reside with them, Jack, Lola and jewel. I also gave Ms Leviseur a copy of the Atlantic Beach Dangerous Dog Ordinance. I explained the requirements to control her dogs and offered to impound the dogs at the owners expense pending any requests for hearings/ hearings, however, did not get any response. I explained that now that the dogs were being classified as dangerous, should they get out, run at large etc, the city would move to impound the dogs. I also informed her that should the dogs get loose and bite someone they could be charged criminally. I also issued her the nuisance abatement notice and explained to her that the nuisance notice has deadlines should she want to request a hearing, Ms. Leviseur said the dogs belonged to her daughter and believed this was ongoing because her daughter and the neighbor that is the lawyer have had wards and this is a result of that conflict. I explained to her that we have received numerous affidavits stating the dogs were off leash and acting aggressive. She stated her daughter was at school and was not at home. She was courteous and fully cooperative. I was able to make contact around 9:50 pm with Cecilia "Willi" Babillis at 330 Magnolia St. and asked her if she spoke with her mother in reference to my earlier delivery of the dangerous dog classification notices for Jack, Lola and Jewel. She said she had briefly. I explained the seriousness of the dangerous dog classifications to her. l explained to her if the dogs are found to be loose after we have notified her the city would move to impound them pending final classification. I explained the requirements and offered to impound the dogs at the owners expense pending any requests for hearings /hearings, however, she stated they were staying with her. I explained that now that the dogs were being classified as dangerous, should they get out, run at large etc, the city would move to impound the dogs. I also informed her that should the dogs get loose and bite someone they could be charged criminally. She was cooperative and courteous. 5 g ORI L001616 01100 0 1111e: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDA Sgt. L. jevic #1407 F. Spratt #311 Int,...ant Offense Report Aa Additional Narratives la (OCT 71 2012)' On October 10, 2012, I, ACO Fonda Spratt, received a signed City O: of Complaint Affidavit from Bruce Robbins in reference to an incident inar occurred on October 7, 2012 at approximately 7:40 p.m. According to Robbins he was at 330 Magnolia St taking his yard trash across the street approximately 50 feet from his driveway, when he observed a canine 150 feet (3 home lots) north of him, Robbins stated that the canine came at him growling at a full run. Robbins stated the dog ran past him as he was waving shears to keep the dog away from him. Robbins stated the dog made a second full speed pass again growling. Robbins stated the owner (Willie) was in the street yelling at the dog, Lola, to stop. Robbins stated the owner got the dog under control at that time. I, Sgt. L. jevic made contact with Bruce Robbins on October 10, 2012 at approx 8:45 pm via telephone to conduct a follow up to the affidavit described above. According to Robbins, he was taking trash to the trash area across the street from his home located at 310 Magnolia St. on Oct 7, 2012 at approx 7 :40 pm. Robbins said he was approx. 50 feet from his driveway when looked up and saw a pit bull in the road off leash approximately 150 feet north of him. Robbins said the pit bull carne at him, running full speed, growling and showing its teeth. Robbins said he dropped everything in his hands except the shears and starting waving them towards the dog to keep the dog from attacking him. Robbins said the dog came within a 36 inches of him as the dog ran past him, Robbins said he thought the dog would attack him if he did not have the shears. Robbins stated the dog ran made 3 additional passes towards him, as the dog turned around from the initial pass, it came running towards him from the south, turned around and came at him again from the north, turned around once again and charged him from the south. Robbins said the dog continued to growl as he was waving the shears during all of the dog's passes, Robbins stated the owner, who identified as "Willie" (younger female) who lives at 330 Magnolia St. was standing across from her home on the east side of the street when the dog was coming at him. Robbins said while the dog was charging at him, "Willie" was yelling at the dog to stop. Robbins said "Willie" was calling the dog, "Lola ". Robbins said "Willie" got the dog under control after the 4th pass by him. Robbins said "Willie" said to him, "Sorry Mr. Bruce ". P_ R gency OR! Lo160100 Titte: SUPPLEMENT - JEVIC 10/10/212 Sgt L. Jevic #1407 Inc.,.4nt Offense Report Additional Narratives Agenoy RepM. ,tuber 12-17085 cohi 8 of On this date, at approx. 8:00 pm, I made contact with Suzanne Leviseur at 330 Magnolia St and issued dangerous dog classification notices to her and explained they were for her and her daughter, Cecilia "Willi" Babillis for the three dogs that reside with them; Jack, Lola and Jewel. I also gave Ms Leviseur a copy of the Atlantic Beach Dangerous Dog Ordinance. I explained the requirements to control her dogs and offered to impound the dogs at the owners expense pending any requests for hearings/ hearings, however, did not get any response. I explained that now that the dogs were being classified as dangerous, should they get out, run at large etc, the city would move to impound the dogs. I also informed her that should the dogs get loose and bite someone they could be charged criminally. I also issued her the nuisance abatement notice and explained to her that the nuisance notice has deadlines should she want to request a hearing. Ms. Leviseur said the dogs belonged to her daughter and believed this was ongoing because her daughter and the neighbor that is the lawyer have had words and this is a result of that conflict. 1 explained to her that we have received numerous affidavits stating the dogs were off leash and acting aggressive. She stated her daughter was at school and was not at home. She was courteous and fully cooperative. I was able to make contact around 9 :50 pm with Cecilia "Willi" Babillis at 330 Magnolia St. and asked her if she spoke with her mother in reference to my earlier delivery of the dangerous dog classification notices for Jack, Lola and Jewel. She said she had briefly. I explained the seriousness of the dangerous dog classifications to her. I explained to her if the dogs are found to be loose after we have notified her the city would move to impound them pending final classification. I explained the requirements and offered to impound the dogs at the owners expense pending any requests for hearings/ hearings, however, she stated they were staying with her. I explained that now that the dogs were being classified as dangerous, should they get out, run at large etc, the city would move to impound the dogs. I also informed her that should the dogs get loose and bite someone they could be charged criminally. She was cooperative and courteous. ��►G�,k c(ate On September 11th, 2012, at approximately 1:15 p.m. I, ACO Kelley Caton, was dispatched to 850 Seminole Rd. (Atlantic Beach Police Station) in reference to an animal complaint. Upon arrival, I met with the complainant Shannon Porter who had a signed City of Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint in reference to an incident that occurred on September 10th, 2012. According to the affidavit completed by Ms. Porter, at approximately 10:45 a.m. she witnessed two pit bulls in the street which were off of their leashes. She described the pit bulls as one brown and one was white with brown spots. She observed these dogs when she visiting her friend, Lindsay Cole at 338 Magnolia on September 10th, 2012. Ms. Porter stated that the white and brown pit bull charged her car as she pulled into Ms. Cole's yard. Ms. Porter was afraid and said she would not get out of the car until the owner took the dogs away. Based on this affidavit, Animal Control Citation #4002 was issued to Cecilia Babillis on September 17, 2012 for Running -at- Large. This affidavit was revisited during a Dangerous Dog investigation. I initiated another follow -up investigation on October 3rd, 2012 into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Ms. Porter. I advised Ms. Porter that a Running -at -Large citation was issued to Ms. Babillis based on her affidavit. However, now we were looking at the