Cloister condo meeting - 5Dan, sorry that your judgement is being questioned by folks who are simply trying to cover their rear and not address the problem, however thanks to you the board approved getting three
bids from forensic structural engineers at tonight's meeting. I'm not sure how much help the two design engineers would be since it may ultimately be determined they have some culpability
but who knows. It may be two more months before the board decides IF they will actually hire an engineer. In the meantime we are pursuing hiring our own. I would not be surprised if
mgt. co. and/or Allison try to get the board to just go with the architect' s report. We shall see. Thanks again, more progress than we've had since this began.
Marshall Howell
On Tue, Feb 19, 2019, 6:19 PM Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us> wrote:
Alison,
I want you to know that I take your concerns very seriously.
I am trying to be careful to not damage your property values or the perception of your buildings.
I am not a structural engineer and I cannot do the evaluation needed here, but I have been building, repairing, and inspecting buildings for a long time and I am very sure that we have
a settlement/deflection issue somewhere beneath Unit #66, that needs to be resolved.
I plan to call the two engineers that designed the remodel of Units #65 and 64, tomorrow, and see if they are interested in helping.
I will keep you informed of anything I do or find out.
Sincerely,
Dan Arlington, CBO
Building Official
City of Atlantic Beach, Florida
darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>
(904) 247-5813
-----Original Message-----
From: Alison [mailto:cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>]
Sent: Tuesday, February 19, 2019 2:06 PM
To: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>
Cc: David Root <droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>>; C. Paul DiGiacomo <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>>;
Adam Veale <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; M. Howell <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>; mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
Subject: Re: Cloister condo meeting
Dan,
Since neither you nor Paul have inspected #64 or 65, I find it extremely reckless for you to say that there is “settling” in those units. There is not and we don’t need a structural
engineer to determine that! You are welcome to inspect these units and verify for yourself. I take complete exception to your misstatements and careless innuendos.
Alison Brown
> On Feb 19, 2019, at 9:29 AM, Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>> by wrote:
>
> David,
>
> Thanks for the reply. It is unfortunate that you cannot share information.
>
> All,
>
> I will meet with anyone, almost any time, but I still recommend that
> you employ a structural engineer to investigate and provide a report for the settling in the Units 64,65,66 column.
>
> Sincerely,
>
> Dan Arlington, CBO
> Building Official
> City of Atlantic Beach, Florida
> darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>
> (904) 247-5813
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: David Root [mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>]
> Sent: Monday, February 18, 2019 11:08 AM
> To: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>; 'Alison'
> <cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>>; 'C. Paul DiGiacomo'
> <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>>
> Cc: 'Adam Veale' <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; 'M. Howell'
> <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>; mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
> Subject: RE: Cloister condo meeting
>
> Dan,
>
> Unfortunately, I have been advised by my client that we are NOT to provide our report to you or any other company or entity.
>
> Sorry.....
>
> Regards,
>
> David
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>
> Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2019 4:13 PM
> To: David Root <droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>>; 'Alison'
> <cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>>; 'C. Paul DiGiacomo'
> <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>>
> Cc: 'Adam Veale' <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; 'M. Howell'
> <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>; mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
> Subject: RE: Cloister condo meeting
>
> David,
>
> I did not receive a copy of your report.
> Can you send me a copy please?
>
> Regards,
>
>
> Dan Arlington, CBO
> Building Official
> City of Atlantic Beach, Florida
> darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>
> (904) 247-5813
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: David Root [mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>]
> Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2019 2:16 PM
> To: 'Alison' <cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>>; 'C. Paul DiGiacomo'
> <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>>
> Cc: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>; 'Adam Veale'
> <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; 'M. Howell' <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>;
> mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
> Subject: RE: Cloister condo meeting
>
> Alison,
>
> So that everyone is clear. We (Paul DiGiacomo PE) and Root Cause Forensics were hired by Universal property and casualty insurance company to evaluate the cracks and wall separation
in the Howell residence and render an opinion as to the cause. We did that and provided a written report to the insurance company. We also accordingly have informed the local building
authorities of the issues we believe that are occurring and should be addressed.