affidavit for a dangerous dog investigation and I had a few more clarifying questions. She agreed to speak with me. Ms. Porter stated that she was driving south on Magnolia Street when she saw two dogs off leash about a house north of Ms. Cole's. The dogs were walking south, in the middle of the street behind a young, white female (Ms. Babillis) who she knows from past experience to be the dogs' owner. Ms. Porter said that she turned into the driveway of 338 Magnolia Street when the brown and white pit bull turned around and charged her car. The dog stood in the middle of the yard barking and staring at Ms. Porter. She did not see the owner or the other dog. Ms. Porter thinks that Ms. Babillis must have summoned the dog because it suddenly turned around and ran next door to 330 Magnolia Street. Ms. Porter stated that she sat in her car "for a few minutes" afterwards. I asked her to elaborate on the time frame. She said she was shaken up sat "long enough" to give Ms. Babillis time to put the dogs in the house. Ms. Porter was picking something up from Ms. Cole and was only at the residence for a few minutes. She did not see the dogs or Ms. Babillis when she left. Ms. Cole did not see the incident. I asked Ms. Porter if she knew where the dogs lived or who the belonged to. She said yes, she has visited Ms. Cole many times and has seen both dogs and owner in the past. She has gone for walks in the neighborhood with Ms, Cole and the dogs have barked at them from the balcony. On Page L4 of 14 gencyORI lnc,_entOffense.Report AgencyRepoi. amber L0160100 Additional Narratives 12 -17085 Title: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDA ACO F. Spratt #311 SGT L. Jevic #1407 On October 10, 2012 I, ACO Fonda Spratt, received a signed City Of Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavit from Andy Huffman in reference to an incident that occurred on October 9, 2012 at approximately 11:20 a.m. According to the affidavit written by Andy Huffman, he stated he was standing near the garage at 338 Magnolia Street reading a manual regarding the lights that he was hired to install. He noticed a young lady walking south with two pit -bulls (one black and one white /tan). As the pit -bulls were north of the driveway, the black pit -bulls were barking at him and tying to break free from the owner and lunged toward him, but the owner yanked the canine back. He then heard more barking and the white /tan pit -bull came out of nowhere and was charging him at a rapid speed, growling, bearing its teeth and snapping at him. He was immediately fearful of being attacked and mauled, so he kicked the pit bull. The pit bull retreated briefly and then circled back and charged at him a second time coming in the garage, again growling and snapping at him, The owner was yelling the whole time "she won't bite." The owner was also trying to call the pit buII, but it was ignoring her commands. He stated that the pit bull eventually left and the owner put both dogs in the house, then the owner came back to ask if the dog had bit him. Mr. Huffman stated that both dogs appeared to be extremely aggressive, for no reason, and completely out of control. On October 11, 2012, Sgt. Jevic contacted Mr. Huffman via telephone to conduct a follow up investigation into the Animal Control Affidavit received from Mr. Huffman, Mr. Huffman provided additional information to his affidavit. Mr. Huffman stated he was standing in front of the garage at 338 Magnolia Street reading a manual regarding the lights that he was hired to install at approximately 11:20 A.M. He saw a young woman about 40 feet away from him walking south in the road just north of 338 Magnolia with two pit bulls on a leash (one black and one white /tan). As the pit bulls were just north of the driveway, the tan /white canine slipped out of its collar and the black pit-bull was barking at him and trying to break loose and lunged toward him, but the owner yanked the black pit - bull back. However, the white/ tan canine got loose and started to charge him at a rapid speed growling, bearing its teeth and snapping at him. Mr. Huffman stated that he was immediately fearful of being attacked and mauled, so he kicked the white /tan pit -bull. The white /tan pit -bull then retreated briefly and circled back and charged him a second time near the garage, again growling and snapping at him but ran past him. Huffman said the owner was yelling the whole time "she won't bite ". The owner was also trying to call the pit -bull, but it was ignoring her commands. The pit -bull eventually went back to the owner and she put both dogs into the house directly next to and south of 338 Magnolia St. Mr. Huffman said after the owner put the pit -bulls were put inside their house, the owner came over and asked Mr. Huffman if the dog had bit him. He said he was not bit. 338 Magnolia Street, Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 lindsMeolel9gmail.com September 28, 2012 Dear Friends and Neighbors; • Al pu4) /:)3 -A000 k%.Ull) I am writing to advise the neighborhood of a situation involving potentially dangerous dogs on Magnolia Sheet. There are three pit bull mixed breeds' living at 330 Magnolia Street, one tan, one tan and white and one black, which are unpredictable and aggressive. Further exacerbating the problem, the ovvnlers frequently allow the pit bulls to roam the streets without a leash. If you have ever walked down Magnolia Street towards Howell Park, you likely know the pit bulls to which I am referring. Many of the neighbors on Magnolia Street have tried discussing the situation with the pit bulls owner(s) in the hopes of reaching an amicable resolution, but have been met with hostility and disrespect. It has come to the point that I and my neighbors are afraid for our safety, the safety of our pets, and all of you your loved ones and your pets, e have now learned tha I have also been informed by many of you that you too have been scared and disrupted by these pit bulls. In fact, I know that some of you no longer feel comfortable walking down Magnolia Street. This is simply no way to have to live in our own neighborhood. , The City is aware of this serious problem and is working on a solution. However, the City and Police need to blow about all incidents that have occurred with regard to these dogs. We, MUST have more people come forward and share their experiences regarding these pit bulls. If you have ever been fearful of, confronted by, intimidated by, or disrupted by these pit bulls, please email or write to the following as soon as possible: Mayor and City Commission electedofficials�,coab.us City Manager jhanson60oab.us City Attorney alan(a)AJensenLaw.com 1 We are all dog lovers on Magnolia Street and have no animosity towards any particular breed of dog. The issue is that these particular dogs are aggressive and not restrained by their owners, despite numerous requests by neighbors, fines by animal control and warnings from the police. -1- ATTACHMENT A Chief of Police mclassq(i ,coab.us City of Atlantic Beach 800 Seminole Road Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Also, you can describe any incident that has taken place in the enclosed "Animal Complaint Affidavit" and return it to the police department. If you experience any incident in the future, please immediately contact the Atlantic Beach Police Department at (904) 249 - 5859. I know some of you have already received this letter, but I am updating it and expanding the number of people who receive it. I know that many incidents with these pit bulls have gone unreported. We cannot leave these types of occurrences unreported. It is unlawful for a dog to approach a person in an aggressive manner. This has been a frequent occurrence on Magnolia Street and must be reported. Also, please report any occurrence that you have witnessed in the past. of such an incident. Please help me in protecting the safety and peacefulness of our wonderful neighborhood. Feel free to contact me anytime at the number or email address above. If you email me, I will gladly keep you apprised of the status of the issue. Thank you for your time and assistance in this regard. Enclosure cc: Elected Officials Michael Classey, Chief of Police Jim Hanson, City Managex Alan Jensen, City Attorney - 2 - Very truly yours, N ATTACHMENT B On October 3rd, 2012, I (Sgt. JX Tusing #1408) checked my work voicemail box and had a message from Mr. Brogden. Mr. Brogden advised that he submitted two Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavits for review. One of these affidavits pertains to this incident and the other pertains to an incident with the same pit -bull that occurred on May 20th, 2012. I spoke to Animal Control Officer (ACO) Fonda Spratt who advised that she had the two affidavits from Mr. Brogden. At approximately 12:00 p.m., I initiated a follow -up investigation into the affidavit in reference to the incident that occurred on May 26th, 2012 at approximately 2:00 p.m., at 310 Magnolia Street. Mr. Brogden stated in his affidavit that he was working at 310 Magnolia Street and observed a brown pit -bull run up to a lady walking her dog. Mr. Brogden stated that the pit bull circled both of them and was growling and, "looked as if it would attack at any moment." Mr. Brogden stated he grabbed his machete "just in case" and the owner came and got the dog. Mr. Brogden stated spoke to the victim afterwards and was shaken up and feared for her and her dog's safety. At approximately 1:30 p.m., I made contact with Mr. Brogden via phone. I advised Mr. Brogden that I had a few clarifying questions in reference to the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint he filed about the incident that occurred on May 26th, 2012 at 310 Magnolia Street: I asked ?& Brogden if this was the second incident he witnessed with this brown pit bull and he stated it was and that the two incidents were approximately one week apart. I asked him if it was the same dog in both incidents and he stated it was. He stated that during this incident he observed a white female in her late 40's to early 50's walking a very large dog approximately the size of a Great Dane on a leash. Mr. Brogden stated he was in the driveway of Bruce Robbins when he observed the incident occur in the roadway. He stated that the brown pit bull "charged" the large dog and approached it from the side (dog's shoulder area). He heard the pit bull growling and sniffing the large dog. He stated that he observed the pit bulls head to be below his shoulders (crouching) as it growled at the dog. He grabbed his machete and stated that he would defend the other dog or lady against the pit bull if he had to. I asked Mr. Brogden how close was the pit bull away from the dog and he stated it was right next to the dog. He stated that the incident took approximately 2 minutes and observed the dog owner's daughter come into the street and retrieve the dog. Mr. Brogden stated he spoke to the woman who appeared to visibly shaken and nervous about the incident. I asked Mr. Brogden if he knew the owner of the dog and he stated he did not and described her as a white female in her late teens to early twenties. I asked Mr. Brogden if he knew the lady walking the dog and he stated that he has been doing landscaping for Mr. Robbins for approximately 6 years and has never seen the lady or the dog before this incident and has not seen them since. I ATFACHMENT C Incident Offense Report [�12-17YO134 genc Report Number gency ORl ' 00160100 Additional Narratives Title: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVITS (MAY 20 & 26) J. TUSING #1408 On October 2nd, 2012, 1 (Sgt. J.N. Tusing #1408) initiated afollow -up investigation into the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavit received from Mr. Robbins in reference to an incident that occurred on eet. Mx. Robbins stated in his affidavit May 20th, 2012, at approximately 11:00 a.m. at 310 Magnolia Str that his landscaper Mr. Brogden called him, and stated that a brown pit -bull charged him when he was working outside at 310 Magnolia Street. The landscaper advised that the canine was showing signs of aggression by growling and snarling. The landscaper then. picked up a shovel to ward off the canine from attacking him. The owner Ms. Babillis arrived and retrieved her canine. At approximately 3:00 p.m., I made contact with Mr. Robbins via phone. I advised Mr. Robbins that I received his Animal Control Affidavit and had a few questions that needed clarification and he agreed to speak with me. Mr. Robbins advised that his landscaper who he identified as Spencer Brogden reported to him an incident involving the brown pit -bull from 330 Magnolia Street. Mr. Robbins stated that Mr. Brogden owns Spencer's Creations and his contact number is 327 -6842. Mr. Robbins stated that Mr. Brogden was in the process of completing an affidavit in relation to this incident. 1 asked Mr. Robbins if he observed the - incident with Mr. Brogden and stated that he did not. At approximately 3:30 p.m., I attempted to contact Mr. Brogden via phone but received no answer. I left a message for Mr. Brogden to contact me. On October 3rd, 2012, 1 checked my work voicemail box and had a message from Mr. Bro den. Mr. Brogden advised that he submitted two affidavits for review. One of these affidavits pertains to this incident and the other pertains to an incident with the same pit -bull that occurred onbJ11 v 26th,- 2012. 1 spoke to Animal Control Officer (ACO) Fonda Spratt who advised that she had the two affidavits from Mr. Brogden. At approximately 12:00 p.m., I initiated a follow -up investigation into the affidavit in reference to the incident that occurred on Ma� Y 2012 at approximately 11:00 a.m., at 310 Magnolia Street. According to Mr. Brogden s affidavit he working at 310 Magnolia Street and was taking trash to put across the street when he observed a brown pit bull come "charging down the street out of 330 Magnolia Street. The dog then ran into the yard of 310 Magnolia Street and chased the owner's cat over the back fence. The dog then charged me. The dog approached Mr. Brogden with a "lowered head all the while growling and barking." He had his shovel in his hand and thought that he may have to defend himself. At this time the owner's daughter retrieved the dog and told Mr. Brogden that the dog "wouldn't bite." At approximately 1:30 p.m., I made contact with Mr. Brogden via phone. I advised Mr. Brogden that I had a few clarifying questions in reference to the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Complaint he filed about the incident that occurred on May 20th, 2012 at 310 Magnolia Street. Mr. Brogden agreed to speak with me about the incident. Mr. Brogden was asked where he was standing when he observed the dog which he described as a brown pit bull, and lie stated he was standing on the east side of the street near the wooded area. He stated that the dog came "charging" down the street. I asked him to describe what he meant by "charging" and lie stated that the dog was "running with a purpose." He described the dog as taking a "full sprint" as he observed it run from the driveway of 330 Mannolia Street, and chased Bruce Robbins cat over the fence. He stated once the cat was gone, the dog looked at him and charged at him. I asked Mr. Brogden how close the dog came to him and he advised approximately 2 feet. He stated that he had his shovel in his hand and stated that he could have hit the dog and would have if it got any closer to him. He described the dog as barking, crouching down, growling, and showing his "canine" teeth (snarl). He stated that the incident lasted approximately 45 seconds to a minute and heard the owner yelling for the dog. He stated that the owner had to come and grab the dog by the collar to get it to leave him alone. Mr. Brogden stated r 1,0ncy ORl 160100 incident Offense Report Additional Narratives i ATTACHMENT C Agency Report Number 12 -17084 Title: SUPPLEMENT - AFFIDAVITS (MAY 20 & 26 that the owner who he described as a white female in her late teens to early twenties told him, "he won't bite." Mr. Brogden stated that he felt that the behavior of the dog in this incident was overly aggressive. October 10, 2012 Suzanne Leviseur and Cecilia Babillis 330 Magnolia Street Atlantic Beach, PL 32233 Re: Dangerous Dog Declaration - Jewel Dear Ms. Leviseur and Ms. Babillis: CK-01bf-( 12 CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX: (904) 247 -5867 �>CttiB i 1 I� www.coab.us The purpose of this letter is to advise you that per city code section 4 -10, the Atlantic Beach Police Department, which is the animal control authority for Atlantic Beach, has made an initial determination that there is sufficient cause under the city code to classify your dog, Jewel, as dangerous. She has, on numerous occasions, when unprovoked, chased or approached a person in a menacing fashion or apparent attitude of attack. The following is a list of incidents reported to Animal Control by residents and/or other witnesses; however additional complaints continue to be filed. • July 26, 