>
> If you have any other questions please feel free to contact me at the number listed below.
>
> All the best,
>
>
> David J Root
> President
> Root Cause Consulting
> 36181 East Lake Rd #402
> Palm Harbor, FL 34685
> droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>
> 813-777-5363 cell
> 888-566-0815 office
>
>
>
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Alison <cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>>
> Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2019 1:49 PM
> To: C. Paul DiGiacomo <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>>
> Cc: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>; Adam Veale
> <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; M. Howell <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>;
> mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>; David Root <droot@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:droot@rootcauseconsulting.com>>
> Subject: Re: Cloister condo meeting
>
> Who is your client?
>
>> On Feb 14, 2019, at 10:04 AM, C. Paul DiGiacomo <pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>> wrote:
>>
>> Good Morning,
>>
>> I've yet to hear from my client. Have you contacted the EOR of the sealed drawings you should have for the remolded units? The only drawings I reviewed were incomplete and not sealed.
>>
>> Please use this email in the future:
>> pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> C. Paul DiGiacomo P.E.
>> 770 Wakemont Dr., OP, FL 32065
>> 904.775.1308; pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com<mailto:pdigiacomo@rootcauseconsulting.com>
>>
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Arlington, Daniel [mailto:darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>]
>> Sent: Thursday, February 14, 2019 9:47 AM
>> To: Alison <cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>>
>> Cc: alohaengineering@outlook.com<mailto:alohaengineering@outlook.com>; Adam Veale
>> <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; M. Howell <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>;
>> mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
>> Subject: RE: Cloister condo meeting
>>
>> Alison,
>>
>> I can't close this out without an evaluation from a licensed professional engineer.
>> We talked about doing this in stages and we can have two inspection meetings, if you like, but I would rather have one with the engineer present.
>> The first stage of this process would be verifying that we had engineered plans and permits and I can say now, without the first inspection, that is no longer an issue.
>> I am stating in this email and I will state in a separate letter that Units #64 and #65 had approved engineering and building permits for their respective remodeling projects.
>> The bigger structural issue requires a structural engineer to evaluate the three units.
>> I hope to hear from Mr. DiGiacomo soon.
>>
>> Sincerely,
>>
>> Dan Arlington, CBO
>> Building Official
>> City of Atlantic Beach, Florida
>> darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>
>> (904) 247-5813
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Alison [mailto:cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>]
>> Sent: Wednesday, February 13, 2019 9:34 AM
>> To: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>
>> Cc: alohaengineering@outlook.com<mailto:alohaengineering@outlook.com>; Adam Veale
>> <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>; M. Howell <mfhowelljr@gmail.com<mailto:mfhowelljr@gmail.com>>;
>> mbcampbell46@gmail.com<mailto:mbcampbell46@gmail.com>
>> Subject: Re: Cloister condo meeting
>>
>> Dan,
>> As we discussed when we met on Monday, I want the inspection of units 64. 65 and 66 to be done ASAP. As we also discussed, all permitting and approvals were received for the renovations
of units 64 and 65 from the city of atlantic beach, although your letter suggests otherwise. In my opinion, those required at the meeting are you, me, the campbells (#65 owners),
their contractor if they wish and the Howells, if they wish. I am not willing to wait for a response from Mr. DiGiacomo as to his availability for the inspections.
>>
>> Alison
>>
>>> On Feb 13, 2019, at 9:23 AM, Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>> wrote:
>>>
>>> Thanks Alison,
>>>
>>> Hello Adam,
>>> I am forwarding this email to Paul DiGiacomo, P.E., from Aloha Engineering, who recently conducted a preliminary inspection and study of the 66, 65, 64 vertical structure.