2012 -- A visitor at a Magnolia Street address pulled into the driveway when the black dog aggressively approached and circled the vehicle. As the person exited the vehicle, the dog charged at the person while baring its teeth. • August 21, 2012 — A visitor at a Magnolia Street address was walking to her vehicle in the driveway when the black dog blocked her path. The dog was not more than 6 inches away and was barking. Ms. Babillis was calling the- dogs, all three were loose at the time, but they did not listen. Babillis finally came up and had to physically carry Jewel away. • September 6, 2012 -- A Magnolia Street resident had just returned home when he observed 3 unleashed dogs in the area. He removed a surfboard from his vehicle and when he turned around the three dogs were right there barking aggressively, growling deep and showing teeth. One of the dogs lunged.at him and he had to swing his surfboard at it to keep it back. The victim believes that swinging the surfboard was the only thing that kept the dogs from biting him. • October 9, 2012 — A contractor was working at a residence on Magnolia Street when he saw a young lady walking two pit bulls (one black and one white /tan). The black dog was barking at him and trying to break free, lunging at him. Then the white and tan dog came out of nowhere charging him at a rapid speed, growling, bearing its teeth and snapping at the man. He was fearful of being attacked so he kicked the dog. It retreated briefly and then circled back charging him a second time again growling and snapping at him. The owner was trying to call the dog, but it ignored the commands. The contractor stated that both dogs appeared extremely aggressive for no reason and completely out of control. You will note that in some of these incidents more than one dog- (Jewel) was present. The incidents listed here are for the sole purpose of describing Jewel's behavior only. CKI-h 1 '6Cf la- These incidents were investigated by Animal Control Officers Kelley Caton and Fonda Spratt as well as Police Detective Sergeant Jon Tusing and it was determined that the aggressive dog, appears to be a black Pit Bull or Pit Bull mix named Jewel. Both of you have made statements that the dog belongs to you. As such, this written notification is addressed to both parties. ; ' After reviewing the reports and statements submitted to the Animal Control Officers, I ha\�e determined that the actions of your dog are prohibited as a violation of city code sections 4 -10 (1) (d) under the Dangerous Dog Section. Enclosed you will find a copy of the City of Atlantic Beach ordinances sections 4 -10, 4 -11 and 4"12 dealing with Dangerous Dogs to assist you in understanding what this classification entails. City Ordinance 411 (1) (a) requires that any animal that is the subject of a dangerous dog investigation shall be humanely and safely confined by the owner in a securely fenced or enclosed area pending the resolution of any hearings related to the dangerous dog classification. Failure to securely confine this animal will result in additional civil and/or criminal action(s). Under city code section 411 (1) (c), you have the opportunity to have a hearing before the City of Atlantic Beach Code Enforcement Board before a final determination is made. If you wish to have such a hearing, you are required to file a written request within seven (7) calendar days from the date of receipt of this notification. Please direct any such request to the attention of Commander Victor Gualillo. Sincerely, Michael D. Classey IV Chief of Police Enclosure IF] October 10, 2012 Suzanne Leviseur and Cecilia Babillis 330 Magnolia Street Atlantic Beach, PL 32233 Re: Dangerous Dog Declaration - Lola Dear Ms. Leviseur and Ms. Babillis: 13 C1TV OF ATLANTIC BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX: (904) 247 -5867 www.coab.us The purpose of this letter Is to advise you that per city code section 4 -10, the Atlantic Beach Police Department, which is the animal control authority for Atlantic Beach, has made an initial determination that there Is sufficient cause under the city code to classify your dog, Lola, as dangerous. She has, on numerous occasions, when unprovoked, chased or approached a person in a menacing fashion or apparent attitude of attack. She has also severely injured a domestic animal while off your property. The following is a list of incidents reported to Animal Control by several residents and other witnesses; however additional complaints continue to be filed. • August 2011 — Two of your dogs identified as Jack and Lola were being walked in Howell Park by Ms. Leviseur. The dogs broke loose and viciously attacked another dog causing several lacerations, which required sutures and surgery. The dog has permanent scarring as a result of the attack. • July 26, 2012 - there was a young girl about 5 -6 years old riding her bike down Magnolia Street accompanied by her Grandmother. Both Jack and Lola came running down the street and aggressively approached and circled the little girl. Another woman was in the area and had a stick. She stepped in between the dogs and the little girl to block them until Ms. Babillis was'able to grab the dogs. • August 10, 2012 — a contractor was working at a local resident's home when the brown and white Pit Bull ran at the man and was growling and snapping. • September 6, 2012 -- A Magnolia Street resident had just returned home when he observed 3 unleashed dogs in the area. He removed a surfboard from his vehicle and when he turned around the three dogs were right there barking aggressively, growling deep and showing teeth. One of the dogs lunged at him and he had to swing his surfboard at it to keep it back. The victim believes that swinging the surfboard was 'the only thing that kept the dogs from biting him. • September 10, 2012 —A person coming to visit a resident on Magnolia Street noticed two Pit Bulls running loose in the street as she approached her friend's driveway. The brown and white dog charged at the vehicle while in the driveway. The driver was too afraid to exit the vehicle until the owner arrived and took the dog away. • October 7, 2012 -- A Magnolia Street resident was taking the trash out when he observed Lola about 150 feet away from him, unleashed and in the roadway. The dog came charging at him at full speed. The resident was holding a set of shears in his hand and started to waive it at the dog. The resident believes that had he not done so, he would have been attacked. • October 9, 2012 — A contractor was working at a residence on Magnolia Street when he saw a young lady walking two pit bulls (one black and one white /tan). The black dog was barking at him and trying to break free, lunging at him. Then the white and tan dog came out of nowhere charging him at a rapid speed growling, bearing its teeth and snapping at the man. He was fearful of being attacked so he kicked the dog. It retreated briefly and then circled back charging him a second time, again growling and snapping at him. The owner was trying to call the dog, but it ignored the commands. The contractor stated that both dogs appeared extremely aggressive for no reason and completely out of control. You will note that in some of these incidents more than one dog (Lola) was present. The incidents listed here are for the sole purpose of describing Lola's behavior only. These incidents were investigated by Animal Control Officers Kelley Caton and Fonda Spratt as well as Police Detective Sergeant Jon Tusing and it was determined that the aggressive dog appears to be a brown and white Pit Bull or Pit Bull mix named Lola. Both of you have made statements that the dog belongs to you. As such, this written notification is addressed to both parties, After reviewing the reports and statements submitted to the Animal Control Officers, I have determined that the actions of your dog are prohibited as a violation of city code sections 4 -10 (1) (b) and (d) under the Dangerous Dog Section. Enclosed you will find a copy of the City of Atlantic Beach ordinances sections 4 -10, 4 -11 and 4.12 dealing with Dangerous Dogs to assist you in understanding what this classification entails. City Ordinance 4 -11 (1) (a) requires that any animal that is the subject of a dangerous dog investigation shall be humanely and safely confined by the owner in a securely fenced or enclosed area pending the resolution of any hearings related to the dangerous dog classification. Failure to securely confine this animal will result in additional civil and /or criminal