>>>
>>> Paul,
>>> As we discussed yesterday, by phone, here are the main contact people to help arrange a visit to the three units in question (except Unit 65). We hope that you can get approval,
from the parties that originally contracted with you, to make the visits necessary to complete your report.
>>> As with any group meeting, I hope you can offer some dates to choose from, so we can all have some flexibility in scheduling the visit.
>>>
>>> Thank you all,
>>>
>>> Dan Arlington, CBO
>>> Building Official
>>> City of Atlantic Beach, Florida
>>> darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>
>>> (904) 247-5813
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: Alison [mailto:cloister64@aol.com<mailto:cloister64@aol.com>]
>>> Sent: Tuesday, February 12, 2019 6:17 PM
>>> To: Arlington, Daniel <darlington@coab.us<mailto:darlington@coab.us>>
>>> Cc: Adam Veale <aveale@stellarproperties.com<mailto:aveale@stellarproperties.com>>
>>> Subject: Cloister condo meeting
>>>
>>> Dan,
>>>
>>> I have included Adam Veale’s email address, as well as my own. Please work with Adam to coordinate scheduling the inspections for units 64, 65 and 66.
>>>
>>> Thanks,
>>> Alison Brown
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>
>
> ---
> This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
> https://www.avast.com/antivirus
>
>
慨汬䠠睯汥൬ഊ伊畔ⱥ䘠扥ㄠⰹ㈠ⰹ㘠ㄺ‹䵐䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵‾牷瑯㩥汁獩湯ബഊ䤊眠湡⁴潹⁵潴欠潮⁷桴瑡䤠琠歡潹牵挠湯散湲敶祲猠牥潩獵祬മ䤊愠牴楹杮琠敢挠牡晥汵琠潮⁴慤慭敧礠畯牰灯牥祴瘠污敵牯琠敨瀠牥散瑰潩景礠畯畢汩楤杮⁉浡渠瑯愠猠牴捵畴慲湥楧敮牥愠摮䤠挠湡潮⁴潤琠敨攠慶畬瑡潩敮摥摥栠牥ⱥ戠瑵䤠栠癡敢湥戠極摬湩Ⱨ爠灥楡楲