actibn(s). Under city code section 4 -11 (1) (c), you have the opportunity to have a hearing before the City of Atlantic Beach Code Enforcement Board before a final determination is made. If you wish to have such a hearing, you are required to file a written request within seven (7) calendar days frorh the date of receipt of this notification. Please direct any such request to the attention of Commar)der Victor Gualillo. sincerely, Michael D. Classey Chief of Police Enclosure October 10, 2012 Suzanne Leviseur and Cecilia Babillis 330 Magnolia Street Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Re Dangerous Dog Declaration - Jack Dear Ms. Leviseur and Ms. Babillis: CITY OF ATLANTIC BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX: (904) 247 -5867 Lf www.coab.us The purpose of this letter is to advise you that per city code section 4 -10, the Atlantic Beach Police Department, which is the animal control authority for Atlantic Beach, has made an initial determination that there is sufficient cause under the city code to classify your dog, Jack, as dangerous. He has, on numerous occasions, when unprovoked, chased or approached a person in a menacing fashion or apparent attitude of attack. He has also severely injured a domestic animal while off your property. The following is a list of incidents reported to Animal Control by several residents and other witnesses; however additional complaints continue to be filed. ® June 10, 2011 — Magnolia Street resident was walking towards her car when she was instantaneously approached by Jack who stood in front of her with his head down, growling with teeth bared and ears up. She was terrified that she was about to be attacked. Dog owner eventually came out and took the dog away. August 2011 — Two of your dogs, identified as Jack and Lola, were being walked in Howell Park by Ms. Leviseur. The dogs broke loose and viciously attacked another dog causing several lacerations, which required sutures and surgery. The other dog has permanent scarring as a result of the attack. May 3, 2012 — While Ms. Babillis was on the beach with Jack unleashed, he ran towards a leashed dog and proceeded to attack the other dog. Jack grabbed the other dog by the back of the neck and was shaking him vigorously causing two puncture wounds. May 20, 2012 — A contractor was working at a Magnolia Street address when the brown Pit Bull came charging down the street towards him. The dog was within 2 feet of him and had its head down growling, barking and showing his teeth. The contractor believes the dog was overly aggressive. July 18, 2012 — A Magnolia Street resident was standing in his driveway when Jack came at him quickly with head down and growling with teeth bared. The dog circled him 3 times and he was, extremely fearful for his safety. ® July 26, 2012 - there was a young girl about 5 -6 years old riding her bike down Magnolia Street accompanied by her Grandmother. Both Jack and Lola came running down the street and aggressively approached and circled the little girl. Another woman was in the area and had a stick. She stepped in between the dogs and the little girl to block them until Willi was able to grab the dogs. os)—1 ►4 ® August 14, 2012 — A woman and young girl were walking down the street when the solid brown dog charged at them. The dog had its head down low to the ground acting very aggressively and squaring up to the people as it circled them. The owner finally came to retrieve the dog. ® September 6, 2012 — A Magnolia Street resident had just returned home when he observed 3 unleashed dogs in the area. He removed a surfboard from his vehicle and when he turned around the three dogs were right there barking aggressively, growling deep and showing teeth. One of the dogs lunged at him and he had to swing his surfboard at it to keep it back. Victim believes that swinging the surfboard was the only thing that kept the dogs from biting him. You will note that in some of these incidents more than one dog (Jack) was present. The incidents listed here are for the sole purpose of describing Jack's behavior only. These incidents were investigated by Animal Control Officers Kelley Caton and Fonda Spratt as well as Police Detective Sergeant Jon Tusing and it was determined that the aggressive dog appears to be a brown Pit Bull or Pit Bull mix named Jack. Both of you have made statements that the dog belongs to you. As such, this written notification is addressed to both parties. After reviewing the reports and statements submitted to the Animal Control Officers, I have determined that the actions of your dog are prohibited as a violation of city code sections 4 -10 (1) (b) and (d) under the Dangerous Dog Section. Enclosed you will find a copy of the City of Atlantic Beach ordinances sections 4 -10, 4 -11 and 4 -12 dealing with Dangerous Dogs to assist you in understanding what this classification entails. City Ordinance 4 -11 (1) (a) requires that any animal that is the subject of a dangerous dog investigation shall be humanely and safely confined by the owner in a securely fenced or enclosed area pending the resolution of any hearings related to the dangerous dog classification. Failure to securely confine this animal will result in additional civil and /or criminal action(s). Under city code section 4 -11 (1) (c), you have the opportunity to have a hearing before the City of Atlantic Beach Code Enforcement Board before a final determination is made. If you wish to have such a hearing, you are required to file a written request within seven (7) calendar days from the date of receipt of this notification. Please direct any such request to the attention of Commander Victor Gualillo. Sincerely, Cs.is Michael D. Classe Y Chief of Police Enclosure OK41-6�1 15 POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 PAX: (904) 247 -5899 btt12://ww%y.coab.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity, My name is Kelley Caton, Animal Control Officer #309. I work for the Atlantic Beach Police Department, 850 Seminole Rd, Atlantic Beach and my office telephone number is (904) 246 -5866. Name/Description of Anim ':Je l,)black female pit Name /Address of Owner: Suzanne Leviseur and Cec Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 Time /Date of Incident: multiple dates, including 7 rt't ci +'fS�9 � � /Stir! i `q,. rrr4.. •` 1 lfirl {1i5;'330'�Ivla'Ii a���'1�e�i�; �� :i t' ,iS1i 4irji� it'efi4(A":.tpSii 4� 1i�,� •. •tst �.. .� '(e• {iYt'., fd W ftttt8:pttltiirt�; :`d_.,�5`�.:.�c;:, :.:.'.f L4'W"yi Describe the incident: Several complaints were made regarding the actions of Jewel, the dog mentioned above, I have received multiple affidavits from neighbors, including Ronelle Davis at 354 Magnolia St; Gretchen Deter -Smith at 346 Magnolia St; and William Ross of 301 Magnolia St, All complainants state that the dog, Jewel, had charged and growled at them in an aggressive and threatening manner while off the property of its owner, I conducted an investigation into these claims and believe that these actions meet the definition of a dangerous dog in City ordinance 4- 10(1)(d), I recommend that the City move forward with dangerous dog proceedings at this time, as directed by City ordinance 4 -11. H rt't ci +'fS�9 � � /Stir! i `q,. rrr4.. •` 1 lfirl {1i5;'330'�Ivla'Ii a���'1�e�i�; �� :i t' ,iS1i 4irji� it'efi4(A":.tpSii 4� 1i�,� •. •tst �.. .� '(e• {iYt'., fd W ftttt8:pttltiirt�; :`d_.,�5`�.:.�c;:, :.:.'.f L4'W"yi Describe the incident: Several complaints were made regarding the actions of Jewel, the dog mentioned above, I have received multiple affidavits from neighbors, including Ronelle Davis at 354 Magnolia St; Gretchen Deter -Smith at 346 Magnolia St; and William Ross of 301 Magnolia St, All complainants state that the dog, Jewel, had charged and growled at them in an aggressive and threatening manner while off the property of its owner, I conducted an investigation into these claims and believe that these actions meet the definition of a dangerous dog in City ordinance 4- 10(1)(d), I recommend that the City move forward with dangerous dog proceedings at this time, as directed by City ordinance 4 -11. CKtho�i [ �' I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. , i Person Making Statement STATE OF FLORIDA Spptn to and subscribed before me thik3 )1day of Abec 2 20 [0 by . (Name of person making sta ement) '1 04 a 1 _ Seal: `� LINDA t.. LENNART Notary RubHC 4 State of Florida hfy CW"4 E 00" AuV30. 2014 r ComWealon 0 EE 207027 SOMME Through NiMU Notuy Assn.1 t Notary Public /Officer Print, Type, or Stamp Name Personally Known /OR OR Produced ID If Produced ID, type & number C POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX: (904) 247 -5899 htti3: / /www.coab.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily mare the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Kelley Caton, Animal Control Officer #309. I work for the Atlantic Beach Police Department, 850 Seminole Rd, Atlantic Beach and my office telephone number is (904) 246 -58660 Name/Description of Animal: Lola, brown brindle and whi lam Mho 3 �+ A)#t Oitd{Y�4�� Name /Address of Owner: Suzanne Leviseur and Cecilia B � Atlantic Beach, Florida 32233 rse ;os ::4 a0fa krmto0 .ttt!�j t(ikHJ�i!;RP�itW{A (tb<lOitiT Time /Date of Incident: multiple dates, including 7/26/12, 8/10/12, 9/6/12 and 9/: Describe the incident: Several complaints were made regarding the actions of Lola, the dog mentioned above. I have received multiple affidavits from neighbors, including Bruce Robbins, who Iives at 310 Magnolia St; Ronelle Davis at 354 Magnolia St; Gretchen Deter -Smith at 346 Magnolia St; and William Ross of 301 Magnolia St. All complainants state that the dog, Lola, had charged and growled at them in an aggressive and threatening manner while off the property of its owner. I conducted an investigation into these claims and believe that these actions meet the definition of a dangerous dog in City ordinance 4- 10(1)(d), I recommend that the City move forward with dangerous dog proceedings at this time, as directed by City ordinance 4 -11. Uf G fi N-V13 t 1 1.7 POLICE DEPARTMENT 1��D� 850 SEMINOLE ROAD P a-'I U o( ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 yl U' TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 FAX: (904) 247 -5899 htto: / /www.coab.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Kelley Caton, Animal Control Officer #309. I work for the Atlantic Beach Police Department, 850 Seminole Rd, Atlantic Beach and my office telephone number is (904) 246 -5866. Name /Description of Animal (Jack, tan/brown male pit pA_llull Name /Address of Owner: Suzanne Leviseur and Cecilia Babl!ls '330Vlagio1ia Street; Atlantic Beach; Florida 32233 Time /Date of Incident: multiple dates, including 7/18/12, 7/26/12, 8/21/12 and 9/6/12 Describe the incident: Several complaints were made regarding the actions of Jack, the dog mentioned above. I have received multiple affidavits from neighbors, including Bruce Robbins, who lives at 310 Magnolia St; Ronelle Davis at 354 Magnolia St; Gretchen Deter -Smith at 346 Magnolia St; and William Ross of 301 Magnolia St. All complainants state that the dog, Jack, had charged and growled at them in an aggressive and threatening manner while off the property of its owner. I conducted an investigation into these claims and believe that these actions meet the definition of a dangerous dog in City ordinance 4- 10(1)(d), I recommend that the City move forward with dangerous dog proceedings at this time, as directed by City ordinance 4 -11. Robert W. Hammesfahr r� &I (xg 13 i 1 1,6 A-nv ATTACHWANT D �E Education: AS Math and Physics, Florida Keys Gomm College, Key West, FL BAE Adult Education, Univ. of North Florida, Jacksonvioff - New Hampshire, MBA Finance and Resource Management, .Univ. Manchester, NH MS Behavioral Psychology, Univ. of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 1000+ hours of CEU's in Canine Behavioral Science Certifications: Trainers Certified Professional Dog Trainer - Assn. of A D09 Trainers Animal Behavioral Certified Dog Behavioral Consultant Intl Consultants. AKC Canine Good Citizen evaluator Work History. I've been a trainer and behaviorist in the greater Tacks ®nville area for over 28 years. Speaker at international education conferences on dog behavior. r Robert W. Hammesfahr, CPDT -KA, CDBC Behavior Training for Dogs November 15, 2012 BACKGROUND: ATTACHMENT E Excerpts are from: "Canine Behavior, a phofo illustrated handbook ", by Barbara Handleman, M.Ed, CDBC. Woof and Word Press, Norwich, v 05055. ISBN 978-0- 9765118 -2 -3. Pages 203 - 215. The above is only one of several well written books that describe Wolf and terms is Dog hunting behavior or `drives" . The b�the act of obta n for g food by ki I ng `Predatory Motor Patterns'. Predation is and consuming prey. These patterns are exhibited by both wolves and dogs. It is generally accepted in the behavioral community that the behavior is genetically predisposed. All dogs share the same genetic makeup with wolves. This being accepted, then why don't all dogs exhibit this pattern? The answer is in the breeding of dogs. If humans do not want dogs to exhibit strong predatory motor patterns then they will only breed the animals that exhibit weaker or muted predatory patterns. After many subsequent generations where this type of selective breeding occurs, the result will be that dogs no longer exhibit these patterns. As defined, the predatory motor pattern includes most and sometimes all of the following behaviors: o Scan and scent ® Orient ® Freeze ® Stalk ® Charge, pounce (also called foreleg -stab or mouse jump) or chase ® Grab bite ® Kill bite o Toss (also called kill shake) ® Dissect o Consume or cache (page 203) A11'AUHMEN T A dog is able to vary the pattern and may skip a specific behavior but the overall result is the dog will be the death of the prey. I have reviewed the reports of the three dogs in question and the following are my opinion based on what is written in the reports. It is based on my experience and training in the field of dog behavior. I have not seen the dogs. EXAMPLES of DOCUMENTED INCIDENTS: Agency Report 12 -17084 Page 6 "The dog charged him with head down, growling and teeth bore." "...the dog circled him three times." Page 7 "The dog charged and bared its teeth" "The black dog then quickly approached the little girl and growled at her." Two other dogs joined Page 8 "...two dogs... aggressively approach the group, circling the little girl on the bicycle..." Page 9 "The dog had it's head down low to the ground and was acting very aggressive, "squaring" up to the lady and young girl as it circled them." Page 12 Presence of all three dogs in victims yard one of the dogs lunged at him. Animal Complaint Affidavit of Spencer Brogden incident of 5/26/2012. "I witnessed the brown pit bull run up to the lady walking her large dog. The pit bull circled both of them and was growling...." The above are examples of Orienting and Charging. Although it is not a direct part of the Predatory Motor Pattern, before a dog will charge a large prey animal it will display a behavior called Testing. The dog will work alone or cooperatively to test the prey (victim). The display consists of the dog darting in close, bow (head down) and move away quickly to keep themselves out of harm's way. This display is seen in the above incidents and is a precursor to Charging. The following is a full copy of a dog bite: "Date5/3/2012 Subject Pit Bull attack on beach south of Dewees Ave I was walking my French Bulldog on 48" nylon ( non- extension type) leash just south of the Dewees access on the beach- in the surf. Two females were out of the water with their red Pit Bull - on loose sand about 10 yards 3 A l l AU 1.V1 2N 1 k east of dunes and 20 -- 25 yards west of the surf (tide was low). The dog (off leash) came running towards the surf at my dog and grabbed him by the back of his neck. The girls were running and screaming towards the dog but he already had a hold of Beaux shaking him vigorously. I threw myself on their dog and tried to pry him off. We eventually got their dog off mine - words were exchanged and I ran to some workers at a house on 16th access and borrowed their phone allowing me to contact authorities. Photos of abrasions to the back of Beaux's neck and some blood in the anal region were taken by Animal Control Officer Kelley Caton #309" The above is an example of full predatory motor pattern. The only thing that prevented the dog from killing the French Bulldog was the intervention of the human. It has Orient, Charge, Grab Bite, Kill Bite and Toss. The following is an excerpt from a dog bite,report: SGT J. N. Tusing #1408 dated 10103/2012 On October 2nd, 2012 at approximately 3:25 pm, I Sgt J.N. Tusing #1408 initiated a follow -up investigation into the Atlantic Beach Animal Control Affidavit received from Mr. Robbins in reference to an incident that occurred on August 10th, 2012 at approximately 4:45 pm at 310 Magnolia Street. Mr. Robbins stated in his affidavit that the brown and white pit bull mix nipped a roofing contractor that was working at his house. Mr. Robbins stated that the dog ran at the contractor and the contractor grabbed a hammer to back it down. Mr. Robbins stated that he then observed a dog growling at the contractor. He stated that the nip was minor only due to the contractor's quick action. Later in this report it describes the bite as being a small break in the skin. This is an example of the dog going through the predatory motor pattern up to the Bite phase. It was thwarted due to the size and defensive maneuver of the victim. CONCLUSION These two examples demonstrate that the dogs are not only aggressive but are willing to complete the predatory pattern on not only animals but humans as well. M Individually and collectively this group of dogs, meet definition of being dangerous to animals and humans. based on their documented behavior, they are capable injuries on both animals and humans. bert W. Hamm AITACHMENT E the behavioral In my opinion, of inflicting fatal 5 A 1 1 AUtiN EN i' 11 POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC TELEPHONE: (904) 247W5859 FAX (904) 247 -5899 httn /�ti'w4v.conb.