杮湡湩灳捥楴杮戠極摬湩獧映牯愠氠湯楴敭愠摮䤠愠敶祲猠牵桴瑡眠慨敶愠猠瑥汴浥湥⽴敤汦捥楴湯椠獳敵猠浯睥敨敲戠湥慥桴唠楮⁴㘣ⰶ琠慨⁴敮摥潴戠敲潳癬摥മഊ䤊瀠慬潴挠污桴睴湥楧敮牥桴瑡搠獥杩敮桴敲潭敤景唠楮獴⌠㔶愠摮㘠ⰴ琠浯牯潲ⱷ愠摮猠敥椠桴祥愠敲椠瑮牥獥整湩栠汥楰杮മ䤊眠汩敫灥礠畯椠普牯敭景愠祮桴湩⁉潤漠楦摮漠瑵മഊ匊湩散敲祬ബഊ䐊湡䄠汲湩瑧湯䉃൏䈊極摬湩
晏楦楣污楃祴漠瑁慬瑮捩䈠慥档汆牯摩ൡ搊牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳㤨㐰
㐲ⴷ㠵㌱ⴭⴭ伭楲楧慮敍獳条ⵥⴭⴭ牆浯›汁獩湯嬠慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㱭慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㹭൝匊湥㩴吠敵摳祡敆牢慵祲ㄠⰹ㈠‹㨲㘰倠്吊㩯䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾捃›慄楶潒瑯㰠牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴携潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯㸾※⹃倠畡楄楇捡浯瀼楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵
捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭㬾䄠慤敖污愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾䴠潈敷汬㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯㸾※扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯ാ匊扵敪瑣›敒›汃楯瑳牥挠湯潤洠敥楴杮慄Ɱ楓据敮瑩敨潹⁵潮慐汵栠癡湩灳捥整⌠㐶漠㔶⁉楦摮椠⁴硥牴浥汥⁹敲正敬獳映牯礠畯琠慳⁹桴瑡琠敨敲椠玓瑥汴湩鑧椠桴獯湵
瑩吠敨敲椠潮⁴湡敷搠湯璒渠敥瑳畲瑣牵污攠杮湩敥潴搠瑥牥業敮琠慨ⅴ夠畯愠敲眠汥潣敭琠湩灳捥⁴桴獥湵瑩湡敶楲祦映牯礠畯獲汥䤠琠歡潣灭敬整攠捸灥楴湯琠潹牵洠獩瑳瑡浥湥獴愠摮挠牡汥獥湩畮湥潤汁獩湯䈠潲湷‾湏䘠扥ㄠⰹ㈠ⰹ愠⁴㨹㤲䄠ⱍ䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾戠⁹牷瑯㩥ാ㸊䐠癡摩ബ㸊‾桔湡獫映牯琠敨爠灥祬䤠⁴獩甠普牯畴慮整
琠慨⁴潹⁵慣湮瑯猠慨敲椠普牯慭楴湯മ㸊‾汁ⱬാ㸊䤠眠汩敭瑥眠瑩湡潹敮污潭瑳愠祮琠浩ⱥ戠瑵䤠猠楴汬爠捥浯敭摮琠慨൴㸊礠畯攠灭潬⁹瑳畲瑣牵污攠杮湩敥潴椠癮獥楴慧整愠摮瀠潲楶敤愠爠灥牯⁴潦桴敳瑴楬杮椠桴湕瑩㐶㘬ⰵ㘶挠汯浵ാ㸊匠湩散敲祬ബ㸊‾慄牁楬杮潴Ɱ䌠佂‾畂汩楤杮传晦捩慩൬㸊䌠瑩⁹景䄠汴湡楴敂捡ⱨ䘠潬楲慤‾慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵ാ㸊⠠〹⤴㈠
㜴㔭ㄸള㸊ാ㸊‾ⴭⴭ伭楲楧慮敍獳条ⵥⴭⴭ‾牆浯›慄楶潒瑯嬠慭汩潴携潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯洼楡瑬㩯牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭൝㸊匠湥㩴䴠湯慤ⱹ䘠扥畲牡⁹㠱〲㤱ㄠ㨱㠰䄠്㸊吠㩯䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾※䄧楬潳❮‾挼潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㱭慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㹭㬾✠⹃倠畡楄楇捡浯❯‾瀼楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯
䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭ാ㸊䌠㩣✠摁浡嘠慥敬‧愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾✠⹍䠠睯汥❬‾洼桦睯汥橬䁲浧楡潣㱭慭汩潴洺桦睯汥橬䁲浧楡潣㹭㬾洠换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧楡潣㱭慭汩潴洺换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧楡潣㹭‾畓橢捥㩴删㩅䌠潬獩整潣摮敭瑥湩൧㸊‾慄Ɱാ㸊唠普牯畴慮整祬䤠栠癡敢湥愠癤獩摥戠⁹祭挠楬湥⁴桴瑡眠牡低⁔潴瀠潲楶敤漠牵爠灥牯⁴潴礠畯漠湡⁹瑯
敨潣灭湡⁹牯攠瑮瑩ാ㸊匠牯祲⸮⸮മ㸊‾敒慧摲ⱳാ㸊䐠癡摩ാ㸊ⴠⴭⴭ牏杩湩污䴠獥慳敧ⴭⴭഭ㸊䘠潲㩭䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾‾敓瑮›桔牵摳祡敆牢慵祲ㄠⰴ㈠‹㨴㌱倠്㸊吠㩯䐠癡摩删潯⁴搼潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯洼楡瑬㩯牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭㬾✠汁獩湯ധ㸊㰠汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯洼楡瑬㩯汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯㸾※䌧慐汵䐠䝩慩潣潭ധ㸊㰠摰杩
慩潣潭牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯洼楡瑬㩯摰杩慩潣潭牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯㸾‾捃›䄧慤敖污❥㰠癡慥敬獀整汬牡牰灯牥楴獥挮浯洼楡瑬㩯癡慥敬獀整汬牡牰灯牥楴獥挮浯㸾※䴧潈敷汬ധ㸊㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯㸾※扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯ാ㸊匠扵敪瑣›䕒›汃楯瑳牥挠湯潤洠敥楴杮ാ㸊䐠癡摩ബ㸊‾⁉楤潮⁴敲散癩潣祰漠潹牵爠灥牯‾慃潹⁵敳
摮洠潣祰瀠敬獡㽥ാ㸊删来牡獤ബ㸊ാ㸊䐠湡䄠汲湩瑧湯䉃൏㸊䈠極摬湩晏楦楣污‾楃祴漠瑁慬瑮捩䈠慥档汆牯摩ൡ㸊搠牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳‾㤨㐰
㐲ⴷ㠵㌱ാ㸊ാ㸊ⴠⴭⴭ牏杩湩污䴠獥慳敧ⴭⴭഭ㸊䘠潲㩭䐠癡摩删潯⁴浛楡瑬㩯牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴携潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯崾‾敓瑮›桔牵摳祡敆牢慵祲ㄠⰴ㈠‹㨲㘱倠്㸊吠㩯✠汁獩湯‧挼潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㱭慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㹭㬾✠⹃倠畡楄楇捡浯❯‾瀼楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭ാ㸊䌠㩣䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯
獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾※䄧慤敖污❥‾愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾✠⹍䠠睯汥❬㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯㸾഻㸊洠换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧楡潣㱭慭汩潴洺换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧楡潣㹭‾畓橢捥㩴删㩅䌠潬獩整潣摮敭瑥湩൧㸊‾汁獩湯ബ㸊‾潓琠慨⁴癥牥潹敮椠汣慥†敗⠠慐汵䐠䝩慩潣潭倠⥅愠摮删潯⁴慃獵潆敲獮捩敷敲栠物摥戠⁹湕癩牥慳
牰灯牥祴愠摮挠獡慵瑬⁹湩畳慲据潣灭湡⁹潴攠慶畬瑡桴牣捡獫愠摮眠污敳慰慲楴湯椠桴潈敷汬爠獥摩湥散愠摮爠湥敤湡漠楰楮湯愠潴琠敨挠畡敳圠楤桴瑡愠摮瀠潲楶敤牷瑩整敲潰瑲琠桴湩畳慲据潣灭湡†敗愠獬捡潣摲湩汧⁹慨敶椠普牯敭桴潬慣畢汩楤杮愠瑵潨楲楴獥漠桴獩畳獥眠敢楬癥桴瑡愠敲漠捣牵楲杮愠摮猠潨汵敢愠摤敲獳摥മ㸊‾晉礠畯栠癡湡⁹瑯敨畱獥楴湯汰慥敳映
敥牦敥琠潣瑮捡⁴敭愠⁴桴畮扭牥氠獩整敢潬ാ㸊䄠汬琠敨戠獥ⱴാ㸊‾慄楶⁊潒瑯‾牐獥摩湥൴㸊删潯⁴慃獵潃獮汵楴杮‾㘳㠱‱慅瑳䰠歡摒⌠〴ല㸊倠污慈扲牯䱆†㐳㠶വ㸊搠潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯洼楡瑬㩯牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭‾ㄸⴳ㜷ⴷ㌵㌶挠汥൬㸊㠠㠸㔭㘶〭ㄸ‵景楦散ാ㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊ⴠⴭⴭ牏杩湩污䴠獥慳敧ⴭⴭഭ㸊䘠潲㩭䄠楬潳挼潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㱭慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴
潡潣㹭ാ㸊匠湥㩴吠畨獲慤ⱹ䘠扥畲牡⁹㐱〲㤱ㄠ㐺‹䵐‾潔›⹃倠畡楄楇捡浯瀼楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭ാ㸊䌠㩣䄠汲湩瑧湯慄楮汥㰠慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵㸾※摁浡嘠慥敬‾愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾䴠潈敷汬㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯㸾഻㸊洠换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧