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional Tights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is 1 live Vanessa Chamberlin Address City and my telephone number is _ (904)993 -9197 ` Name /Description of Animal: Name /Address of Owner: 330 Magnolia Street Time and Date of Incident: office Describe the incident: no control State bi Continuation of Statement QW( la A-/ry �q�#c�kmcl�J -C �l ATTACHMENT F Page 2. of .2. pages Beach, FL .32250, and I authorize the City to obtain the records as needed The surgerX included his body being shaved: and tubes being inserted to drain an infection that had occurred .due to his bite wounds. He wore a cone, around. his head and took over a month to recover from the severe injuries. That .day. was horLdfyjng as I truly believed my beloved pet was being. killed. I am so thankful that the veterinarian was able to save bis life. His veterinarian did say he was very hucky to be alive! I do hereby certify that I have read the pree'eding .statement and that it is true to the best of:my knowledge and belief.. STATE OF FLORIDA Sworn to and ubscribed before me this CkW Notary Seal, I Signature of Person Statement S.igriature of Parent or Guardian if Minor `T day of �( C [ , 2QjZ� by Nam of person malmg statement) Notary. Print, Type; or Stamp Name Personally I{nown K .OR Produced ID If Produced ID, type & number 146iry Publlo Stakol Florida Karma La1.Qsa INy,Corttml6slcri.EB 18.3208 rx lros 03/2812010 12 w � _ -�; :' ;', �- }� �M .4 kS!� f .[. ,..^?E.. QKI�iajf tq 4x14ij3i1 la 1 i • Animal. Complaint .Aftidavit Qq(i 5 it �e POLICE DEPARTMENT $SO SEMTNOLE ROAD _LANi',tC BEACH, FLORIDA: 32233 TELEPRONB: (904) 247 "W9 PAX-*(904)247"5899 http; / /www.coab,us Z have been warned of my constitational rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or -other 'issue. I fafher state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and Have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is S I live at _q M P I 1 G� SIT t 1C* W4!k&�' R4S" , f�L AdMss City State and my telephone number is gaAl fte3za Ala ©o'? ep. Name/Description of Animal: Name /Address of Owner. Time and Date of Incident: Describe the incident. 0t�u �Se'e' al / OVER FA Continuation of Statement Page of pages I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. / ``� � I / Signature of Person Making Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA Sworn to and subscribed before me this L99 day of 20��y L DoAq C5 . (Name of person making statement) Notary Seal: �. NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF • 1• Comm#EEI . t I e i� •t Wx1i ' i Print, Type, or Stamp Name Persona,,y Known OR Produced ID� tD /4 -� � L42 o :! -6 ,If s &.� -(!::) a &gglU1 3 dogs (Pit Bull all Brown (Jack), Pit Bull brown /White face (Lola) and Pit Bull mix black dog) Cecilia (Willi) Babillis, 330 Magnolia St, Atlantic Beach, FL 32233 Time and date: late morning Thursday, July 26, 2012 ► witnessed, from inside my home, the black dog running through my yard and going into the back yard of 346 Magnolia St. The homeowners' Pet Sitter arrived and abruptly stopped her car on the street in front of their driveway. The;,black.dog aggressively approached and,circled:the;;car and as the sitter ex�lted the car the black dug charged and bated itseteeth at,her T, l went outside to call out to her to be careful and where the dog was from She decidedwto make sure the.dog didn't reenter 346 Magnolia's back yard and to force it to go home. This occurred out -of- -view from the street and during this short period coming from the Howell park area, heading south on Magnolia, was a little girl (looked kindergarten or first grade age) on a bike equipped with training wheels. Behind her was her grandmother on her own bike. The Pet Sitter started to warn them and the black dog quickly approached the little girl and growled at the group. Willi appeared from 366 Magnolia St and called multiple times to the black dog. She was finally able to capture and carry the black dog back to 330 Magnolia. The sitter and grandmother waited for the coast to clear, however Willi immediately returned (without the black dog or leashes) walking around the group. When she was halfway down 366 Magnolia St's driveway, I heard a banging noise. I could see the Pit Bulls Jack and Lola running past her and aggressively approached and circled the little girl. The Pet Sitter, with a stick to block.the dogs, placed herself between the little girl and the dogs. Willi was able to pick up one of the dogs and the other followed: The Pet Sitter and Willi had an exchanged of words and I could hear the sitter informing Willi about Atlantic Beach leash laws and her dogs aredpgerous in how they approached the little girl: Willi's final response to the sitter was "Shut -up you:oid cow." Elm QKt116V1 l POLICE DEPARTAMT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 3233 TELEPHONE %.(904) 247 -5859 PAX: (904) 247-5899 . J%% / /www.coab.us Animal Complaint Affdavifi I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or •other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is t� J•t/ I live at �..- �Di9-Siy4►�.L �� /T / /��rJG -' �,��_� Address City State and my telephone number is �� *�4ZOO Name/Description of Animal. Name /Address of Owner. Time and Date of Incident. Describe the incident. AA vp /� r r< I I i /�1 .rJi/3 ix-jwd.. .t,►iive/' �OAO> /i 04ve.- la OVER i Continuation of Statement Page of pages I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. Nignature or Person fling Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA 71 P Sworn to and subscribed before me this Z.*Y day of 20 %.�- t•v �,��e%,,r� .(Name of person making statement) 5 Notary Seal:<.� -� KAREN E. KEMPF _ NOTARY PUBLIC I$TATr OF FLORIDA i RCOtnn)# EE1654 Expires B109ced ID, type & Print, Type, or Stamp Name ' Known OR Produced ID 12,14 "-6 (v5�6 /-2Z6•6 P Nignature or Person fling Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA 71 P Sworn to and subscribed before me this Z.*Y day of 20 %.�- t•v �,��e%,,r� .(Name of person making statement) 5 Notary Seal:<.� -� KAREN E. KEMPF _ NOTARY PUBLIC I$TATr OF FLORIDA i RCOtnn)# EE1654 Expires B109ced ID, type & Print, Type, or Stamp Name ' Known OR Produced ID 12,14 "-6 (v5�6 /-2Z6•6 POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247 -5859 PAX, (904) 2475899 ht�d/www ooab.u9 �!�' \y/ £� j'. 01..,1. { F ...Y • , i { Animal Complaint A.fti iayii' I have been warned of my constitutional righta and know.that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this tatemet, or any portion thereof, may he used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I Anther state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no, profAi$e -of reward.or immunity. . My name is I live at Address ,City and my telephone number is rc� Name /Description of Animal: State Name/Address of Owner: Time and Date of Incident: '�c r OVER N /Ti AL I Continuation of Statement Page, of ~ - pages J I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement a4d that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. STATE OF FLORIDA Signature of Person Malting Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian. if Minor SwrQlm to and ubscribed before me this L day of n &--1 ', 201 Z--- by f taj � � (} 661*11S . (Name of person making statement) Notary Seal: Aw(�ddlul�iiiYfii'K�iYi�fiO ',yy ° ; u • Personally arn n• OR Produced ID If Produced . number Lf f1 1 A R ATLA V-- Gt7 6 Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and lmow that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I :am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I farther state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My Warne is fliveat Si l, fKAGOoLIJA tTTAJQ r. i L!� , 11 1 d• and my telephone •' 510 I r� Name/Description of Animal: Name /Address of Owner: (D) LL t_ ' _ _ _ __ _ —�M-O Time and Date of Incident: Describe the incident: �A/ y l= ► n� .� n`i'1J &0 L S 1� I y� OVER C Wi D it 6�� Continuation of Statement Page of pages rj I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding of my knowledge and belief. 4s STATE OF FLORIDA 1 and that it is true to the best Of Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor w- day ofJjfi20 t X by - (Name of pers n rmaking statement) v+n+u MERLYN A. ADA3 Notary Public/Of ficer Notary Public •StaFlorida My t;vmm. t xptres Commission � DBonded through Nattort Print, 'hype, or Stamp Name Personally Known_ OR Produced ID- If Produced ID, type & number _) a & P, )-?() -&- ?� �6 ) 1-- 6 Y 6<w6t�( Animal Complaint Af aayit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is I live at `� ^�Q �C�2 �-�=— Address Gary state and my telephone number is ' a k 3 V (o w j "1 l 5 B rl) t�'r ) Name/Description of Animal; Name/Address/of Owner: Time and Date of incident: Describe the incident: q11 1401a, ID', 4'5` t Continuation of Statement M f ageLN ftiD i 1013 I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement of my knowledge and belief. / , is true to the best Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA worn to and subscri b f re me this] ( day o *�� 20 by R (Name of person mat ng statement) Notary Seal: A01.. Notary Public/Officer ado KC blk CM•t Print, Type, or Stamp Name � # to Personally Known OR Produced ID V e«ww t�,n► 4ti roduced ID, type &number r � tNJ r POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMINOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BEACK FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 247.5859 FAX (904) 247 -5899 hap: / /www coat us &mal Complaint Affidavit 1 M I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I_am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing- full well this statement, or any poxttort thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Andv Huffman Z live at 11447 orlon D ve kcsnlie F 32218 Address City State and my telephone number is (904) KjI9920 Narne/Description of .Animal; Name /Address of Owner ;3U Ma olio Street voune¢r lady Time and Date of Incident; Octolaer 9, 2012 at�nroxima #eiY 11 *20 a Describe the incident: I_ was standing near the crnrattA raafl;,,n A ,.. ^4 Continuation of Statement completelout of� control, v c aq Page �2� of 2. pages I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief . Signature of Person Making of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of , 20 by . (Name of person making statement) Notary Seal; Notary Public /Officer Print, Type, or Stamp Name Personally Known. OR Produced ID � If Produced ID, type & number -__ - -_ VA POLICE DEPARTMENT 850 SEMMOLE ROAD ATLANTIC BRACH, FLORIDA 32233 TELEPHONE: (904) 2474859 FAX (904) 247 -5899 la: / /www.coab.us Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. -I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Andy Huffman I live at 11447 Harlan Drive Jacksonville FL 32218 , Address City State and my telephone number is 904 838 -9920 , Name/Description of Animal: Two Pit Bulls — (one black and one whitMan� Name /Address of Owner: 330 Magnolia Street, your er lady Time and Date of Incident: October 9. 20124 approximately 11.20 a.m. Describe the incident: I was standing near the garapinding a manual regarding the south with two nit bulls (one black and one white /taut As the pit bulls wexe just north of 3 Continuation of Statement COMT)letelv out of control. Page 2. of 2. pages I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is of my knowledge and belief. STATE OF FLORIDA Notary Seal: •�•�" LINDA L. LENHART Notary Public • State of Florida • My Comm, Expires Aug 30, 2011 -. commission # EE 201927 "'�,4;,,�t,'�'� Bonded Through NHfo►teE NW Assn. Personally If Produced ID, type & numbert I Signature to the best Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor me this r 4ay . 20 tyby (Name of person malting statement) b F Notary Public /Officer Print:, Type, or Stamp Name IM OR Produced ID _b I ATLANT 1�014 "C 'GGi i,S LI to Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, knowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue, I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is Willi , . . ,r , i loo& � I live at �j v 4i ,. $•1- Address and my telephone number is Name/Description of Animal: Name /Address of Owner, Time and Date of Incident: T Describe the incident:: ._., .1.�'.,; City State W S.�l" f• 23 Y OVER sf fa � 1"% Continuation of Statement U[Wl 15 f'-- Lf t"AL Gw^ii Sbv+r,a%r,a x!111-- _- ___51,, r- `bo41J,G'1 'iD � 5 -3(11 Wv eA Wcia Ll .j_,\ , y 1 I� j ..f,,, ! U a , z L M t n.L a � U,..C.� Sn�Al e) n wv� `T %.e e7 ^.�C i t Q. I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief.. Signature of Person Making Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian if Minor STATE OF FLORIDA Sworn to ands bspribe�d/jbefore me this a z day of ' 20� by % (Name of person making statement) wawig MERLYN A. ALVARO Notary Public - State of Florida My Comm. Expires Aug 5. 9013 Commission # Od 913050 Banded through NelfoMf Notory Assn. Notary Public /Officer Al ALVK-0 Q•, 01.E ��..,�.( Print, Type, or Stamp Name Personally Known OR Produced ID vv` If Produced ID, type & number PL 0& �ZW.-q vA�-s-�c4513 � IN Animal Complaint Affidavit I have been warned of my constitutional rights and know that I do not have to make any statement at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make the following, imowing full well this statement, or any portion thereof, may be used against me or any other person at any time in any court, trial, or other issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to any threats or duress and have received no promise of reward or immunity. My name is JA/1 I I 10, VW% 6V, tic, (4S I live at _ ' Aq Ino j,at;, 5 , Address l �Ici -A 6 r L City state and my telephone number is . Name/Description of Animal: 3 Name /Address of Owner, Time and Date of Incident, Describe the incident::!.: �,✓�, s c� ,r', v S or, f� 5 OVER Ely et)y 3 i Continuation of Statement Page of pages SLO [Ald) i'11 1 � ^^ I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. Signature of Person Making Statement Signature of Parent or STATE OF FLORIDA ��S `worn to and s bsoribed before me this v7lt day of P� ; 20� by `W L (Name of person making statement) 1Vn�tar� gpgj I _ ,. T �, lam- o&,.L Notary Public P State of Florida My Comm.. Expires An ti, 2013 Commission # DD 913880 Bonded 7brouph National Notary Assn, If Produced ID, type & number. if Minos Notary Public /Officer Al 1 ALt.(kk,0 Print, Type, or Stamp Name Known OR Produced ID ✓ .0 0/1111% 1'l y AGENDA ITEM # 8A OCTOBER 22, 2012 PoUCE,DFX-.'" MI NT 850 SEMINOM.ROAD ATLAi`1`z?[C BEMAL FL -ORMA 32233 TELEPHONE: (90 4) 247 -5859 �FAX:`(904) •247 -5899 • h'tfp• /lvn�rsv coab,us Animal ComiiIAW Affidavi E I<<hav6 beeAlw,amed. o£ my constitutional rights and know that x do not have to make, any< sfatexnent at this time. I am freely and voluntarily make e following, lixuowing Ul well this stafeij?on, or any portion thex.6 may be used. against me or any other perso at`any't ine in any court, trial, or outer. issue. I further state that I have not been subjected to aiiy tbteats or duress and have xece ved no piomise of reward or immunity My name is � *Cr, I live at 9 Address city State and my telephone number isC_%1 Namp/Description of Animal: Name /Address of Owner: Time and Date of Ineident: Describe the incident: SC) I i cA &r-duv i-� ? + L UA- 3S© �'rv1 �r�, fie' �( >c�v`` ") CA,/a �kt`f;L, ova i 0 no CA 0 0 rUiv,, ` run te b 0 CSC ' eilndn 01 Gvt7 R OVER Continuation of Statement CA- Page of pages c1 t.1 (vl Cam, Pn OyA r'j jaf rt �� 6 -c( c - .Sl�c'y�� CJ_ I do hereby certify that I have read the preceding statement and that it is true to the best of my knowledge and belief. STATE OF 4Q MA Signature of Person Malting Statement Signature of Parent or Guardian. if Minor day of ® , zo/ Z—by (Name of person malting statement) ^ / Notary Public /Officer Fp we, Print, Type, or Stamp Name Personally Known V' OR Produced ID_ e & number