楡潣㱭慭汩潴洺换浡扰汥㑬䀶浧楡潣㹭※慄楶潒瑯㰠牤潯䁴潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴携潲瑯牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯㸾‾畓橢捥㩴删㩥䌠潬獩整潣摮敭瑥湩൧㸊‾桗獩礠畯汣敩瑮ി㸊㸾传敆㐱〲㤱瑡ㄠ㨰㐰䄠ⱍ䌠慐汵䐠䝩慩潣潭㰠摰杩慩潣潭牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯洼楡瑬㩯摰杩慩潣潭牀潯捴畡敳潣獮汵楴杮挮浯㸾眠潲整ഺ㸊ാ㸊‾潇摯䴠牯楮杮ബ㸊ാ㸊‾❉敶礠瑥琠敨牡映潲祭挠楬湥†慈敶礠
畯挠湯慴瑣摥琠敨䔠剏漠桴敳污摥搠慲楷杮潹⁵桳畯摬栠癡潦桴敲潭摬摥甠楮獴‿吠敨漠汮⁹牤睡湩獧䤠爠癥敩敷敷敲椠据浯汰瑥湡潮⁴敳污摥മ㸊ാ㸊‾汐慥敳甠敳琠楨浥楡湩琠敨映瑵牵㩥㸾瀠楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭㸾㸾吠慨歮ⱳ㸾㸾䌠慐汵䐠䝩慩潣潭倠䔮മ㸊‾㜷‰慗敫潭瑮䐠偏䱆㌠〲㔶㸾㤠㐰㜮㔷ㄮ〳㬸瀠楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳
瑬湩潣㱭慭汩潴瀺楤楧捡浯䁯潲瑯慣獵捥湯畳瑬湩潣㹭㸾㸾㸾㸾ⴠⴭⴭ牏杩湩污䴠獥慳敧ⴭⴭഭ㸊‾牆浯›牁楬杮潴Ɱ䐠湡敩浛楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵洼楡瑬㩯慤汲湩瑧湯捀慯獵崾㸾匠湥㩴吠畨獲慤ⱹ䘠扥畲牡⁹㐱〲㤱㤠㐺‷䵁㸾吠㩯䄠楬潳挼潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㱭慭汩潴挺潬獩整㙲䀴潡潣㹭ാ㸊‾捃›污桯敡杮湩敥楲杮潀瑵潬歯挮浯洼楡瑬㩯污桯敡杮湩敥楲杮潀瑵潬歯挮浯㬾䄠慤敖污㸊‾愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数
瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾䴠潈敷汬㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯㸾഻㸊‾扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯ാ㸊‾畓橢捥㩴删㩅䌠潬獩整潣摮敭瑥湩൧㸊ാ㸊‾汁獩湯ബ㸊ാ㸊‾⁉慣❮⁴汣獯桴獩漠瑵眠瑩潨瑵愠癥污慵楴湯映潲楬散獮摥瀠潲敦獳潩慮湥楧敮牥മ㸊‾敗琠污敫扡畯⁴潤湩桴獩椠瑳条獥愠摮眠慣慨敶琠潷椠獮数瑣潩敭瑥湩獧
晩礠畯氠歩ⱥ戠瑵䤠眠畯摬爠瑡敨慨敶漠敮眠瑩桴湥楧敮牥瀠敲敳瑮മ㸊‾桔楦獲⁴瑳条景琠楨牰捯獥潷汵敢瘠牥晩楹杮琠慨⁴敷栠摡攠杮湩敥敲汰湡湡数浲瑩湡⁉慣慳⁹潮ⱷ眠瑩潨瑵琠敨映物瑳椠獮数瑣潩Ɱ琠慨⁴獩渠潬杮牥愠獩畳㸾䤠愠瑳瑡湩湩琠楨浥楡湡⁉楷汬猠慴整椠敳慰慲整氠瑥整桴瑡唠楮獴⌠㐶愠摮⌠㔶栠摡愠灰潲敶湥楧敮牥湩湡畢汩楤杮瀠牥業獴映牯琠敨物爠獥数瑣
癩敲潭敤楬杮瀠潲敪瑣㸾吠敨戠杩敧瑳畲瑣牵污椠獳敵爠煥極敲瑳畲瑣牵污攠杮湩敥潴攠慶畬瑡桴桴敲湵瑩㸾䤠栠灯潴栠慥牦浯䴠䐠䝩慩潣潭猠潯㸾㸾匠湩散敲祬ബ㸊ാ㸊‾慄牁楬杮潴Ɱ䌠佂㸾䈠極摬湩晏楦楣污㸾䌠瑩⁹景䄠汴湡楴敂捡ⱨ䘠潬楲慤㸾搠牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳㸾⠠〹⤴㈠㜴㔭ㄸള㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊ാ㸊‾ⴭⴭ伭楲楧慮敍獳条ⵥⴭⴭ㸾䘠潲㩭
䄠楬潳浛楡瑬㩯汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯洼楡瑬㩯汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯崾㸾匠湥㩴圠摥敮摳祡敆牢慵祲ㄠⰳ㈠‹㨹㐳䄠്㸊‾潔›牁楬杮潴Ɱ䐠湡敩搼牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳ാ㸊‾捃›污桯敡杮湩敥楲杮潀瑵潬歯挮浯洼楡瑬㩯污桯敡杮湩敥楲杮潀瑵潬歯挮浯㬾䄠慤敖污㸊‾愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭㬾䴠潈敷汬㰠晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯晭潨敷汬牪杀慭汩
挮浯㸾഻㸊‾扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯洼楡瑬㩯扭慣灭敢汬㘴杀慭汩挮浯ാ㸊‾畓橢捥㩴删㩥䌠潬獩整潣摮敭瑥湩൧㸊ാ㸊‾慄Ɱ㸾䄠敷搠獩畣獳摥眠敨敷洠瑥漠潍摮祡⁉慷瑮琠敨椠獮数瑣潩景甠楮獴㘠⸴㘠‵湡㘶琠敢搠湯十偁獁眠污潳搠獩畣獳摥污数浲瑩楴杮愠摮愠灰潲慶獬眠牥敲散癩摥映牯琠敨爠湥癯瑡潩獮漠湵瑩㐶愠摮㘠‵牦浯琠敨挠瑩⁹景愠汴湡楴敢捡ⱨ†污桴畯桧礠畯敬瑴牥猠杵敧瑳瑯敨睲
獩†湉洠⁹灯湩潩Ɱ琠潨敳爠煥極敲瑡琠敨洠敥楴杮愠敲礠畯敭桴慣灭敢汬⌨㔶漠湷牥⥳桴楥潣瑮慲瑣牯椠桴祥眠獩湡桴潈敷汬ⱳ椠桴祥眠獩†⁉浡渠瑯眠汩楬杮琠慷瑩映牯愠爠獥潰獮牦浯䴠䐠䝩慩潣潭愠潴栠獩愠慶汩扡汩瑩⁹潦桴湩灳捥楴湯㸾㸾䄠楬潳൮㸊ാ㸊㸾传敆㌱〲㤱瑡㤠㈺″䵁牁楬杮潴Ɱ䐠湡敩搼牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳‾牷瑯㩥㸾ാ㸊㸾吠慨歮
汁獩湯ബ㸊㸾㸾‾效汬摁浡ബ㸊㸾䤠愠潦睲牡楤杮琠楨浥楡潴倠畡楄楇捡浯Ɐ倠䔮Ⱞ映潲汁桯湅楧敮牥湩Ⱨ眠潨爠捥湥汴⁹潣摮捵整牰汥浩湩牡⁹湩灳捥楴湯愠摮猠畴祤漠桴㘶㔶㐶瘠牥楴慣瑳畲瑣牵㸾ാ㸊㸾倠畡ⱬ㸾‾獁眠楤捳獵敳敹瑳牥慤ⱹ戠⁹桰湯ⱥ栠牥牡桴慭湩挠湯慴瑣瀠潥汰潴栠汥⁰牡慲杮楶楳⁴潴琠敨琠牨敥甠楮獴椠畱獥楴湯⠠硥散瑰唠楮⁴㔶⸩†敗栠灯桴瑡礠畯挠湡朠瑥
愠灰潲慶ⱬ映潲桴慰瑲敩桴瑡漠楲楧慮汬⁹潣瑮慲瑣摥眠瑩潹Ⱶ琠慭敫琠敨瘠獩瑩敮散獳牡⁹潴挠浯汰瑥潹牵爠灥牯㸾‾獁眠瑩湡⁹牧畯⁰敭瑥湩Ⱨ䤠栠灯潹⁵慣景敦潳敭搠瑡獥琠档潯敳映潲Ɑ猠敷挠湡愠汬栠癡潳敭映敬楸楢楬祴椠捳敨畤楬杮琠敨瘠獩瑩മ㸊㸾㸾‾桔湡潹⁵污ⱬ㸾ാ㸊㸾䐠湡䄠汲湩瑧湯䉃൏㸊㸾䈠極摬湩晏楦楣污㸾‾楃祴漠瑁慬瑮捩䈠慥档汆牯摩ൡ㸊㸾搠牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳
慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳㸾‾㤨㐰
㐲ⴷ㠵㌱㸾ാ㸊㸾㸾ാ㸊㸾㸾ാ㸊㸾ⴠⴭⴭ牏杩湩污䴠獥慳敧ⴭⴭഭ㸊㸾䘠潲㩭䄠楬潳浛楡瑬㩯汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯洼楡瑬㩯汣楯瑳牥㐶慀汯挮浯崾㸾‾敓瑮›畔獥慤ⱹ䘠扥畲牡⁹㈱〲㤱㘠ㄺ‷䵐㸾‾潔›牁楬杮潴Ɱ䐠湡敩搼牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㱳慭汩潴携牡楬杮潴䁮潣扡甮㹳ാ㸊㸾䌠㩣䄠慤敖污愼敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㱭慭汩潴愺敶污䁥瑳汥慬灲潲数瑲敩潣㹭ാ㸊㸾匠扵敪瑣›汃楯瑳牥挠湯潤洠敥楴杮㸾ാ㸊㸾䐠湡
ബ㸊㸾㸾‾⁉慨敶椠据畬敤摁浡嘠慥敬玒攠慭汩愠摤敲獳獡眠汥獡洠⁹睯倠敬獡潷歲眠瑩摁浡琠潣牯楤慮整猠档摥汵湩桴湩灳捥楴湯潦湵瑩㐶㔶愠摮㘠⸶㸾ാ㸊㸾吠慨歮ⱳ㸾‾汁獩湯䈠潲湷㸾ാ㸊㸾㸾㸾ാ㸊‾ⴭഭ㸊吠楨浥楡慨敢湥挠敨正摥映牯瘠物獵獥戠⁹癁獡⁴湡楴楶畲潳瑦慷敲മ㸊栠瑴獰⼺眯睷愮慶瑳挮浯愯瑮癩物獵ാ㸊